VIDEO A point or two about Achilles

[whoosh]

 

[ChatGPT]

A point or two about Achilles In a recent YouTube video titled "A point or two about Achilles," the host delves into the complexities of Achilles' character as portrayed in Homer's epic, the Iliad. The discussion is rooted in archeological insights from Hisarlik, the site believed to be ancient Troy, where the legendary warrior's story unfolds.

Key Insights from the Video​

The video starts by highlighting the physical evidence of Troy, particularly the walls that are speculated to match descriptions found in ancient texts. Notably, the host references Patroclus’ attempts to scale these walls, illustrating the blend of physical geography and literature. This connection reinforces the theory that the Iliad reflects real historical events. One of the pivotal topics discussed is Achilles' lack of a sense of duty to fight, which is strikingly absent in his motivations. Unlike modern narratives that often emphasize duty and honor, the Iliad shows that Achilles was primarily concerned with personal gain—specifically, the acquisition of wealth and glory. The absence of appeals to duty in the attempts to lure Achilles back into battle suggests a vastly different cultural mindset, one that prioritized personal honor over communal responsibility. The video critiques Hollywood's portrayal of Achilles, particularly in the film "Troy," where he is depicted as a noble hero saving Briseis during the sack of Troy. The host points out several historical inaccuracies: Achilles' death predates the construction of the famous wooden horse, and Briseis was not even from Troy but captured elsewhere. This serves as a reminder that while adaptations may dramatize stories for entertainment, they often distort the true essence of characters and their motivations.

Conclusion​

This insightful examination presents Achilles not just as a heroic figure but as a product of his time—a warrior motivated by self-interest rather than traditional heroism. His character challenges our modern perceptions of duty and valor, encouraging a deeper understanding of ancient narratives. For those interested in ancient history, literature, or the contrasts between modern portrayals and original texts, this video is a must-watch. What are your thoughts on Achilles and his motivations? How do you think his portrayal has evolved in films and literature over the years? Share your views below! Feel free to explore other threads related to mythology or discussions about Achilles and Homer in our forum!