AI PCs in 2025: Why Adoption Isn't Catching On Yet

Enthusiasm for AI PCs has hit a peculiar ceiling: the public’s attention has been captured by bold claims and high-profile marketing, yet widespread adoption remains a step too far for most. While industry leaders like Microsoft, Intel, AMD, and Qualcomm trumpet their latest hardware with phrases like “Copilot Plus,” “120 TOPS AI acceleration,” and “on-device inference,” the practical reality for everyday users and even many business buyers is one of skepticism, caution, and, ultimately, hesitation. As partners and resellers report, customers are curious—they demo devices, ask questions, and click through online spec sheets—but meaningful sales volume for AI-branded PCs and mini desktops is yet to materialize. Behind this disconnect is a complex web of technical, economic, and user-experience tradeoffs that the PC industry must navigate as it attempts to make the “AI PC” not just a buzzword, but a genuine reason to upgrade.

Curiosity Outpaces Commitment: AI PC Sales in Context​

Reseller and partner feedback illuminates the central dilemma: interest in AI PCs is real, but conversion is weak. Industry analysts from Gartner and Mercury Research point to a telling set of data: by late 2024, over a third of all new PCs shipped were equipped with some form of neural processing unit (NPU), but just a small fraction (less than 10%) actually met Microsoft’s demanding Copilot Plus hardware requirements, and Snapdragon X-based flagship laptops barely crested 1.5% of PC sales in Q3 2024. Even as Microsoft and its OEM partners flood the market with models like the Surface Laptop 7, Lenovo Yoga Slim 7x, and HP Omnibook X 14, the gap between marketable innovation and consumer need is stark.
Several dynamics drive this pattern:

• Price premiums remain substantial: AI PCs can cost hundreds more than their non-AI equivalents, with starting prices (e.g., $999 for some Surface Copilot Plus models) considerably higher than for traditional x86 laptops.
• Value uncertainty: For many, advertised AI features represent improvements rather than essential, never-before-seen capabilities. Video call enhancements, automatic transcriptions, or real-time translation are appreciated, but rarely decisive.
• Compatibility risks: Arm-powered Windows systems like Copilot Plus models, in pushing for a new silicon baseline, encounter real-world friction. Many popular x86 applications only run via emulation, peripherals and drivers can lag, and high-end gaming or creative workloads often suffer.

Partner anecdotes corroborate these findings: in-store demos attract attention, but when it comes time to purchase, mainstream buyers frequently opt for proven models—often at lower prices, with broader compatibility, and without the “AI” label.

What AI PCs Are—and Aren’t—Delivering​

The “AI PC,” as it stands in mid-2025, is defined by Microsoft’s Copilot Plus requirements: a system with at least 16GB of RAM, 256GB storage, and a dedicated NPU offering 40+ TOPS (trillions of operations per second) of AI performance. At the ultracompact end, devices like the ASUS NUC 14 Pro AI with Intel Core Ultra processors (boasting up to 120 TOPS total and 48 NPU TOPS) promise acceleration for everything from industrial automation to generative AI content creation.
Strengths of Current AI PCs:

• Battery Life: By shifting select AI workflows (image filtering, background blur, voice enhancement) to the NPU, power draw drops. ARM-based Copilot Plus systems in particular challenge Apple’s MacBook Air for endurance—a leap that is validated by hands-on reviews and user reports.
• Local Privacy and Latency: For supported AI tasks (e.g., Recall’s on-device activity search, Click To Do task creation), keeping data on the PC means privacy concerns about cloud processing are reduced and results are generated more quickly, even if offline.
• Foundation for New Applications: Hardware upgrades have historically seeded software innovation: widespread deployment of NPUs could inspire developers to create new classes of on-device, latency-free AI experiences. Early benefits are being seen in creative tools like Affinity Photo 2, Blender, DaVinci Resolve, and Cubase, which harness NPU acceleration for tangible performance gains.

Lingering Pain Points:

• Feature Gaps and Cloud Dependence: Microsoft’s vaunted Recall feature was quickly scaled back amid privacy and security outcries, shipment delays, and audits; many key AI functions today still process in the cloud, meaning their true speed and privacy value hinge on a reliable internet connection.
• Compatibility and Ecosystem Immaturity: Arm desktops and laptops struggle with numerous Windows applications that haven’t been rebuilt for Arm64. App emulation software—Prism—doesn’t solve all compatibility cases, and performance sometimes lags. Gaming is particularly affected, while power-user workflows face similar snags.
• Transparency and Overpromising: Resellers echo customer complaints that marketing often outpaces reality. Which features truly run locally? What do NPUs enable that CPUs and GPUs cannot? The answers, so far, remain unsatisfyingly vague, leading to confusion and disappointment.

Industry data makes the case plain: for most PC buyers, the “AI” label doesn’t outweigh fundamentals like battery life, keyboard feel, port array, and display quality—and if it raises the price too much, buyers walk.

Competitive Pressures, Cross-Platform Innovation​

Microsoft is not working in a vacuum. Apple’s “Apple Intelligence” suite and Google’s Gemini integration into premium Chromebooks have taken AI integration mainstream, but they, too, rely heavily on cloud compute for the most advanced features. Notably, Apple has placed a significant emphasis on on-device privacy—as has Microsoft with its Copilot+ PCs—as a key differentiator for enterprise and privacy-conscious buyers.
Apple’s experience, however, reveals a crucial lesson: even when AI features are embedded at the OS level and enabled by powerful new silicon (like Apple’s M-series chips), it still takes time, and a robust developer ecosystem, for these features to cross the line from curiosity to necessity. Early adopters praise seamless on-device search, text summarization, and creative tools, but the mainstream continues to upgrade mainly for tangible hardware reasons, not AI alone.

Hardware Leap or Hype? Technical and Market Realities​

The technical underpinnings of Copilot Plus and similar AI PCs are impressive. For instance, only devices with an NPU capable of 40+ TOPS are eligible for the full suite of local AI features and Microsoft’s “Copilot key.” This creates a clear benchmark for partners to target—and in theory, a guarantee to buyers that their device is “future proof” for local AI workloads. In practice, however, adoption is slowed by:

• Software Lag: Many apps do not meaningfully utilize NPUs yet; much of the headline AI differentiation is tied to future software releases.
• Price-to-Benefit Discrepancy: With ARM-based Copilot Plus systems sometimes more expensive than comparable x86 models (and often less compatible), even business buyers are proceeding with caution, particularly given budget constraints.
• Security Worries: Powerful new features like Recall, which records and indexes virtually every user action for instant search and retrieval, are deeply controversial for privacy reasons. Microsoft promises all processing is local, but enterprise security teams remain wary and are demanding granular controls, third-party audits, and opt-out features before blanket adoption.
• Environmental Impact: If the push for NPUs leads to a wave of device obsolescence and increased e-waste, the ecological cost of mass AI PC adoption will be significant, especially as the practical benefit to many users remains unclear.

Use Cases: Who Should Consider an AI PC Today?​

Despite caution, select user segments can extract tangible value from today’s AI PCs:

• Light Productivity and Portability Seekers: Office workers, students, and web-centric users benefit from the battery life, instant-on, and slim profiles of ARM Copilot Plus models—so long as their workflows are compatible and they don’t depend on niche x86 applications.
• Privacy-Sensitive Professionals: Lawyers, healthcare providers, and others dealing with confidential data may appreciate local AI processing when supported apps are available.
• Developers and Digital Creatives: NPUs show real benefits in select media creation suites where AI-assisted editing is not just faster, but also more responsive.
• Early Adopters and Enthusiasts: Tinkerers and those who want the very latest tech—for curiosity, development, or signaling—find plenty to enjoy. For this group, the window to experiment is now.

For most businesses, however, and the vast mainstream of buyers, solid compatibility, support for legacy applications, and total cost of ownership trump speculative AI benefits.

Critical Analysis: Strengths, Risks, and the Path Forward​

Notable Strengths:

• Genuine Hardware Innovation: There’s no denying that Copilot Plus and new AI PCs move the needle in terms of battery life, integrated AI acceleration, and operating system-level AI awareness. Select models, including the ASUS NUC 14 Pro AI, offer compelling efficiency, portability, and targeted performance for IoT and edge AI scenarios.
• Platform for Future Growth: The NPU revolution is laying the foundation for a next generation of truly interactive, context-aware software. If the right “killer app” emerges—one that simply cannot run on older hardware due to NPU requirements—AI PCs will become a must-have, not a maybe-later.

Potential Pitfalls:

• Risk of “AI Hype Fatigue”: Oversold benefits and unmet promises risk alienating even those who are now curious. If the public perceives AI PCs as little more than a premium branding exercise, backlash could stall or even reverse market momentum.
• Security and Privacy Front and Center: With on-device features like Recall, manufacturers face an ongoing challenge to reassure users that sensitive data isn’t being vacuumed up for analytics or ad targeting, and that robust opt-out provisions exist.
• Fragmentation and Confusion: Inconsistent marketing, unclear hardware specs, and limited feature differentiation between “AI” and non-AI PCs stymie both channel partners and customers.

Environmental Considerations:

• Device Longevity and E-Waste: Rapid hardware cycles threaten to generate a surge in computer waste if consumers feel pressured to swap out recently purchased devices for new AI-compliant ones, before true value is delivered. This environmental concern should not be underestimated.

The Wait-and-See Era: What Needs to Change?​

Anyone betting on overnight, iPhone-style AI PC adoption may be disappointed. The experience of both Windows and Apple platforms confirms that transforming hardware innovation into a mass-market imperative takes time—and, crucially, compelling software that redefines core workflows for millions.
To cross the tipping point, the AI PC ecosystem should:

• Deliver transparent, standardized marketing, making it clear which features run locally, what the privacy tradeoffs are, and what real advantages an NPU brings.
• Prioritize backward compatibility and user choice, enabling a smoother upgrade path for businesses and loyal Windows users.
• Accelerate developer support to bring truly NPU-dependent features—ones impossible on legacy PCs—into the mainstream, so the benefit isn’t just theoretical.
• Continue energy efficiency and value focus, lowering the cost premium to make AI PCs accessible and justifiable even for cost-conscious buyers.

Conclusion: AI PCs—A Revolution on Pause, Not a Dead End​

Interest and innovation are alive and well in the AI PC world, but evidence suggests that mainstream buyers are wise to proceed with caution. The Copilot Plus vision—of every PC as a genuinely intelligent, context-aware assistant—is compelling, but needs software, compatibility, and price points to align for true takeoff.
Partners and resellers’ feedback is unambiguous: curiosity is high, but conversion lags. For now, the best advice for the average user is to focus on fundamentals: battery life, performance, a robust app ecosystem, and value for money. Keep an eye on the AI PC space—its day will come, but decisive, household-changing upgrades aren’t here yet. For those willing to experiment, the rewards are real, but for the rest, patience remains the wisest investment of all.

---

Source: CRN Australia https://www.crn.com.au/news/2025/hardware/ai-pc-windows-11-refresh/