Comparing Productivity: Running Windows 11 on macOS with Parallels Desktop

Running Windows on macOS can be a fascinating experiment that often brings unexpected insights about both ecosystems. Many longtime Windows users might imagine that switching to macOS would mean losing access to essential tools and productivity features. Yet, after testing out Windows 11 in a virtualized environment using Parallels Desktop on a modern M4 Mac Mini, one could easily conclude that the macOS ecosystem has matured to a point where it not only meets but, in some respects, exceeds the Windows experience.

A Smooth Dive into Virtualization​

One of the most striking aspects of the recent experiment was the seamless setup of Windows 11 via Parallels Desktop. Instead of the often laborious process that native Windows installations demand, Parallels offers an almost magical one-click solution. By simply selecting the automatic download option, Parallels handled the out-of-box experience (OOBE) with impressive ease. The setup automatically configured a local account, bypassing the common barrage of prompts related to Microsoft 365, Game Pass, OneDrive sync, and even data collection practices by Edge.
This streamlined setup highlights a stark contrast:

• Virtualized Experience:
  • Local account creation.
  • No intrusive advertisements for Microsoft services.
  • Limited background actions such as OneDrive sync.
• Traditional Windows PC Setup:
  • Mandatory Microsoft account sign-in.
  • Multiple Microsoft 365 upselling screens during initial configuration.
  • Repetitive reminders to enable additional Microsoft features post-setup.

Parallels’ approach not only ensures a smoother journey but also demonstrates how virtualization software can mitigate some of the common annoyances faced by users of native Windows installations. One might even wonder if future iterations of Windows 11 updates and Microsoft security patches could benefit from a similarly streamlined approach.

Productivity Tools: Windows vs. macOS​

When the dust settled on that virtualized Windows 11 desktop, one clear question emerged: Is there much to miss from the native Windows experience when macOS hosts an extensive array of equivalent productivity tools?

Window Management​

Windows enthusiasts often champion tools like PowerToys—especially its FancyZones feature—which allows granular control of window arrangements on a super ultrawide display. However, macOS users have robust alternatives:

• MacsyZones:
  • Provides similar functionality to FancyZones.
  • Free to use with intuitive customization for various layouts.
• Raycast:
  • Outperforms Windows’ Flow Launcher in many aspects.
  • Designed to quickly launch apps, execute system commands, and even integrate fun extensions such as a visually appealing Pokédex.

These tools demonstrate that macOS is no longer the underdog when it comes to managing multitasking workflows. Instead of wrestling with window placement or searching for an app through a cluttered menu, macOS users can configure their workspaces to match or even surpass the organizational features of Windows.

Application Launching and Customization​

At the heart of any productivity system is the ease with which one can navigate between applications. Raycast is proving to be a supercharged alternative to Flow Launcher by offering an uncluttered, user-friendly interface that not only launches applications but also provides extensions for tasks like quick file handling and even YouTube video searches. Such capabilities make macOS an ideal platform for users who prefer a streamlined, less intrusive workflow.
Consider these points:

• Launch Speed and Customization:
  • Photoshop and Lightroom run natively on macOS, offering faster launch times and fluid image handling.
  • Raycast provides system-wide commands that enhance productivity without the additional bloat often seen on Windows.

The comparison makes it clear that modern macOS tools are closing the gap—or even surpassing—traditional Windows utilities. In this light, the necessity of maintaining a Windows-centric workflow, particularly for daily productivity tasks, diminishes considerably.

Real-World Performance Considerations​

While virtualizing Windows 11 on macOS is technically impressive, the experiment also highlights performance trade-offs. Running applications in a virtual machine, no matter how powerful the host hardware, typically introduces a noticeable lag compared to native execution. This becomes especially apparent in tasks that demand quick application launches.

Practical Examples:​

• Cropping Images:
  • In Windows 11, the Photos app offers a simple interface for cropping images to a specific aspect ratio—a task that might seem trivial at first glance.
  • However, due to the inherent delay introduced by virtualization, the native macOS workflow with Photoshop proves to be a faster and more efficient alternative.
  • When you’re working on multiple images at once, the speed and fluidity of macOS applications are undeniably advantageous.
• Screen Capture:
  • The Windows Snipping Tool features an option to automatically obfuscate sensitive information in screenshots, a feature potentially useful during presentations or when quickly sharing images.
  • Despite this clever functionality, macOS users can easily rely on Photoshop’s healing brush to achieve similar results without the need to switch contexts and contend with VM lag.

These examples underscore a broader point: while Windows 11 might offer innovative updates and certain niche features, the day-to-day practicalities of productivity often favor the native macOS environment. As Windows 11 continues to evolve—with its periodic security patches and cybersecurity advisories—the inherent friction points in user experience may persist if they remain deeply integrated into the Windows interface.

User Experience and Setup Woes​

An important aspect of this exploration is the observation of how Windows 11’s native setup can become a source of frustration. New users setting up a Windows 11 PC face a gauntlet of Microsoft product promotions and enforced sign-in protocols. The forced use of a Microsoft account during the out-of-box experience can be particularly exasperating, especially when trying to skip the multiple screens dedicated to Microsoft 365 subscriptions.
This isn’t just a minor hiccup—it’s indicative of a design philosophy that contrasts sharply with the more streamlined, minimal-intervention approach seen in macOS. Several key points include:

• Forced Sign-Ins:
  • Windows 11 increasingly integrates its services deep into the user interface, making it hard to bypass sign-in routines.
  • This is often coupled with persistent reminders to link other devices or enable OneDrive, which may disrupt the user’s workflow.
• Frequent Prompts:
  • Even after the initial setup, these reminders tend to resurface with every cumulative update, potentially interrupting work and reducing overall satisfaction.
• Comparison with Parallels Experience:
  • In contrast, Parallels Desktop’s installation of Windows 11 omits these persistent nudges by default, offering a clear advantage for users who want to use Windows solely for targeted tasks without the peripheral distractions.

The frustration with these aspects might lead some to consider virtualization as a workaround, but it also reflects broader questions about the inherent design priorities of Windows 11. If an operating system routinely interrupts your workflow with nudges towards cloud services and optional subscriptions, is it really catering to productivity, or is it prioritizing engagement metrics over user satisfaction?

The Broader Implications: Operating System Convergence​

The debate between macOS and Windows is not new. For years, users and tech enthusiasts have compared the two in terms of performance, design, and functionality. However, as technology evolves, both platforms are increasingly borrowing features from one another. Consider the following:

• App Ecosystem:
  • The availability of cross-platform software like Adobe Creative Cloud means that professional-grade tools are no longer exclusive to one operating system.
  • Many third-party developers now offer alternative solutions that work seamlessly on both macOS and Windows, effectively neutralizing the advantage that one platform might have historically enjoyed over the other in a specific category.
• Window Management Advances:
  • As demonstrated in the experiment, what once was a flagship feature of Windows—efficient window management through tools like FancyZones—is now matched by similar and sometimes superior solutions on macOS.
• User Customization and Control:
  • Both platforms now support extensive customization not only through built-in settings but also via third-party applications.
  • This means users have more control than ever to tailor their work environments, whether on macOS or Windows.

These trends suggest that in the near future, the question might not be “Which operating system is better?” but rather “Which ecosystem best fits my personal or professional workflow?” For users who prioritize a hassle-free setup and a customized, less intrusive experience, macOS—with the aid of powerful third-party tools—proves to be a compelling choice.

When Windows Still Matters​

It would be remiss not to acknowledge that Windows retains its significance, especially in areas where macOS is less dominant. Gaming, for instance, continues to be a major draw for many users. Windows is also often preferred for certain enterprise applications and specialized software that may not have fully matured counterparts on macOS.
Moreover, Windows 11 continues to receive updates designed to improve security and patch vulnerabilities. These Windows 11 updates and Microsoft security patches are critical for users who run Windows devices, ensuring that the platform remains robust against emerging cybersecurity threats. For professionals who depend on these updates for safe financial operations or sensitive workplace communications, Windows still plays an indispensable role.
In essence, while casual users and even many professionals might lean towards macOS for its superior user experience and streamlined productivity tools, there remains a well-defined niche in which Windows excels. The operating system's commitment to frequent updates and rigorous security protocols makes it the clear choice in environments where robustness and compatibility with a wide array of software are paramount.

Concluding Thoughts​

The experiment of running Windows 11 on macOS using Parallels Desktop unveils a thoughtful narrative about choice, productivity, and the evolution of user interfaces. The smooth virtualization process, the redundancy of switching to Windows for core productivity tasks, and the absence of cumbersome advertising and forced sign-ins collectively paint a picture in which macOS stands as a formidable competitor to native Windows experiences.
Key takeaways include:

• User-Centric Design:
  • macOS, enhanced by targeted third-party tools like MacsyZones and Raycast, delivers an experience that is both fluid and customizable.
• Streamlined Workflows:
  • The native performance of macOS applications in tasks such as image editing and screen capturing significantly outpaces what can be achieved in a virtualized Windows environment.
• Balanced Ecosystem:
  • While Windows 11 offers critical updates, polished security patches, and niche functionalities that are indispensable for some users, the average user may find the continuous intrusions and setup complexities a fair trade-off for the additional hardware and software costs.

Ultimately, the experiment sparks a vital question for technology enthusiasts: Is it time to reexamine our loyalty to a single operating system when so many productivity-enhancing alternatives are at our fingertips? For many, the answer is clear. If you’re a professional seeking efficiency without peppering your workflow with needless interruptions, macOS coupled with a suite of excellent third-party utilities might just be the perfect solution.
In the dynamic world of IT, where cybersecurity advisories and innovative Windows 11 updates often dominate industry headlines, it’s refreshing to see a real-world evaluation that underlines practicality over theoretical advantages. As our computing needs continue to evolve, so too does our choice of platform. And occasionally, running Windows on macOS may simply serve to highlight just how far the macOS ecosystem has come in meeting, and even exceeding, our modern productivity demands.

---

Source: XDA Developers https://www.xda-developers.com/running-windows-macos-made-me-realize-there-isnt-much-miss/