A home network setup with wired routers and a glowing security shield linking Wi-Fi devices throughout the house.
A DIY router is a PC, mini PC or single-board computer running router and firewall software. The idea is back in the conversation after a BGR piece by Joel Loynds. It points to router bans and a steady stream of router vulnerabilities as reasons to take control of your own gear. The idea is appealing. The catch is that you become the vendor, the patch manager and the help desk.

This piece covers what a DIY router is, what it can and can't fix, what hardware to look for, how ISP gateways complicate things, and what maintenance you're signing up for.

A home network setup with wired routers and a glowing security shield linking Wi-Fi devices throughout the house. What "DIY router" actually means​

BGR describes DIY routers as running on specialized operating systems that turn an ordinary PC into a full router for your network. The project can get technical. It also says the owner is entirely responsible for maintenance afterward.

Two clarifications help:

  • A router computer is not a Wi-Fi upgrade. A PC running router software handles routing, firewalling and the wired connection. Wi-Fi coverage usually still depends on access points, and where you place them matters more than how powerful the router is. BGR notes these builds can double as wireless access points. It also says that for that role, modifying an older router may be a better fit.
  • DIY is a flexibility play. BGR says ISP-supplied routers are often cheap and underpowered. It argues that a better inbound connection handler may give you faster speeds. That is the author's position, not a measured benchmark, so treat the speed gain as potential rather than guaranteed.

BGR also says you don't need cutting-edge hardware. It mentions a recent Gamers Nexus video where the team used an Intel 4th-generation chip with 32 GB of DDR3 RAM. The article calls that overkill, but the exposed PCIe slots left room for expansion. Mini PCs, Raspberry Pi boards and the LattePanda Mu are also named as options.

Hardware: minimums are not a shopping list​

Take pfSense as one example. Netgate's documentation lists the minimum for hardware it doesn't sell. That is a 64-bit amd64 (x86-64) compatible CPU, 1 GB or more of RAM, and a disk of 8 GB or larger. You also need one or more compatible network cards and bootable USB or optical media for installation. Netgate itself adds that the minimums are not suitable for all environments.

Two practical points follow:

  • Architecture matters. The requirements are for 64-bit x86. One third-party guide notes that a requirement for an amd64 box rules out a whole shelf of otherwise attractive ARM hardware. That includes Raspberry Pi-style boards for pfSense CE. Other router software supports different hardware, so check each project's own list.
  • Features drive the sizing. Netgate's sizing guidance says required throughput and enabled features are the main factors. It also says estimating throughput for third-party hardware is difficult and inaccurate.

Some details from that sizing guidance are worth knowing:

  • Network card choice matters a lot. Inexpensive, low-end cards use much more CPU than better cards such as Intel. A faster CPU paired with a poor card won't raise throughput proportionally.
  • Firewall states use RAM. Each state takes roughly 1 KB, so 1,000,000 states is about 1 GB. The operating system and other services need at least 175-256 MB on top of that.
  • VPN is CPU-heavy. Encryption and decryption are CPU-intensive. Netgate says hardware acceleration such as AES-NI greatly helps VPN throughput.
  • Intrusion detection is hungry. Snort and Suricata are packages for network intrusion detection. Netgate says 1 GB of RAM should be considered a minimum for them, and some configurations need 2 GB or more. That is in addition to the operating system, firewall states and other packages.

The practical lesson is to size for what you plan to run, not for what it takes to boot. Plan on at least two network ports, one for WAN and one for LAN. Intel NICs are widely recommended in community guidance.

OpenWrt is another route, mainly for supported consumer router hardware. Check the project's supported-device table for your exact model and hardware version before flashing. A mismatch can leave a device unusable.

The ISP modem problem​

BGR warns that some ISPs still require you to use their modem to get service. If your router and modem are one box, you may need a separate modem. You can also ask whether bridge mode or IP passthrough is available. BGR's advice is to confirm your router is supported before you start.

Verizon's support page is a concrete example, not a universal recipe. On the Verizon Internet Gateway it works like this:

  • IP passthrough lets you connect your own router or switch to the gateway.
  • Turning it on switches off all Wi-Fi radios.
  • Passthrough works on the LAN2 Ethernet port on the bottom of the gateway.
  • Internet access is no longer available through Wi-Fi or the LAN1 port.
  • The network-assigned IP address is handed to the device on LAN2.

Verizon's steps are:

  1. Open the router admin page and click Advanced.
  2. Go to Network Settings, then Network Connections.
  3. Click Network (Home/Office), then Settings.
  4. In the Bridge section, tick the IP Passthrough checkbox and click Save Changes.
  5. Wait one to two minutes for the reboot, until the LED is solid white.
  6. Plug your own router or switch into LAN2.

To undo it, connect a device to LAN1, sign in to the admin interface, and repeat the steps to uncheck the box. If you use another provider or gateway, follow that provider's documentation. Menu names and port roles vary.

Maintenance is the real price​

BGR's sharpest warning is about upkeep. It says that if you don't keep up with updates or follow potential issues, your network could become a critical failure point. The article also claims LLMs now act like an electron microscope for finding backdoors, a point made as opinion without supporting data in the piece.

Netgate's records show what the workload looks like in practice. Its advisory list includes pfSense advisories dated in 2026, including a batch announced on August 13 and another on September 15. Most are tagged to the web GUI. That doesn't mean every advisory hits every install. It does show firewall software gets advisories you have to read and match to your version.

Netgate's upgrade guide gives a sense of the routine:

  • Netgate releases new versions periodically with features, bug fixes and other changes.
  • Updates are checked under System > Update. Packages are managed separately.
  • Netgate says its support team only officially assists with the most recent stable releases.
  • The most common upgrade problems are hardware-specific regressions between FreeBSD versions. These are uncommon.
  • Firewalls must be connected to the internet to update.
  • The guide lists backups and a backup plan as pre-upgrade tasks.

This is where a DIY router can turn against you. A consumer router sometimes updates itself. Your build only updates when you do it.

A quick decision test​

Go DIY if you can answer yes to all of these:

  1. Hardware support: Does the software support your exact hardware and network interfaces?
  2. Capacity: Is there enough headroom for your internet speed and for VPN or intrusion detection?
  3. ISP rules: Does your provider allow your setup, and do they document bridge mode or passthrough for your gateway?
  4. Ownership: Will someone in the household monitor advisories and apply updates?
  5. Fallback: Can you keep your old router in a drawer until the new one works?

If the answer to any of these is no, a good off-the-shelf router or a mesh system is likely the saner choice. If your real problem is a dead zone in the back bedroom, access points will do more for you than a repurposed PC.

Bottom line​

A DIY router suits tinkerers who value control and don't mind reading documentation. It is not a guaranteed fix for slow internet or weak Wi-Fi, and the build is only the start of the commitment. Check hardware and ISP compatibility before you spend money, and choose a software platform you are prepared to keep patched. Remember that this advice rests on vendor documentation and one editorial piece. It isn't based on head-to-head speed or cost tests.

 

References

  1. Is A DIY Router Right For You? Here's What You Need To Know bgr.com 2026-11-16T14:47:00+00:00
  2. Hardware Sizing Guidance | pfSense Documentation docs.netgate.com
  3. Minimum Hardware Requirements | pfSense Documentation docs.netgate.com