A photographer edits a mountain landscape on a desktop monitor, comparing the original with a vivid sunset-enhanced version.
Photographers on Windows who leave Lightroom often expect to miss the AI tools. XDA Developers writer Nolen Jonker found the bigger gap was the saved looks he had stopped noticing. In his account of switching to the free, open-source RapidRAW editor, he says many of the edits he "couldn't recreate" were presets. They were saved slider values that Lightroom had been applying for him, and he had never made them by hand.

This is one person's experience, not a benchmark. The RapidRAW documentation and release notes do back up most of the preset mechanics he describes. In places they are more precise than his write-up, and in one case they correct it.

A photographer edits a mountain landscape on a desktop monitor, comparing the original with a vivid sunset-enhanced version. The workflow problem hiding behind the subscription​

Jonker's argument is simple. Lightroom's loop is import, apply a look from the Presets panel, nudge a slider, export. After years of that, it is hard to tell how much of a finished image came from your own edits and how much came from a saved preset. You only find out when the subscription is gone.

He first listed the Lightroom features he assumed he would lose, and most were AI features:

  • Select Subject and Select Sky. Adobe's own announcement is not what the search returned here, but the packet's Adobe MAX 2021 release post, dated October 26, 2021, introduced these as one-tap, machine-learning-based selections. That matches the date in the XDA piece.
  • Lens Blur. He describes it as an AI-estimated depth map built from a flat photo, with the background blurred according to that map.
  • Generative Remove. He dates it to May 2024 and says it uses Adobe's Firefly model.

He notes that open-source editors have been slower with AI. In his view that is partly because trained models add bloat and bug reports. He says darktable only shipped its first AI tools in version 5.6 this year, covering object masking and denoising but not lens blur or generative fill.

Why RapidRAW won out​

Jonker says he tried darktable, RawTherapee and LightCraft before settling on RapidRAW:

  • darktable: powerful, but he says even its own FAQ warns against treating it as a direct Lightroom replacement, and he found the learning curve odd.
  • RawTherapee: impressive and feature-rich, but oriented toward pixel-level RAW control he doesn't need.
  • LightCraft: part of Brandon Thomas's ArtCraft suite, which he describes as clean-room builds of Adobe-style apps. He says the team puts it at roughly 61–62% ready for real work.
  • RapidRAW: a download of about 20–40MB, an approachable interface, and the basics he wanted.

RapidRAW's documentation describes it as a GPU-accelerated RAW photo editor for Windows, macOS, and Linux. The project's own docs also list Android. It is not a Windows-only tool, but Windows is a first-class target.

The AI features, and one correction​

Jonker reports that RapidRAW can mask a subject or sky with a click. It also has a depth mask, AI Lens Blur, AI denoising and object removal. He says generative replace is the exception, needing either RapidRAW's cloud service or ComfyUI.

The settings documentation is more nuanced. It lists four generative-AI modes:

  1. Built-in (default). Everything runs on your computer and is free: AI masks, AI denoise, RapidRes 2x upscaling, automatic tagging and simple generative replace. Models download the first time you use them. Windows and macOS get a "Use GPU for AI models" switch, on by default. Turn it off if AI features crash or hang, and RapidRAW falls back to the CPU.
  2. AI Connector. This links to your own ComfyUI server, for example at 127.0.0.1:8188, for full control over the models used.
  3. Cloud. This uses RapidRAW Cloud for higher-quality generative replace. It needs sign-in and is desktop-only, and the panel shows subscription status and monthly usage.
  4. AI-Free. This hides and disables AI controls. Existing AI edits still render. If you turn on denoise in this mode, RapidRAW uses the classic non-AI BM3D algorithm.

So the accurate version is that simple generative replace is included in the default local mode. The cloud and ComfyUI routes are for higher quality or for your own models.

The same page describes the storage side. You can clear downloaded models and they will re-download when needed. Caches have limits, and the documented defaults include 4 GB for depth and normal maps, and 25 GB each for AI denoise and RapidRes. If disk space matters on your laptop, check these.

The real lesson: rebuild your looks as presets​

Jonker explains a Lightroom preset as a small .xmp file of saved slider values. Different editors' sliders behave differently, so a preset only fully works in the program that made it. He expects something to be lost when bringing Lightroom presets across, and he recommends rebuilding your favourites natively.

His RapidRAW procedure is:

  1. Edit a photo until the look is right.
  2. Click the plus button in the Presets panel and name the preset.
  3. Choose Style or Tool. Style saves every setting and replaces the current edit. Tool saves only what you changed and stacks on top.
  4. Optionally include masks.
  5. When applying the preset to a new photo, use the intensity slider, which he compares to Lightroom's Amount slider.

The documentation confirms the Style/Tool split. Style records every setting, including those at default values, while Tool records only the settings you actually changed. The docs also say the Presets panel opens with P. Its header has buttons for community presets, import, export all and save new.

Importing Lightroom presets​

Jonker is cautious here, and the docs give a more specific picture. Import accepts RapidRAW's .rrpreset files and Lightroom or Camera Raw presets in .xmp and .lrtemplate format, and Lightroom presets are converted to Style presets. A maintainer reply in a project discussion makes the same point about the supported formats.

Conversion is not guaranteed to be lossless. In the same discussion, a user shared a community converter script. A tester reported that some keys in his film-style presets were unmapped and ignored, including incremental temperature and tint. That is one anecdote, not a compatibility audit. It does fit Jonker's warning that imports will not match exactly. Test any imported look on several of your own photos.

The file formats page adds a related caveat. XMP sync writes ratings, labels and tags for other apps, but develop settings from other apps are not imported that way, so you bring over a Lightroom look through the Presets panel.

Backups and where presets live​

Jonker says you can export your collection as a single .rrpreset file to back it up or share it. The docs agree: Export all saves all your presets and folders into one .rrpreset file. On Windows, a project discussion reply says presets are stored in a presets.json file under the app's AppData\Roaming folder for io.github.CyberTimon.RapidRAW. That is a community answer from March 2026, so confirm it on your installed version. Exporting from inside the app is the safer backup route either way.

AI masks inside presets​

For batch work, the most useful detail is how AI masks behave in a preset. The v1.6.7 release notes (October 25, 2026) explain that earlier versions kept the exact mask from the original photo. A pasted sky mask still showed the first image's sky. Since that release, applying a preset or pasting adjustments regenerates AI masks per image in the background, with sky, subject and face masks all recalculated.

This is why a "sunset sky" look can be a preset rather than a repeat job. It also means the result depends on a model's guess for each frame. Check the masks on odd scenes, such as a sky behind bare branches. A reusable preset does not guarantee the same photographic result on every image.

A moving target​

RapidRAW is changing fast. The release workflow shows v1.7.0 created on November 15, 2026, with a new rendering engine called Furka. Before it came v1.6.9 on November 7, which added a Black & White mode, Motion Blur and Speed Edit. The same listing shows v1.6.0 on July 26 with Lens Blur in its title, and v1.5.4 on April 22 with a reworked presets system. (The research notes called v1.6.9 the latest; the workflow listing shows v1.7.0 has since shipped.)

Two items from the v1.7.0 release notes matter to preset users:

  • Default Adjustments. You can pick a default preset for every unedited photo. Per-camera defaults are possible too, and you can turn on automatic lens correction. Masks, crops and transforms are skipped in the default preset.
  • Existing edits will look different. The notes say the new engine changes how every photo renders, so edits will change after updating. The notes warn that colour grading edits will probably need adjusting. If you are mid-project, finish and export first. Presets built on older versions deserve a re-check too.

Verdict: what to take from it​

Jonker is explicit that he was not trying to replace all of Lightroom, and he admits RapidRAW has rough edges. Nothing in the documentation or release notes shows it matches Lightroom's output, catalog depth or camera support across the board. His conclusion is a narrow one: if your look comes from a handful of saved settings, a free editor with good preset handling may cover more than you expect.

A sensible trial for a Windows user:

  1. Copy a few representative photos, so nothing happens to your originals.
  2. Pick the three or four looks you use most and rebuild them as Style presets. Make some Tool presets for fixes such as lens correction.
  3. Try importing a few Lightroom presets and compare them with your rebuilt versions.
  4. Apply everything to varied scenes and inspect any regenerated AI masks.
  5. Decide on AI: keep the local default, turn off GPU acceleration if models crash, or use AI-Free. Watch cache sizes.
  6. Re-check after each update, given how often the app is changing.

Whether that is a full exit from a subscription depends on your files and your tolerance for a young, fast-moving app. The lesson from Jonker's trial is to count your presets before you count the features you think you need.

 

References

  1. I replaced Lightroom with a free open-source editor, and the edits I couldn't recreate turned out to be presets XDA 2026-11-18T17:30:24+00:00
  2. Release: Build & Package App github.com
  3. Releases github.com