The short version
PowerToys is free and open source. Microsoft's documentation describes it as a set of utilities that adds customization options Windows doesn't offer out of the box. Shah's argument is that fewer background apps means a tidier system.
That's a reasonable instinct, but note what it leaves out. Several of these replacements only work while PowerToys itself is running. You're consolidating, not eliminating background processes. The author also admits two of the swaps lose something: Flow Launcher has a plugin edge, and Auto Dark Mode has extras he didn't need.
1. Flow Launcher → Command Palette
Command Palette opens with Win+Alt+Space by default. Microsoft's overview page gives that default shortcut, and you can change it in settings. Microsoft's documentation says Command Palette has to be enabled and running in the background.
The documented capabilities go well past app launching:
- Running commands, searching files and folders, and searching the web
- A calculator that accepts expressions like 23*47 and sqrt(256)
- Windows Settings navigation, clipboard history, window switching and WinGet app search
- Starting, stopping and restarting Windows services
- Windows Terminal profiles and Registry lookups
- System performance metrics
It's also extensible. Microsoft says you can browse, install, update and uninstall community extensions from a built-in Extension Gallery. So the idea that it's closed to plugins doesn't hold. Whether the extension catalog matches Flow Launcher's plugin ecosystem is a separate question. The evidence doesn't answer it, and Shah himself gives Flow Launcher a slight edge there. If you rely on a specific Flow Launcher plugin, check that an equivalent exists before you uninstall.
2. WindowSill → Command Palette Dock
The Dock is an optional toolbar inside Command Palette. Microsoft's documentation says it needs Command Palette enabled and running. You turn it on with the Enable Dock toggle in Command Palette settings.
Shah describes it as a second taskbar. Microsoft's documentation adds more detail than his article does:
- Position: Left, Top (the default), Right or Bottom.
- Auto-hide: Available. If the taskbar or another app already auto-hides on that edge, the Dock falls back to pinned mode.
- Layout: Start, Center and End regions. By default the End region holds Performance Monitor, Network Speed and Date/Time bands.
- Metrics: Performance Monitor covers CPU, memory, network usage and speed, disk, GPU and battery. The Battery band only appears on devices that have a battery.
- Multi-monitor: Each display gets its own Dock and its own set of pinned bands.
- Keyboard access: Win+Alt+J moves focus to the Dock.
Shah calls the Dock a preview feature. Microsoft's current documentation doesn't label it that way, so treat his status note as dated or at least unconfirmed. His comparison also holds only for the functions he lists. Nothing here shows the Dock matches WindowSill's AI tools or its other features.
One more caution comes from a WindowsForum report on PowerToys 0.98. It put the Dock's memory use at roughly 200 MB to 260 MB of RAM at launch. That's a community-reported figure for an earlier build, not a benchmark of current versions. It does show why "one less app" isn't automatically "less memory." Measure it yourself in Task Manager.
3. Auto Dark Mode → Light Switch
Light Switch changes Windows between light and dark themes on a schedule. Microsoft documents three schedule modes:
- Sunset to sunrise
- Fixed hours
- Follow Night Light, which syncs with the Windows Night Light schedule
Sunset-to-sunrise mode needs location services enabled and synced, unless you enter coordinates manually. You can also set a theme-toggle shortcut and choose whether dark mode applies to the system UI, to supported apps, or to both. The documentation also describes a command-line tool that can check or switch the theme from scripts.
Shah says Auto Dark Mode can switch on battery power and can delay the switch while you're gaming or working on a document. The Light Switch documentation doesn't list either option, so don't assume Light Switch has them. If you want those behaviors, keep Auto Dark Mode.
4. Caffeine → Awake
Awake keeps a PC from sleeping without touching your power plan. Microsoft's modes are:
- Keep awake indefinitely
- Keep awake for a time interval
- Keep awake until a set date and time
- Keep using the selected power plan, which requests nothing special
There's a caveat that matters for Shah's example of a long download or a presentation. Microsoft says Awake is active only while you're signed in and it is enabled. When the lock screen appears, it doesn't keep the display on, so Windows can turn the display off according to your power plan. A separate Keep screen on switch keeps displays active, but only while the PC is unlocked.
Microsoft also says Awake is meant for use at your computer or in private environments. For persistent needs, especially when you step away in a shared space, it recommends setting the Windows power plan directly and locking the machine. That is sensible security advice, not just a technicality.
A recent PowerToys 0.103 dev preview adds an option to let the screen turn off while locked. Turning it off keeps the Keep screen on request active during lock. The release notes also warn that Modern Standby systems may still turn the display off. That's a preview build, so don't count on it in the stable release yet.
5. AutoHotkey → Keyboard Manager
This is the swap with the biggest caveat. Shah only used AutoHotkey for remapping, and for that job Keyboard Manager is simpler. It handles:
- Key-to-key and shortcut-to-shortcut remaps
- Remaps scoped to a specific app, using the process name (for example msedge, not "Microsoft Edge")
- Mapping a key or shortcut to a text string
- Shortcuts that launch an app or open a URI
Microsoft says new installations from PowerToys 0.100 open the redesigned WinUI 3 editor by default. You can toggle back to the legacy editor.
The limits Microsoft documents are worth knowing:
- Win+L and Ctrl+Alt+Del can't be remapped.
- Keyboard Manager doesn't work on password screens, including sign-in.
- Remaps stop if PowerToys isn't running.
- Remapping won't work against an elevated app unless PowerToys runs as administrator.
- Microsoft advises against using it while gaming, because key interception can affect frame rate.
If your AutoHotkey scripts do more than remap keys, such as launching and arranging apps at startup, this isn't a replacement. Shah is explicit that he used it only for remapping.
6. QuickLook → Peek
Peek is the cleanest replacement. Microsoft's documentation says to select a file in File Explorer and press the activation shortcut, which defaults to Space. Space became the default in PowerToys 0.95. Older guides say Ctrl+Space. Plenty of articles still carry that older shortcut, which is probably why you may find conflicting instructions online.
Documented settings include:
- A custom activation shortcut
- Keeping the preview window always on top
- Closing it automatically when it loses focus
- A tooltip showing filename, type, date modified and size
Microsoft documents previews for images, Office documents, videos, web pages, Markdown, text and developer files. Peek can also be launched from the command line with PowerToys.Peek.UI.exe and a file path. Pressing Space does nothing in a text field or rename box, where it behaves as a normal space.
The evidence doesn't establish that Peek supports every file type QuickLook does, or that it matches QuickLook's speed. Test your own file types first.
Which swaps are safe?
| Old app | PowerToys equivalent | Safe if you only need | Keep the old app if you need |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flow Launcher | Command Palette | Launching, commands, calculations, services, Registry lookups | Specific Flow Launcher plugins |
| WindowSill | Command Palette Dock | System stats, clock, battery, pinned commands | AI tools or other WindowSill features |
| Auto Dark Mode | Light Switch | Sunset or fixed-hour theme switching | Battery-triggered switching or gaming delays (per Shah) |
| Caffeine | Awake | Timed or indefinite keep-awake while signed in | Display on while locked |
| AutoHotkey | Keyboard Manager | Key and shortcut remapping | Scripting and automation |
| QuickLook | Peek | Spacebar previews of common file types | Specific file formats Peek can't preview |
How to try it without committing
- Install PowerToys and enable only the utility you want to test.
- Leave the old app installed but disabled, rather than uninstalling it straight away.
- Use the PowerToys version for a week of real work.
- Check for conflicts. Command Palette's Win+Alt+Space and Peek's Space are defaults you can change.
- Uninstall the old app only once you haven't missed it.
Bottom line
Shah's experience is real, and for casual users the case for PowerToys is strong. Awake and Peek are close to drop-in replacements, with the lock-screen limit on Awake as the main caveat. Light Switch and Keyboard Manager cover the common cases but are narrower than the dedicated tools. Command Palette and the Dock are the most ambitious swaps, and the ones where your own dependence on plugins or extras decides it. Nothing here shows PowerToys is lighter on resources than the apps it replaces. That's the part to check yourself.
References
- I uninstalled 6 apps after realizing what this free Microsoft app could do - MakeUseOf MakeUseOf · 2026-11-17T16:00:17+00:00
- PowerToys Command Palette Utility for Windows | Microsoft Learn learn.microsoft.com
- Microsoft PowerToys - Windows Utilities for Power Users | Microsoft Learn learn.microsoft.com