A military-themed game case sits beside a PS5 and controller, with an ascending numbered bar chart in front.
Call of Duty: Black Ops II is a 2012 shooter. In 2026 it became one of the best-selling games in the US, and Xbox consoles got no new version of it. Circana's year-to-date chart through the September reporting period lists Black Ops II sixth and Forza Horizon 6 seventh, both with Microsoft as publisher. Pure Xbox noticed the oddity: a Microsoft-published game is thriving because of a PlayStation release.

A military-themed game case sits beside a PS5 and controller, with an ascending numbered bar chart in front. What the chart actually says​

The Circana data, shared by analyst Mat Piscatella, covers August 30 to October 3. The year-to-date window runs from January 4 to October 3, 2026. So "through September" is shorthand for a retail-calendar period that ends in early October.

The ranking is by dollars, not units or players. Piscatella's chart is a "projected" list of physical and full-game digital sales. It excludes mobile and digital add-on content. Black Ops II placing sixth means it earned more full-game US revenue than almost everything else this year. It does not say how many copies sold, how profitable the game was, or how many people play it.

One more caveat applies to Microsoft titles specifically. Pure Xbox reports that Xbox has reportedly pulled out of sharing digital sales data with Circana, so Xbox first-party sales may rely more on estimates. Circana's own charts mark most Microsoft entries with an asterisk for digital-sales projections. Treat the exact positions as informed estimates.

How a 2012 game got here​

The cause is a port. Circana said Black Ops II was projected as July's best-selling game in dollar sales, driven by a PlayStation port supporting PS4 and PS5. Its July rank last month was 67, and Black Ops sat at 150 before its own PlayStation port. Both were released that month.

In Circana's July year-to-date list, Black Ops II climbed from 130th to fifth after the PS4 and PS5 port arrived. GamesBeat reported that Iron Galaxy Studios handled the PlayStation releases and called the jump a sign of either the games' staying power or a thin July release slate.

Neither game moved in the September data: Black Ops II stayed 6th (last month #6) and Forza Horizon 6 stayed 7th (last month #7) on the year-to-date chart. The 5th-to-6th and 6th-to-7th movement happened one report earlier, in the August year-to-date chart (July YTD: Black Ops II 5th, Forza Horizon 6 6th; August YTD: 6th and 7th). The Gaming Amigos "last month" tags correctly matched the August ranks, and the "prior month 5th/6th" framing describes the August move, not September's. In other words, both games held their top-ten places month over month.

Two very different Microsoft hits​

The two Microsoft-published titles reached the top ten in different ways:

  • Forza Horizon 6 is a new 2026 game. It launched on Windows and Xbox Series X|S on 19 May 2026, with a PlayStation 5 release listed for 26 January 2027. On that basis, its chart run so far comes from Xbox and PC sales. It has no PS5 sales yet.
  • Black Ops II is a 14-year-old game. Its 2026 chart run is attributed to a PlayStation port.

That contrast is the real story. Microsoft's multiplatform strategy runs through catalog titles as well as new releases. Dollar sales from a PlayStation port count toward a Microsoft-published title even though Xbox hardware isn't involved.

Pure Xbox's argument, and its limits​

Writer Fraser Gilbert calls the ports a huge success. He notes that they are "largely untouched" and likely cheap to produce. He also points out that the Xbox 360 versions of both Black Ops games remain playable on Xbox through backward compatibility. In his view, the new PlayStation ports offer only minor advantages over those versions, not enough to justify asking Xbox players to pay again. A more thorough remaster, he suggests, might have justified selling the games on Xbox and PC too, though the extra cost might not have paid off.

That reasoning is plausible, but some of it is opinion rather than data.

  • The chart does not show profit. Port costs and revenue splits aren't public, so "cheap and wildly successful" is an inference.
  • "One of Xbox's biggest successes" is a headline framing. The data supports only a strong ranking for a Microsoft-published game, not a verdict on Xbox hardware or services.
  • The backward-compatibility point is fair for owners of the 360 versions. It says nothing about Xbox players who never owned them, or about PC buyers.

The hardware backdrop​

The surprise looks sharper next to September's console numbers. PS5 dollar sales rose 43% year over year, while Xbox Series dollar sales fell 2% and units dropped 27%. Circana said Xbox unit sales hit their lowest ever for a September. The average price paid per Xbox Series unit was $663, up 33% from $497 a year earlier.

Circana's wider commentary links the weakness in part to higher hardware prices driven by the RAM and component crisis. Pricey consoles and a strong PlayStation port are a notable pairing for Microsoft.

What to watch​

  • Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4, due in October, will compete for the chart positions Black Ops II holds now.
  • Grand Theft Auto VI, set for November 19 according to Gaming Amigos, is expected to reshuffle the software charts.
  • Forza Horizon 6 on PS5 in January 2027 will test whether the franchise's chart strength carries over to PlayStation.
  • Pure Xbox suggests World of Warcraft: Forever in November could repeat the pattern. That is speculation, not a sales result.

Bottom line​

Black Ops II's sixth-place finish is a real, sourced result: a 2012 game kept a top-six spot in Circana's projected US dollar-sales chart on the strength of a PlayStation port. It shows that Microsoft's catalog can earn well on rival platforms while Xbox console sales slump. It does not show profits, copies sold, or any change in Xbox hardware demand. Treat the "success" label as a chart result, not a company scorecard.


Correction (October 23, 2026): An earlier version of this article said Black Ops II slipped from fifth to sixth in the September year-to-date chart and Forza Horizon 6 dropped to seventh. Neither game moved between the August and September charts — both held their positions; the 5th-to-6th and 6th-to-7th shifts happened in the August report.

 

References

  1. Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 tops dismal July sales charts | Circana - GamesBeat gamesbeat.com
  2. One Of Xbox's Biggest Successes Of 2026 Didn't Actually Release On Series X|S - Pure Xbox Pure Xbox 2026-10-23T18:30:00+00:00
  3. Circana's Mat Piscatella Warns US Console Market Is Most Precarious Since Early 1980s, As Xbox Hardware Units Crash 33% wccftech.com