So I rebuilt the Index with no change. I went to the Local Group Policy Editor and went to Computer Configuration > Administrative Templates > Windows Components > Search and everything here is 'Not configured' under the State column.
In Windows 10 Home Pro, I went to Settings > Search > Searching Windows and added all the folders I wanted excluded from search under Excluded Folders. I did a search and it is including the folders I excluded. Why is this happening? Thank you.