What Thurrott found
Thurrott calls the P16 a sleek portable workstation for creators, developers and AI enthusiasts who want an early start on local and hybrid AI. He says it is expensive and not aimed at mainstream buyers, but that it has quickly become the best of this first generation.
Pros he lists
- Thin and light for a 16-inch workstation
- A CNC design in Nano Black
- A tandem OLED display with effective anti-reflection
- Windows 11 on Arm
- A solid AAA gaming experience
- Dolby Atmos sound
Cons he lists
- Very high price
- It runs very hot under load, with very loud fans
- No unique Windows 11 features and no Copilot+ PC features
- Middling hybrid-work capabilities
- Below-average battery life
- An error-prone touchpad
On design, he says it is the thinnest RTX Spark machine he is reviewing this year. He puts it a full pound lighter than the HP OmniBook Ultra 16. He compares it with the Snapdragon X2 Elite Extreme-based Zenbook A16 he reviewed in June.
The chassis is a CNC unibody machined from a single piece of aluminum. Thurrott says it takes real pressure on the keyboard center to produce flex. He says the design helps it pass MIL-STD 810H durability tests, though he doesn't name the tests or give results.
Smaller notes:
- The keyboard floats in the center of the deck with no numeric keypad.
- The speaker grilles look tacked on rather than integrated.
- The Nano Black finish is only partly successful against smudges. The touchpad showed some smudging after a month.
- Buyers can also choose Neo White, which uses a sandblasting process.
The excerpt cuts off at the display section, which sits behind Thurrott's Premium paywall. The display, performance, battery and thermal details behind his scores aren't in the public text. The battery-life and noise verdicts therefore come without runtimes or decibel figures.
What ASUS says about the hardware
ASUS announced global pre-orders on October 7, 2026. The laptop is one of the first to use Nvidia's long-awaited SoC, which ASUS describes as a 20-core Grace CPU plus a Blackwell GPU with 6,144 CUDA cores.
Configurations run from 24GB RAM with a 512GB SSD to 128GB RAM with a 2TB SSD. Most use a 4K OLED, and one 64GB model has a 3K panel. ASUS lists operating systems as Windows 11 Home or Pro depending on the SKU.
The P16 specs ASUS lists:
- Up to 128GB of on-board LPDDR5X
- A 99.9Wh battery and a 140W USB-C adapter
- Three USB4 Type-C ports, one USB-A, HDMI 2.1 and an SD Express 7.0 reader
- A weight of 3.9 lb and a thickness of 0.51 to 0.63 inches
ASUS's launch release says the P14 and P16 start at about $2,599.99 and lists a P16 MSRP starting at $2,799.99. The release also says retail pricing is set by the retailer and can change. ASUS's own total-cost illustration uses a 128GB P16 at $6,000. That figure is a footnote assumption, not a confirmed retail price.
ASUS bundles local AI apps, including MuseTree and StoryCube. It also promotes partnerships with ComfyUI and Hermes Agent. All of these are vendor claims about capability, not test results.
How other reviewers compare
Thurrott's heat, noise and battery complaints don't match some other early reviews. That matters because they're the cons most likely to decide a purchase.
- Battery: Trusted Reviews cites nearly 14 hours of battery life. Windows Central reports less than 1% battery loss over 14 hours of overnight standby. PC Gamer calls battery life one of the real disappointments of the RTX Spark platform. Thurrott's "below average" verdict sits closer to PC Gamer's.
- Thermals: Windows Central praises the thermals. The Gadgeteer's sampled readings peaked at 56°C for the GPU and 63°C for the NPU during ArtCraft use. Those figures cover specific AI workloads and say nothing about noise. Thurrott's "very hot under load" claim concerns heavier sustained loads, so the two aren't directly comparable.
- Gaming: TechRadar puts gaming performance between RTX 5060 and RTX 5070 laptop GPUs. PC Gamer flags quality-control issues on its unit and the volume of anti-cheat services still to be added. Thurrott calls gaming solid, but anti-cheat support is worth checking before you buy for competitive titles.
- CPU and creative work: Notebookcheck says the CPU clearly beats the Ryzen AI 9 HX 370 in the previous ProArt P16. Its single-core Cinebench R20 score of 488 was well below several Intel and AMD rivals on that page. Results depend on the workload.
- Compatibility: Jon Peddie Research says every app it used had a native Arm64 version, so it didn't need to test Prism emulation. Your own app mix may not be so lucky.
Reviewers also tested different memory and display configurations. Notebookcheck's unit had 128GB of RAM with 64GB allocated as VRAM by default. Jon Peddie Research tested a 64GB model. Notebookcheck's default allocation was 64 GB of VRAM. Thurrott's exact configuration isn't stated in the public text. That may explain some of the differences.
The "no Copilot+ features" point
Thurrott lists the lack of unique Windows 11 features and of Copilot+ PC features as a con. This is a Windows 11 on Arm machine, so it runs Windows as an Arm device, but its AI pitch is local models, CUDA and ASUS apps rather than the Copilot+ feature set. The last ProArt P16 generation was marketed as a flagship Copilot+ PC, so the 2026 model's positioning is a real change. If your workflow depends on specific Copilot+ Windows features, confirm them on the exact SKU.
Who should consider it
It likely fits you if:
- You want local AI experimentation with a large unified memory pool.
- You want a thin 16-inch machine for creative work and some gaming.
- Your essential tools already run on Arm64 and CUDA.
Think twice if:
- You need quiet sustained performance.
- You need all-day unplugged use and can't tolerate variation between reviewers' battery results.
- You want a conventional gaming laptop, or you rely on x86-only drivers, plugins or anti-cheat software.
- You care about price. The 128GB models sit well above the entry price.
Buyer checklist
- Choose the SKU deliberately: memory, storage, display (3K or 4K) and Home versus Pro all vary.
- Check that your key apps, plugins, peripherals and games run on Windows on Arm. Prefer native Arm64 builds over emulation.
- Test your real workload for fan noise and sustained performance within the return window.
- Treat peak AI figures such as 1 petaflop FP4 as best-case numbers. They aren't a guarantee for your models.
- Check the retailer's current price and warranty, because MSRP can change.
Bottom line
Thurrott's review backs up what ASUS has built: a light, well-made RTX Spark laptop that currently leads the first wave of these machines. The conflicting reports on heat, noise and battery life show these may depend on the configuration and workload. Before you commit, test the specific model you plan to buy against your own work.
References
- ASUS ProArt P16 Review ⭐ - Thurrott.com Thurrott.com · 2026-11-17T17:52:52+00:00
- ASUS Launches RTX Spark Laptop and Pre-Order asus.com
- I’ve tested the Asus ProArt P16 RTX Spark for two weeks and its powerful Nvidia chip has blown me away with its awesome AI, gaming and creative performance — but its high price still makes it a tough sell techradar.com