What the essay argues
The author's starting point is an unexplained disappearance of Outlook from her work computer. She says the lost email, calendar and meeting invitations made her ask how one supplier became so central to the working day. She then asks what that dependence costs financially and environmentally.
Her argument has four parts:
- The cloud has a physical footprint, in the form of electricity, cooling and hardware.
- Software support decisions can turn into hardware purchases.
- Switching costs are real and rarely counted.
- The practical goal is "freedom to choose" through portable data, open formats, repairable devices and contracts that don't penalise switching.
The piece doesn't claim that leaving Microsoft is easy or automatically greener. It says outright that migration has costs and that a rival is not necessarily greener. That restraint is worth keeping when you read the rest.
Checking the numbers
Data-centre energy: global figures, not Microsoft's
The essay cites the International Energy Agency's estimate of 415 TWh of data-centre electricity use in 2024. The IEA's own summary confirms that this is about 1.5% of world electricity consumption. Its base case projects consumption rising to around 945 TWh by 2030, with AI the most important driver alongside other digital services.
The caveat is that these are sector-wide numbers. They say nothing specific about Microsoft or about Outlook, Windows or Microsoft 365. The IEA also stresses large uncertainty. Its sensitivity cases for 2035 range from about 700 TWh to about 1,700 TWh, depending on AI uptake, efficiency gains and energy-sector bottlenecks. Treat 945 TWh as a base-case projection, not a forecast carved in stone.
Microsoft's 25% emissions rise: confirmed
The essay's claim that Microsoft's total emissions rose 25% is supported. In its 2026 Environmental Sustainability Report, Microsoft said total Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions rose 25% year over year. It attributed that mainly to datacenter expansion and to pausing its use of non-additional, unbundled renewable energy certificates. The company says the report covers fiscal year 2025 and measures progress against a 2020 baseline.
Some details sharpen the picture:
- Scope 3 remains the largest share of the footprint, but Scope 2 now represents 13% of total emissions, up from nearly 2% the year before.
- One trade outlet reports total emissions of 20.3 million metric tons of CO2 equivalent for the 12 months ending June 2025.
- Microsoft says the certificate change raises reported emissions in the near term but supports development of new carbon-free energy rather than relying on certificates alone.
So the rise is partly real growth and partly an accounting choice that Microsoft says it made deliberately. The essay's phrasing, "primarily because of expanding data centres and a change in renewable-energy certificate accounting", matches the company's own explanation.
Critics read the numbers differently. Stand.earth, an advocacy group, says gross emissions have risen by about 80% since 2020 and that electricity consumption has surged 244%. That is the group's analysis, not Microsoft's framing. It does show that the one-year jump sits inside a longer upward trend.
Windows 10 and the hardware bill
The essay links software support to device replacement. It notes that regular Windows 10 support ended in October 2025, with extended security updates available to eligible consumer devices through October 2027. The author is careful here. She says the transition doesn't make every older machine obsolete, only that support and compatibility can influence replacement decisions.
The e-waste figures she uses are accurate but global. The UN's Global E-waste Monitor 2024, from ITU and UNITAR, reports that the world generated 62 million tonnes of e-waste in 2022, up 82% from 2010. It adds that 22.3% was documented as properly collected and recycled. The report points to limited repair options and shorter product life cycles among the drivers of the widening gap.
None of this shows that a Windows support deadline caused any particular quantity of e-waste. The report covers all electronics, from toys to solar panels. The fair reading is narrower. Device lifetimes matter in climate terms, and IT buyers control some of them.
Regulators are now on the same topic
The strongest verifiable link between the essay and enterprise IT is the UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA). The essay mentions the March 2026 announcement. The story has since moved on.
31 March 2026. The CMA said its board would launch a strategic market status (SMS) investigation into Microsoft's business software ecosystem, starting in May. The same announcement said Microsoft and Amazon had taken steps on cloud egress fees and interoperability, subject to ongoing review.
16 October 2026. The CMA proposed to designate Microsoft with SMS in its business software ecosystem. It will consult before a final decision. Its provisional findings say Microsoft has a strong position in five areas it examined:
- PC operating systems
- Productivity suites
- Security software
- Server operating systems
- Relational database management systems
The CMA also says the findings are provisional and subject to consultation, with a final designation decision due by the February 2027 statutory deadline. It adds that SMS designation does not assume wrongdoing. A designation could allow targeted interventions such as conduct requirements.
The October update lists areas for further scrutiny:
- Whether customers can freely pick AI tools, and whether rival AI providers compete on a level field with Copilot.
- Whether Microsoft's bundling and integration of security products limits choice.
- Whether customers have effective choice over which cloud hosts their Microsoft licences, and how licensing practices affect that choice.
On cloud switching, the CMA says Microsoft and AWS have made concrete changes:
- Completely removing data-transfer fees for customers changing cloud providers, and reducing them for customers using more than one cloud.
- Connecting data centres with rivals, starting with Google.
- Introducing a mechanism to request greater interoperability.
- Rolling out AI tools to automate technical switching steps.
It also says barriers remain. It singles out identity and access management across clouds and the portability of cloud architectures. A further update is planned for spring 2027.
Microsoft's side deserves a mention. In its submission to the CMA, the company argued that the product areas under review are distinct, face competition, and shouldn't be treated as one ecosystem. That is the company's position, not a finding.
Where the essay stretches
The essay says a buyer unable to change providers may struggle to choose lower-emission computing. It labels this a potential consequence, not a demonstrated one. That is the right label. The CMA material establishes competition and interoperability concerns. It does not link them to measured emissions.
There is also a gap in the framing. Her opening anecdote is about service continuity, meaning what happens when a tool vanishes. The rest is about supplier choice and environmental impact. These are three separate problems with different fixes. A multi-vendor strategy might help with the second and do little for the first or third.
What admins can take from it
You don't need to accept the climate framing to use the practical points. A sensible dependency review might include:
- Inventory essential services. List which workflows stop if mail, calendar, identity or file storage goes down, and who owns the fallback.
- Test data portability. Check that you can export mail, documents and configuration in open or well-documented formats, and time how long it takes.
- Map identity dependencies. The CMA itself highlights identity and access management as a cross-cloud sticking point.
- Read the licensing terms. Check where licences can be deployed and what switching or multi-cloud usage costs. Egress fees have been cut, but your contract may differ from the headline changes.
- Plan device lifecycles. For Windows 10 machines, weigh ESU eligibility, replacement cost and repair or reuse options. Don't assume replacement is the only route.
- Ask for emissions data. Compare lifetime costs and credible reporting, not only the next renewal quote.
The essay mentions Thunderbird and LibreOffice as possible alternatives. They may suit some workplaces, but they bring migration, training and compatibility costs of their own. No evidence here shows they are greener or cheaper at scale.
Bottom line
The essay is a thoughtful opinion piece, not breaking news. Its Microsoft emissions claim checks out against the company's own report. Its energy and e-waste figures are real but global. Its regulatory point is now stronger than when she wrote it, since the CMA has moved from announcing an investigation to proposing SMS designation. What remains unproven is any direct causal link between vendor lock-in and extra carbon.
Next up is the CMA's final designation decision, due by February 2027. For IT teams, the useful exercise is the dull one: find out what you would do if a core Microsoft service disappeared, and what it would cost you to leave.
References
- Could You Survive Without Microsoft? The Cost of Digital Dependence - The Quint The Quint · 2026-11-17T08:08:44+00:00
- Microsoft's sustainability report discloses 80% emissions increase since 2020, reveals energy demand rivaling Denmark, leaves out massive new fossil gas buildout that will double company’s pollution: analysis - Stand.earth stand.earth
- Microsoft’s data center expansion drove 25% emissions spike in 2025: report esgdive.com