What Thurrott argued
Thurrott says Microsoft has had eras of "Apple envy," but that this has mostly faded over the past decade or two, apart from certain groups inside the company. In his telling, the two companies now pursue different core strategies:
- Microsoft is a cloud and AI infrastructure company that dominates the corporate market.
- Apple is a personal-computing hardware company focused on individuals.
- Moving from the cloud into AI infrastructure is, strategically, "too big of an opportunity to miss."
He also says Microsoft missed the web and mobile waves after it dropped open, web-based technologies in Windows and went back to proprietary ones. He adds that its client group wasted time on Cortana and Windows Mixed Reality/HoloLens, which never became waves of their own. His text, as published, cuts off mid-thought while describing Windows and Apple's device positions. The rest sits behind a Premium paywall, so I won't attribute a conclusion to him.
The broader argument is a historical interpretation, not a measured finding.
The spending claim, checked against the numbers
Thurrott voices "deep concerns" about what he calls dramatic overspending on AI infrastructure. He also alleges "financial shenanigans" meant to hide it. The first part is easy to ground. The second is an accusation his post doesn't back with documents, and I found nothing in the evidence that confirms it.
Microsoft's fiscal 2026 annual report gives the scale:
- Microsoft reported $45.2 billion in capital expenditures, including assets acquired under finance leases, for the quarter ended September 30, 2026. That quarter was the first of fiscal 2027.
- Capital spending has stayed elevated across five quarters: $34.9 billion, $37.5 billion, $31.9 billion, $41.0 billion, then $45.2 billion.
- CFO Amy Hood expects fiscal second-quarter capital expenditures to exceed $50 billion, bringing projected calendar-year spending to approximately $170 billion.
- On the call, Microsoft said roughly three quarters of capex went to short-lived assets, primarily CPUs and GPUs, including higher memory and storage costs.
The annual report adds that cash used in investing rose to $139.5 billion in fiscal 2026. Microsoft attributes that mainly to a $51.4 billion increase in additions to property and equipment. These are company-reported figures.
Capex, cash and leases are different measures
Much of the "hidden" suspicion comes from the fact that Microsoft reports several overlapping numbers. They are not interchangeable:
| Measure | Q1 FY2027 figure | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Capital expenditures (including finance leases) | $45.2 billion | Headline spend, including leased assets |
| Finance leases | $7.4 billion | Full principal recognized in capex when the lease begins |
| Cash paid for property and equipment | $39.4 billion | Actual cash out the door in the quarter |
| Free cash flow | $18.6 billion | Cash flow after the higher spending |
Microsoft's call put finance leases at $7.4 billion this quarter. The company also noted that it recognizes the full principal value of finance leases in capex when the lease commences. One outside tally says cash paid for property and equipment was $39.4 billion, roughly double the $19.4 billion paid a year earlier. That doubling arguably says more about the real pace of spending than the capex headline does.
A real accounting change, and what it does and doesn't show
Skeptics who want ammunition will find a candidate. Calcalist reported that Microsoft's guidance followed an accounting change that extends the depreciation period for long-term data center leases from 15 years to 25 years. The same report says Microsoft said reported capital expenditures will decline because it extended the accounting life of long-term data center leases. It adds that the company stressed the change does not reflect lower investment, and that underlying AI infrastructure spending plans remain unchanged.
Two readings are fair:
- Critic's reading: Accounting choices can make costs look smaller or later, and investors are right to read the footnotes closely.
- Defender's reading: The change was publicly disclosed, and the spending still appears in capex, cash flow and balance-sheet figures.
Disclosed accounting judgment is not the same as concealment. Whether the 25-year life is appropriate is a legitimate question for auditors and analysts. Nothing in the evidence here shows wrongdoing.
Is the bet paying off?
Microsoft's own numbers support Thurrott's "makes sense strategically" point, though they don't prove the returns will be adequate. The annual report cites fiscal year 2026 revenue of $331.8 billion, up 18 percent, and Azure passing $100 billion for the first time. It also reports Microsoft 365 Copilot above 30 million paid seats. In the latest quarter, Microsoft disclosed Azure revenue in dollars for the first time, at $33.17 billion. Azure grew 48%, and the company says demand still exceeds supply.
There are costs on the other side:
- Microsoft's annual report warns that these investments will continue to increase operating costs and may decrease operating margins. A third-party summary notes gross margin slipped from 69.0% to 67.8% year over year.
- CNBC reported that Microsoft said it would cut 4,800 jobs and then offered buyouts to up to 60,000 employees, as it balances a costly AI build-out with capital efficiency.
- On the call, Microsoft said weaker sales execution in M365 E3 and standalone SKUs partly offset its cloud growth. It also guided Windows OEM and Devices revenue to decline in the mid-thirties next quarter. That fits Thurrott's point that consumer-facing Windows is not the engine.
For IT admins, the Copilot seat count and Windows OEM guidance suggest the same thing. Microsoft's money and attention are flowing to Azure, Foundry and Copilot subscriptions, not to the PC.
The Apple half of the comparison
Thurrott's lead item concerns a report that Apple is building an AI agent for computer and app tasks. Bloomberg's Mark Gurman reported on November 19 that Apple is developing its own autonomous AI agent. The reporting rests on job listings describing a system that would write code, browse the web, control apps and navigate devices. Bloomberg says development remains in the early stages, and that Apple has eyed an introduction as soon as the end of next year. That is a reported possibility, not an announced launch, and Apple didn't respond to Bloomberg's request for comment.
Bloomberg also says that in the macOS 27.3 beta, Apple added warning screens for third-party agents seeking control of a Mac. According to the report, enabling ChatGPT's computer-use support now takes 14 steps instead of four. Some AI companies see that as slowing competitors, while Apple frames it as customer protection. Windows admins will recognize the debate. Agent permissions, sandboxing and auditing are the same problems Microsoft is working on with Copilot and tools like Purview, which Microsoft says has audited more than 7.6 billion agent activities.
The Siri jab
Thurrott's aside that Siri "can't pull a phone number out of a screenshot" is a joke, not a test. Apple documents Visual Intelligence as able to recognize contact details such as phone numbers and email addresses in text. Apple's iOS 27 pages also describe "Siri AI (Beta)" features that work with on-screen content. Those features come with device, language and regional limits, including a requirement for iPhone 15 Pro or later. Whether any given request works on a given phone is a separate question.
Bottom line
- Apple envy: Thurrott's view is that it has largely faded, and the financial evidence fits that. Microsoft's growth is tied to enterprise cloud, not to imitating Apple's hardware.
- Overspending: The scale is real and documented. Whether the returns justify it is an open judgment call.
- "Shenanigans": Thurrott's accusation is unsupported by the evidence here. The 15-to-25-year lease depreciation change is public and open to debate. It is not proof of hiding anything.
- Apple's agent: It is a reported early-stage effort, so it is too soon to compare it with shipping Microsoft products.
The question under the Q&A is whether Microsoft's AI spending produces durable returns before the build-out outruns demand. It's a better question than whether Microsoft is copying Apple.
References
- Ask Paul: November 20 ⭐ - Thurrott.com Thurrott.com · 2026-11-20T15:34:35+00:00
- Siri AI: Learn about what’s on your iPhone screen - Apple Support support.apple.com
- Use visual intelligence on iPhone - Apple Support support.apple.com