A gamer sits before a screen of games, backed by server racks, a security shield, and official-looking paperwork.
A Pennsylvania state senator wants to turn "server shutdown" from a quiet line in a publisher's end-of-life notice into a consumer-protection obligation. Sen. John Kane's proposed Protect Our Games Act would require video game makers to give buyers advance warning before they cut off a digital game. Publishers would also have to offer a way to keep playing it or pay back part of the purchase price.

Before anyone celebrates or starts drafting angry letters to publishers, be clear about what this is. It is a proposal. It is not a law, and on the evidence available it has not yet been formally introduced as a bill.

What Kane is actually proposing​

According to Harrisburg station WHP (Local 21 News), Sen. John Kane (D) helped circulate a memo on Sept. 18 seeking support for the proposed Protect Our Games Act. In Pennsylvania, a co-sponsorship memo is how a legislator asks colleagues to sign on before a bill is filed. Kane's own memo makes the timing clear: "At the request of constituents, I will soon introduce the Protect Our Games Act to address this consumer protection issue." The Senate's memo page still said the document had not been submitted for introduction when it was captured on September 28.

Tom's Hardware, which brought the story to a wider tech audience, described Kane as having "filed a bill." That goes a little further than the official record supports right now.

The memo describes three main obligations:

  • 60 days' notice. Under the proposal, video game manufacturers would be required to give customers at least 60 days' notice before ending access to the game or changing its features. The "changing its features" part matters. It isn't only about full shutdowns.
  • At least one remedy. The company would have to give the buyer one or more of these: the ability to play offline, a patch that lets the game keep working online without the company's own servers, or a refund.
  • A refund formula with a floor. The refund would equal the highest price the game was offered at during the 12 months before the operator stops supporting its "ordinary use." The refund amount cannot fall below 25% of the initial sale price of the game.

Enforcement would sit with state and local prosecutors: The Protect Our Games Act will be enforced by the PA Attorney General and District Attorneys. The memo doesn't mention a private right to sue, so the draft doesn't appear to give individual gamers a way to take publishers to court themselves.

The "one or more" catch​

Some coverage has blurred this point. Nexstar's WHTM, for example, reported that the developer will also have to allow the consumer to play the game while offline, and the developer would have to give a refund to players, which makes it sound as if every remedy is required. The memo says the company must provide one or more of the options. A publisher could probably meet its obligation by choosing only the refund, which is likely the cheapest option for a game that has been heavily discounted. The memo doesn't say who picks the remedy, but the wording points to the company, not the player.

Section summary: The draft gives buyers notice, a remedy chosen from a menu, and a refund of at least 25%. It does not guarantee that every game stays playable forever.

Who gets a pass​

The memo lists three exemptions, and they matter a lot in practice:

  1. Subscription access. Any service that sells access to a game only for as long as the subscription lasts is exempt.
  2. Free games, with a catch. Games offered at no cost are exempt unless the person has made purchases or invested money to upgrade characters or unlock features within the game. That condition could pull many free-to-play live-service games back into scope, depending on how the final text is written.
  3. Games that can't be revoked. A game is exempt if the seller can't revoke access after purchase, including a game offered at purchase for permanent offline download to external storage that runs without an internet connection.

My analysis, not the memo's: For Windows and Xbox players, the subscription exemption looks as if it would cover libraries accessed through services like Game Pass. Titles bought outright from digital storefronts are the clearer target. The third exemption also reads like an incentive: a publisher that sells DRM-free, offline-installable copies could avoid the law's obligations entirely. That's a meaningful nudge, and it may be the most consequential idea in the proposal.

The Sony spark and the Xbox angle​

Kane's memo points directly at Sony. In a July 1, 2026 PlayStation Blog post, Sony Interactive Entertainment said physical disc production for all new games on PlayStation consoles would stop starting in January 2028. After that, new games will be sold only in digital formats, through the PlayStation Store and at retailers. Sony also said the change doesn't affect games already released on disc, or due on disc, before that date. So the 2028 cutoff covers new releases. It is not a recall of existing discs.

Still, the memo argues that PlayStation access could then depend on licensing terms that companies can change at will. According to WHP, this would potentially cause video game access to be subject to licensing agreements that can be changed at any time for any reason, according to the memo.

Microsoft's ecosystem is part of the same trend. WHTM noted that Xbox introduced a feature last month where players can download the digital version of a game if they have the disc, and while this isn't them stopping the production of actual discs, it shows the direction the trend is going. The same report adds that Grand Theft Auto VI will not have a physical disc, and if players buy the video game's case, it will come with just a code.

The memo covers "video game manufacturers" and "digital games" in general, not just consoles. PC games bought through a launcher that checks in with a license server look as if they'd be in scope, subject to whatever the final text says.

California got here first, and its path is a warning​

This is where the verifiable record adds something the headline misses. Pennsylvania's proposal isn't just similar to California's. It uses the same name and much of the same design.

California's Assembly Bill 1921 is also called the Protect Our Games Act. BillTrack50 summarizes it as a bill that aims to ensure consumers can continue to "ordinarily use" digital games they purchase, meaning they can access the core features as advertised. The "ordinary use" wording appears in Kane's memo too. So do California's exemptions, which, according to an analysis by law firm Segev LLP, cover subscription services, free-to-play titles, and games that allow permanent offline download.

Tom's Hardware said California's version "has already passed a State Assembly vote" but still has far to go. Segev's July analysis gives a more detailed status: the bill passed the California State Assembly but failed to advance out of its second Senate committee, though the committee granted reconsideration, leaving a procedural route to bring it back. In plain terms, it stalled but isn't completely dead.

California's bill also has a limit that readers should watch for in Pennsylvania: only digital games first made available, or re-released, for purchase on or after January 1, 2028 are covered. Kane's memo mentions no such cutoff. If the Pennsylvania bill ends up copying California's, it wouldn't protect the digital library you already own.

Pennsylvania (Kane memo)California AB 1921
StatusCo-sponsorship memo; not yet formally introducedPassed Assembly; stalled in Senate committee with reconsideration granted
Core test"Ordinary use" of a digital game"Ordinary use" of a digital game
ExemptionsSubscriptions, free games without purchases, games that can't be revokedSubscriptions, free-to-play, games with permanent offline download
Start dateNot specified in memoGames first sold or re-released on/after Jan. 1, 2028

The wider Stop Killing Games movement, which pushes for exactly these kinds of end-of-life protections, hasn't produced a law anywhere yet. Tom's Hardware reports that EU officials declined to pursue new legislation in response to it.

Section summary: Pennsylvania is borrowing a template that has already stalled once. The details, especially any start date, will decide whether it helps existing libraries at all.

The open questions​

A co-sponsorship memo is a sales pitch, not a statute. It leaves several practical questions unanswered:

  • What counts as a qualifying patch? Offering "online use independent of the company's servers" sounds good. The memo doesn't say who would run those independent servers, what security standards would apply, or what happens when the game's backend can't practically be released because of licensed middleware or anti-cheat systems.
  • How does the refund math work for bundles, DLC and discounted purchases? The 25% floor is based on the initial sale price. The main formula uses the highest price in the final year of service, which for an older game could be a clearance price.
  • What about publishers based outside Pennsylvania? State consumer-protection laws often reach companies selling to residents. How that works across global storefronts is a question for lawyers, not a memo.
  • What happens to the free-game exception with mixed monetization? "Made purchases or invested money" could cover a lot of live-service titles. The line isn't drawn yet.

Publishers will likely argue that forcing offline modes or server patches adds real engineering and licensing costs, especially for games built around online services from the start. Supporters will answer that the refund option is the fallback built for exactly that case. That tension is where the legislative fight will happen.

What this means for PC and Xbox players right now​

In practical terms: nothing changes today. HappyGamer put it bluntly: "Right now this is just a proposal, not a law. It still has to clear the Pennsylvania senate and house before a governor could sign anything."

While lawmakers work it out, the old advice still applies. When a game offers a DRM-free or fully offline version, that's the only form of "ownership" the digital market really guarantees. Kane's memo seems to agree, since that kind of game is exactly what his proposal exempts.

For WindowsForum readers, this fits alongside our ongoing coverage of digital licensing and game preservation, how DRM works on PC, and the Xbox disc-to-digital shift.

 

References

  1. Proposed Pennsylvania law targets publishers that kill digital games Tom's Hardware 2026-09-28T10:00:00+00:00
  2. Protect Our Games Act Would Force 60-Day Notice Before Game Shutdowns | HappyGamer happygamer.com
  3. California Protect Our Games Act and Digital Game Ownership – Segev LLP segevllp.com