Reviving the Audio Popup in Windows 11: A Step-by-Step Guide

The evolution of Windows 11’s audio management has left many users nostalgic for the old “Which device did you plug in?” popup. Long enjoyed in earlier versions of Realtek HD Audio Manager, that prompt allowed users to easily switch between audio devices by manually confirming whether a plugged-in jack was intended for headphones, speakers, or a microphone. If you’ve ever wondered why you no longer see that friendly query, or if you’d rather have it back for enhanced control, read on for a deep dive into the ins and outs of managing audio devices under Windows 11.

Historical Context and Evolution​

Before Windows 11 streamlined many aspects of user experience through automatic device detection, Realtek’s HD Audio Manager (and its predecessor, High Definition Audio drivers) offered a manual prompt for audio device configuration. This prompt proved particularly useful on systems where a single 3.5mm jack could serve as both an input and an output. It gave you, the power user, the choice to specify whether you were plugging in a headphone, a speaker, or even a microphone.
Back in the day, installing older versions of Realtek drivers meant you were greeted with this handy dialog. However, as Microsoft and hardware vendors pushed for more automated audio management systems in Windows 11, the popup was gradually sidelined. Modern systems now primarily rely on Realtek UAD (Universal Audio Driver) versions and custom OEM software designed to manage audio settings seamlessly, often without user intervention.
Key takeaways from this historical shift include:

• Early Realtek drivers provided manual selection, perfect for dual-function audio jacks.
• Modern Windows 11 implementations favor automatic detection.
• Many OEM configurations (from brands like HP, Dell, Lenovo, and ASUS) have integrated proprietary software that further minimizes the need for manual prompts.

Modern Audio Management in Windows 11​

The shift to USB-A or Bluetooth audio devices, coupled with improved automatic detection, has pushed many manufacturers toward eliminating redundant prompts. While automatic detection certainly cleans up the workflow, it sometimes takes away a degree of control that seasoned users may prefer. After all, what if your device isn’t properly recognized or you need to quickly switch between inputs and outputs without diving into setting menus?
Windows 11 still welcomes you to view and manage your audio devices, though the process is now more integrated into the operating system’s main settings. You can find out which device is active through several windowing methods:

• Sound Settings: Right-click the speaker icon in the system tray and select Sound settings. Under the “Output” section, check which audio device is currently active, and see the “Input” section for connected microphones.
• Device Manager: Press Win + X and choose Device Manager. Within the “Sound, video, and game controllers” category, and under “Audio inputs and outputs,” you’ll find a list of active devices.
• Control Panel: Navigate to Hardware and Sound > Sound, and check the Playback and Recording tabs. If you want to see disconnected or disabled devices, simply right-click and enable the “Show Disabled Devices” option.
• Windows Settings: Open Settings with Win + I, then head to Bluetooth & devices > Devices for an overview of all connected peripherals.

These methods ensure you remain in control over your PC’s audio configuration, even as modern drivers roll out with less overt prompts.

Enabling the “Which Device Did You Plug In?” Popup​

If you’re yearning for the manual selection process—and for a time machine that brings it back—there’s a workaround, though it might come with its share of caveats. In short, you need to replace the newer Realtek UAD driver with an older High Definition Audio (HDA) driver version that supports the popup.
Here’s how you can attempt to restore the popup:

• Uninstall the Current Audio Driver:
• Press Win + X and select Device Manager.
• Expand “Sound, video and game controllers.”
• Locate Realtek Audio or Realtek High Definition Audio.
• Right-click and choose Uninstall device. (Important: If prompted, check the box labeled “Delete the driver software for this device.”)
• Restart your PC to ensure the newly uninstalled driver is fully removed.
• Download an Older HDA Driver:
• Visit your PC manufacturer’s support website.
• In the support section, search for your laptop or motherboard model and navigate to the Audio or Sound drivers section.
• Look for a version of the Realtek HDA driver—preferably version R2.79 or even an earlier iteration. (Be cautious: starting with version R2.79, Realtek HD Audio Manager began to be phased out, with many package changes directing audio configurations straight into Windows Sound Properties.)
• Install the Driver:
• Run the downloaded driver setup file.
• Follow the on-screen instructions to install the older HDA driver.
• After the installation is complete, restart your PC again for the changes to take effect.
• Test the Popup:
• Open Control Panel, navigate to Hardware and Sound > Sound.
• Plug in a headphone, microphone, or speaker.
• Ideally, the “Which device did you plug in?” popup will appear, allowing you to select the desired device.
• Alternative – Realtek HD Audio Manager:
• If the popup still resists appearing, consider downloading and installing Realtek HD Audio Manager directly onto your Windows 11 PC.
• Open the software (or any similar OEM audio management tool like MaxxAudio Pro).
• Look for options related to “Connector Settings,” “Jack Detection,” or “Device Advanced Settings” and enable the manual selection prompt.

Remember that while these steps are effective for some users, installing legacy drivers isn’t always the best practice—especially on systems where OEM software is finely tuned to the hardware. For users with PCs from HP, Dell, Lenovo, or ASUS, the built-in audio software may override or disable this popup regardless of the driver version.

Disabling the Popup for a Seamless Experience​

Conversely, if you find the persistent popup more of a distraction than a help, there are straightforward methods to disable it. Here’s how you can stop Windows 11 from asking you “Which device did you plug in?”:

• Using Realtek HD Audio Manager:
• Open Realtek HD Audio Manager (if installed on your system).
• Click on the folder icon typically found in the upper right corner of the interface.
• Look for an option labeled “Enable auto popup dialog, when device has been plugged in” and uncheck it.
• Via Waves MaxxAudio Pro:
• If your system uses Waves MaxxAudio Pro, open the application.
• Select the active audio device.
• Click on “Advanced” at the bottom of the window.
• Uncheck the “Show pop-up dialog when device is connected” option.
• Through Windows Notification Settings:
• Open the Settings app (Win + I) and navigate to System > Notifications.
• Scroll down under “Notifications from apps and other senders.”
• Locate “Realtek HD Audio Console” and toggle off notifications.
• Reboot Your PC:
• A simple reboot will ensure that any changes you’ve made are fully applied and that the unwanted popup remains disabled.

For those wanting an immaculate, uninterrupted workflow, these steps provide a quick fix to disable a feature that may no longer serve its original purpose in a modern environment.

Managing and Monitoring Your Audio Devices​

Whether you’re enabling or disabling the popup, it’s valuable to know other methods to check and manage your connected audio devices in Windows 11:

• Taskbar Shortcut:
• Right-click the speaker icon in the taskbar and select “Sound settings” to immediately view which audio device is currently selected.
• Device Manager:
• Open the Device Manager via Win + X. Under the “Sound, video and game controllers” category, you can interact directly with installed drivers and even update or uninstall them as necessary.
• Control Panel Navigation:
• For those who favor the classic Control Panel, navigate to Hardware and Sound > Sound. The “Playback” and “Recording” tabs show all active and available devices, with options to reveal hidden devices if something seems amiss.
• Windows Settings:
• Open the Settings app and go to Bluetooth & devices > Devices. This new interface in Windows 11 lists connected audio, USB, Bluetooth, and other peripherals in a centralized view.

By familiarizing yourself with these methods, you can swiftly troubleshoot issues, switch between devices, or ensure that your hardware is correctly recognized—all without waiting for a popup prompt.

Considerations and Best Practices​

Before making changes to your audio driver configuration, consider a few key points:

• OEM Specificities:
• Many PC manufacturers have tailored their audio management software to offer a seamless experience. If you’re using a PC from a major vendor like HP, Dell, Lenovo, or ASUS, the customized software might bypass traditional Realtek configurations altogether.
• Driver Compatibility:
• Installing an older driver can resolve the absence of the popup but might introduce compatibility issues or diminish performance in other areas. Always check for potential conflicts, and consider backing up your current driver prior to making changes.
• System Stability:
• Legacy drivers may not receive security updates or full compatibility with newer Windows 11 features. Evaluate the trade-off between manual control and system stability—especially in environments where security and reliability are paramount.
• User Experience:
• The original design behind automatic device detection was to reduce unnecessary popups and create a cleaner user experience. While the manual prompt provides valuable control for some users, most benefit from the speed and hands-off nature of automatic detection.

A question to ponder: Is manual control worth the occasional hassle? For those accustomed to a tailored setup, regaining that manual prompt can enhance the usability of your audio ports. However, if you prefer a “set it and forget it” approach, the default Windows 11 settings might be just the right balance.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts​

Whether you’re chasing the nostalgia of older Realtek HD Audio Manager days or seeking more control over your audio connections on Windows 11, understanding how to enable or disable the “Which device did you plug in?” popup is essential. By carefully following the steps—either by rolling back to a legacy HDA driver or tweaking the current settings—you can fine-tune your audio experience to match your workflow.
In summary:

• The old popup was designed to let users manually configure the audio device when plugging in a jack.
• Realtek UAD drivers and OEM software in Windows 11 have mostly abandoned this feature in favor of automatic detection.
• There are multiple methods available to view and manage your audio devices through Sound Settings, Device Manager, or the classic Control Panel.
• For enthusiasts eager to restore manual control, uninstalling the current driver and installing an older HDA version (preferably pre-R2.79) is the remedy.
• Conversely, if the popup annoys you, it can be easily disabled through the built-in audio management tools or Windows notification settings.
• Always consider the compatibility and stability of your system when opting for legacy drivers.

Ultimately, whether you value nostalgia or practicality, Windows 11 keeps you in control—if you know where to look. With multiple avenues available for managing audio hardware, you can easily adapt your system setup to best fit your personal preferences, ensuring your PC sounds as good as it looks.
By staying informed on these settings and options, you ensure that your experience with Windows 11 remains both efficient and tailored to your needs. Enjoy fine-tuning your audio experience while keeping in mind that sometimes, the evolution of technology is all about striking the perfect balance between automation and manual control.

---

Source: The Windows Club Which device did you plug in message in Windows 11