What the author reported
Onyimadu describes five complaints:
- Placeholders after a reinstall. The desktop looks complete, but the files aren't local yet.
- Sync-status icons. He found them visually cluttered.
- Conflict copies. He saw duplicates after edits on different devices.
- Uploads of large files. He says these can eat his upload bandwidth.
- Layout and shortcuts. Icon layouts shift between screens, and shortcuts tied to one PC's paths break on another.
His replacement is Nextcloud running in Docker containers, using Docker Compose, on an old laptop running Linux Mint. These are one person's experiences, not measurements. A few of his claims need qualifying, as explained below.
Why the desktop "comes back as a shell"
Two separate OneDrive features combine here.
Folder backup is the first. XDA-Developers describes it as the feature that redirects folders like Desktop and Documents into the OneDrive directory, so anything saved there is stored in OneDrive by default. Microsoft's support page says that when you back up the Desktop folder, the items on your desktop roam with you to your other desktops running OneDrive. It is a sync feature, not just a backup.
Files On-Demand is the second. Microsoft documents that the feature is enabled by default starting with OneDrive build 23.066. In that mode, files show up in File Explorer as online-only, and you can't open them without an internet connection. Microsoft also notes that new files or folders created online or on another device appear online-only. The exception is a folder you've marked "Always keep on this device".
Put together, a freshly restored desktop full of cloud-only items is expected behavior. It isn't a bug. It does catch people out, especially on a slow or absent connection.
Where the author's claims need qualifying
- "Always keep on this device" after a reset. The setting keeps files local while the device and its data are intact. It can't survive a wipe or reinstall, because the local copies are gone. The author's account of re-marking folders afterward is plausible, but it isn't OneDrive ignoring the setting.
- "Only pausing works" for bandwidth. Microsoft documents other controls. OneDrive's Advanced settings let you cap the upload and download rates. You can also choose which folders sync to a PC. Some options may be locked by an admin on work or school accounts.
- Conflict copies. Microsoft acknowledges that sync conflicts happen. They can follow edits made offline or on another PC that syncs at the same time. Its advice is to rename the edited file to something unique. Microsoft's pages don't confirm the "edits seconds apart" trigger or the exact naming pattern the author gives.
- Git and Dropbox "smart merge" comparison. The source doesn't back this up, so treat it as opinion.
- Plan limits. The author says oversized files fail silently to push upgrades. Microsoft's documented limit is a 250 GB maximum per synced file, which is separate from your total storage. I found no support for the upsell claim.
Nextcloud isn't conflict-free
Self-hosting changes who runs the infrastructure, not whether sync can go wrong. The research material says Nextcloud's own documentation describes conflict handling: when it can't reconcile local and remote changes, it keeps a conflict file with the local version, downloads the remote one and alerts the user.
Nextcloud's troubleshooting guide adds a warning. Synchronizing the same directory with Nextcloud and other sync software, or cloud services such as Dropbox, isn't supported. The guide says that in the worst case it can cause data loss. So don't point Nextcloud and OneDrive at the same folder.
You also take on responsibility for the following:
- Uptime. The server must be reachable for sync to work.
- Updates. You apply them yourself.
- Backups. Use independent backups. One laptop in a cupboard isn't a disaster-recovery plan.
Keep OneDrive but stop syncing the desktop
If you'd rather not run a server, this achieves most of what the author wanted.
- Select the OneDrive cloud icon in the notification area. Open Help & Settings, then Settings.
- Go to the Sync and backup tab and select Manage backup.
- Turn off the toggle for Desktop, or any other folder, and choose what happens to the files. Microsoft's page offers two options: keep the files only in OneDrive, or keep them only on the PC.
- If the folder contains cloud-only files, you may see a message that some files couldn't be moved. Microsoft's instruction is to download them first by setting them to Always keep on this device.
- Check the contents of your local Desktop afterward. Microsoft notes that files already backed up can stay in OneDrive, and you may need to drag them back manually. Don't delete anything until you've confirmed where the originals are.
Two practical extras:
- Selective sync. In Account settings, Choose folders controls which OneDrive folders sync to the PC.
- Bandwidth. Under Advanced settings, set upload and download rates.
Microsoft's own documentation also covers some failure points. Work and school accounts may have these options changed by IT, and macOS has extra prerequisites. File names with disallowed characters, over-long paths, and files over 250 GB can also block backup.
Before your next reinstall
- Keep important work in a normal local folder, or in a OneDrive folder marked Always keep on this device.
- Before travel or recovery work, make sure the files you need show the green check, not the cloud.
- After a reset, expect to re-mark folders for offline use.
- Keep a separate backup that doesn't depend on any single sync service.
Verdict
The author's frustration is real, and the folder-backup default catches people out. His conclusion goes further than the evidence does. Most of his problems come from combining Desktop roaming with on-demand files, and both can be adjusted in settings. Nextcloud gives you control and privacy, but you also take on the maintenance, and it still creates conflict files.
References
- I’ll never sync my entire desktop with OneDrive again — here’s the setup I use now MakeUseOf · 2026-10-25T13:00:17+00:00
- Troubleshooting — Nextcloud 35 Administration Manual docs.nextcloud.com
- Save disk space with OneDrive Files On-Demand for Windows | Microsoft Support support.microsoft.com