His advice holds up. Government guidance and vendor security advisories going back to 2011 support it. It also needs a few caveats: which WPS method is the real problem, what the toggle can and can't fix, and how to tell whether the change worked.
What WPS actually does
WPS is a shortcut. It lets a device join your Wi-Fi without you typing the network password. That's handy for printers, smart TVs, speakers and range extenders, where entering a 24-character password with a remote is a slow punishment.
As Shah describes it, WPS usually comes in two forms:
- Push-button. You press the WPS button on the router, which opens a short pairing window, then start WPS on the client device. Shah says the window lasts about two minutes on his hardware. Treat that as typical rather than a rule, because timing varies by vendor.
- PIN. You enter an eight-digit code, often printed on the router's label, instead of the Wi-Fi password.
The two modes carry very different risks.
Section summary: WPS trades security for convenience. The PIN mode is where that trade goes badly wrong.
The 2011 flaw that never went away
Researcher Stefan Viehböck disclosed the problem in December 2011, and CERT/CC published it as Vulnerability Note VU#723755 (CVE-2011-5053). A design flaw in the WPS specification for PIN authentication significantly reduces the time required to brute force the entire PIN because it allows an attacker to know when the first half of the 8 digit PIN is correct.
The math is where it gets ugly. An eight-digit PIN looks like 100 million possible codes. According to CERT/CC, though, the router's failure messages reveal whether the first half was right, and the last digit is only a checksum. That cuts the search to 10⁴ + 10³, or 11,000 guesses. CERT/CC also noted that the lack of a proper lock out policy after a certain number of failed attempts to guess the PIN on many wireless routers makes this brute force attack that much more feasible.
Cisco's advisory from January 2012 said the same thing in more detail: a weakness in the protocol affects all APs that have a static PIN, and may allow an unauthenticated, remote attacker to use brute force calculations to determine the AP's PIN in a short amount of time. Cisco also credited the discovery to Stefan Viehbock and Craig Heffner, and its own fix was blunt: "It is our recommendation to disable the WPS feature to prevent exploitation of this vulnerability."
According to CERT/CC, a successful attacker within wireless range could recover the Wi-Fi password, change the access point's configuration, or knock it offline. CERT/CC also reported that some routers crashed under the guessing attack and needed a reboot.
Lockouts slow attackers down but don't stop them
Shah notes that newer routers try to defend themselves by locking out repeated failed PIN attempts. The old advisories show how limited that protection is:
| Vendor example (2011–2012) | Lockout behavior | Reported effect |
|---|---|---|
| Cisco (models in its advisory) | 60 seconds after 3 failures | Raised attack time from a few hours to at most several days |
| Technicolor (per CERT/CC vendor note) | 5 minutes after 5 retries | Vendor's own test: about 189 hours to try every PIN |
These figures come from specific products and aren't universal. The pattern still matters: a lockout turns an afternoon project into a week-long one. For a determined neighbor with a laptop and patience, that's a speed bump.
Then there's Pixie Dust
The PIN problem got worse after 2011. According to the security reference site The Hacker Recipes, in 2014, Dominique Bongard identified a security vulnerability he dubbed "Pixie Dust". That attack goes after weak random-number generation in some vendors' WPS implementations, and once the secret values are known, the PIN can be retrieved in a matter of minutes. The same source names two main tools now available for conducting this attack: Reaver (C) and Bully (C). When Shah says there are "dedicated tools" for this, that is what he means.
Section summary: The WPS PIN weakness is old, well documented and easy to automate. Lockouts reduce the risk without removing it.
Is the push button safe, then?
It's safer, though it still carries some risk. DrayTek's UK security advisory draws the line clearly: the 2011 flaw affects the router PIN method. The company says client-PIN and physical-button WPS aren't affected by that particular bug. SQ Magazine reports that NETGEAR takes a similar position, recommending that customers disable the WPS PIN because only the WPS PIN connection method is vulnerable to brute-force attacks, while Zyxel tells users not to use the WPS PIN Configuration method.
Shah's concern about the button is a different, smaller one. During the pairing window, the router accepts any WPS device in range, not only yours. In a detached house that barely matters. In a packed apartment block it's a short window worth thinking about. As SQ Magazine puts it, turning the router PIN off helps reduce the risk of a brute-force attack, and turning the whole feature off also removes the button window.
What the authorities recommend
This isn't just one writer's preference:
- US Federal Trade Commission: its home Wi-Fi guidance tells consumers to turn off WPS, remote management and UPnP. Its reasoning is that convenience features can weaken a network's security.
- Canadian Centre for Cyber Security: its router best-practices guide (ITSAP.80.019) lists disabling WPS as a basic measure, warning that an attacker within range can brute-force the PIN.
- CISA: SQ Magazine reports that the US agency's checklist says simply: Disable Wi-Fi Protected Setup (WPS).
Some newer hardware has already dropped the feature. SQ Magazine reports that eero and Google leave it out of their routers, citing security. That fits Shah's point that many modern mesh systems ship without WPS.
How to turn WPS off
Shah's path was Local Network > WLAN > WPS. That's his router only. Labels vary a lot between manufacturers, firmware versions and ISP-supplied gateways, so use these general steps:
- Sign in to the router's admin page. Use the address and credentials from the label, the manual or your ISP's instructions. If you still have the default admin password, change it while you're there.
- Find the WPS setting. It's usually under Wireless, WLAN, Wi-Fi or Advanced/Security. CERT/CC warns that depending on the vendor, this may be labeled as external registrar, router PIN, or WiFi Protected Setup.
- Disable the PIN method at minimum. If you see separate PIN and push-button controls, switch off the router PIN or external registrar option first. Disabling WPS entirely is the cleaner choice.
- Save or apply the change. Some interfaces discard edits if you navigate away without clicking Apply.
- Check that it stuck. Reload the settings page, and look again after a reboot or firmware update.
- Do it on every access point. Mesh nodes, range extenders and a separate ISP gateway may each have their own WPS settings.
What success looks like: the admin page shows WPS or the router PIN as disabled after a refresh and after a reboot. Shah also mentions a blinking LED during push-button pairing on his router. The WPS LED behaves differently from one model to the next, though, so don't treat it as proof either way.
Common sticking points
- No WPS option at all: your router may not support WPS. That's the best outcome, and there's nothing to do.
- The setting is greyed out or missing on an ISP gateway: the provider may control it. Ask them directly whether WPS, especially the router PIN, is enabled.
- WPS can't be disabled: this does happen. Cisco's 2012 advisory listed some affected products that offered no permanent off switch. Check for a firmware update. If there isn't one, start budgeting for a replacement.
- A device has no other way to connect: turn WPS on, pair the device, then turn it off again. Shah calls this the best of both worlds, and it's a sensible compromise.
The newer caveat: some WPS bugs ignore the toggle
Turning WPS off fixes the 2011 PIN design flaw on routers where the toggle really disables it. It may not fix every WPS-related bug.
In late October 2026, TechRadar reported on "WPSplinter," a flaw researcher Quentin Kaiser says he found in Broadcom's legacy WPS Monitor code. Kaiser says it can be reached over the air before any pairing happens. According to his documentation, switching WPS off in the router interface may not remove the vulnerable parser. TechRadar's report draws mainly on Kaiser's account and says Broadcom had issued no public advisory or CVE. On affected equipment, Kaiser's guidance is a firmware update from the ISP or router maker, or replacing the hardware outright.
This is a separate implementation bug, not the 2011 PIN flaw. It is a reminder that a settings toggle doesn't replace patching.
Analysis: a good habit, if you keep it in proportion
Shah's headline says he "closed a security hole," and for the PIN attack on a router where the setting works, that's fair. Three things the headline leaves out:
- Disabling WPS is one item on a list. The FTC and the Canadian Centre for Cyber Security put it alongside WPA2 or WPA3 encryption, unique admin and Wi-Fi passwords, firmware updates and a guest network. If your router still runs WEP and the admin password is "admin," WPS is the least of your problems.
- The threat comes from people nearby, not the whole internet. Attackers need to be within radio range. Flats, offices and shared buildings carry more risk than a farmhouse.
- Old routers are the real worry. Hardware without lockouts, without updates, and without a working WPS off switch is where these attacks succeed most easily.
Is it worth the effort? It takes about two minutes, you can easily undo it, and nobody connects a new printer every day. Few router changes give you more protection for less work.
Bottom line: turn off WPS, or at least the router PIN. Then check your encryption settings and update your firmware. The PIN flaw has been public since 2011, and some routers still have it switched on.
References
- I changed one router setting and closed a security hole I didn't know existed MakeUseOf · 2026-11-16T14:30:17+00:00
- Security Advisory : WPS Router Pincode Exploit draytek.co.uk
- VU#723755 - WiFi Protected Setup (WPS) PIN brute force vulnerability kb.cert.org