The pitch in brief
Kanellakos admits up front that a standalone player has real advantages, including better audiovisual fidelity and broader disc-format support. He also gives up Dolby Vision on discs. His argument rests on three points:
- Looks and mechanics. Most dedicated players are anonymous black boxes, while the PS5 and Xbox Series X have distinctive designs. Consoles also use slot-loading drives, which he finds more luxurious than the trays on most mid-range players.
- Controllers over remotes. He dislikes bundled infrared remotes with their streaming-service buttons and narrow line of sight. He prefers the DualSense and the Xbox gamepad, which connect over radio.
- Two machines in one. A console plays games and movies, which makes it more versatile than a player that only handles discs.
He closes with a prediction that disc drives on consoles are on borrowed time, so now is a good moment to buy one that has a drive. Design and ergonomics are matters of taste. The article gives no measurements or reliability testing, so treat those points as his experience, not as established advantages.
A correction: Xbox Series S has no disc drive
The article names "XBOX Series X/S" as consoles for 4K UHD playback. That is wrong for the S. Microsoft's own product page describes the difference this way: Series X is available with a UHD Blu-ray player, while Series S is designed for disc-free gaming. The Series X specification lists the 4K UHD Blu-ray optical drive on the disc-equipped models, such as Carbon Black and the 2TB Galaxy Black Special Edition. The page also lists a 1TB Digital Edition, which has no drive.
The trade press says the same. What Hi-Fi? noted that both this generation's Xbox and PlayStation have standardised 4K Blu-ray support, provided you have a console with a disc drive, with the Series S the exception. Forbes put it plainly: an Xbox Series X, but not a Series S, doubles as a 4K Blu-ray movie disc player.
Buyer's checklist for Xbox:
- Check that the model is a Series X, not a Series S.
- Confirm that it is a disc-drive configuration, not the Digital Edition.
- Don't assume every Series X in a retailer listing includes the drive.
PlayStation 5: the drive is the whole story
Sony's PS5 FAQ says nothing new is needed here, only a drive. It states that the PS5 version with a Blu-ray disc drive supports video playback from 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Discs, standard Blu-rays, and DVDs. The Digital Edition does not support any optical discs. Sony also says the only difference between the two models is the Ultra HD Blu-ray drive. The evidence gathered for this article also indicates that some newer Digital Edition Slim models can be paired with a separately sold drive. That requires an internet connection for initial pairing, so check the exact model before buying.
The Dolby Vision caveat, in more detail
The author says he gives up Dolby Vision playback. That is accurate, and the limitation is a distinct one. Xbox's product page lists Dolby Vision for games and Dolby Vision media streaming, which is a different thing from playing a Dolby Vision UHD disc.
Independent outlets say the console falls short here:
- TechRadar reports that Dolby Vision support for games and streaming doesn't carry over to Blu-ray playback, and neither Dolby Vision nor HDR10+ works with 4K Blu-rays, leaving only standard HDR10.
- Tom's Guide says the PS5 does not support Dolby Vision for games, streaming or Blu-rays, and that on the Xbox a Dolby Vision-mastered Blu-ray plays back as stock HDR10.
These articles date from the early life of the consoles. I did not find a more recent source confirming that anything has changed, so check current specifications before you buy.
How much this matters depends on your TV. TechRadar's point is that if your TV supports neither format, you aren't missing much with either a console or a standalone player. The same article says someone with shelves of UHD discs and a Dolby Vision or HDR10+ TV will do better with a standalone player.
Console playback quality is not a settled win
Kanellakos does not claim consoles beat standalone players on picture quality, but readers should know the independent evidence is mixed:
- TechRadar covered an audio-visual expert's testing which concluded that the PS5 takes the crown over the Xbox Series X for 4K Blu-ray playback. It also reported that the PS5 avoids the occasional stutter or frame-rate hitch that the Series X is prone to.
- Tom's Guide's reviewer did not experience major playback issues on the Series X but noted limitations as a part-time Blu-ray player.
- On audio, the Series X lists Dolby TrueHD with Atmos and DTS 5.1 support. Sony says Dolby Atmos and DTS:X are available for Blu-ray and Ultra HD Blu-ray video when connected to a supported device. What Hi-Fi? says both consoles support playback of all the audio formats currently found on 4K Blu-rays.
The fair reading is that a console is a good-enough player for casual viewing. A big physical collection and a premium TV change that calculation.
What Sony actually announced about discs
The article says Sony will end game-disc production for the PS5 "starting in 2027" and calls a disc-less PS6 "extremely likely". Neither point is accurate or established.
- Sony's July 1, 2026 PlayStation Blog post says physical game disc production for all new games releasing on PlayStation consoles will be discontinued starting January 2028. The date is January 2028, not 2027.
- The post adds that the change doesn't affect games already released, or released before January 2028, on disc.
- The announcement concerns new game discs. It says nothing about movie discs, about PS5 consoles losing movie playback, or about the specifications of any next-generation hardware.
The PS6 prediction is speculation, and so is Kanellakos's guess about a digital-only Xbox. The game-disc announcement is no evidence that movie playback on current consoles is going away. Existing consoles with drives should keep playing the discs they play now.
Who should actually buy a console for discs?
A disc-equipped console makes sense if:
- You want one box for games and the occasional movie.
- Your TV doesn't do Dolby Vision or HDR10+ on discs.
- You value convenience over squeezing out every last bit of picture performance.
A standalone player makes more sense if:
- You have a large UHD collection and a Dolby Vision or HDR10+ display.
- You want the most reliable picture and sound.
- You want to avoid console updates and an interface designed around games.
Bottom line
Kanellakos's argument holds up as a statement of taste. A disc-equipped Xbox Series X or PS5 is a convenient way to play UHD discs and games from one box. Before you buy, make sure the console has a drive, that it isn't a Series S, and that you accept the lack of Dolby Vision on discs. Sony's disc announcement covers new game production only, not movies or future hardware.
References
- Is the Xbox Series X a good 4K Blu-ray player? techradar.com
- PS5 Vs Xbox Series X 4K Blu-Ray Player Showdown forbes.com
- PS5 has a better 4K Blu-Ray player than Xbox Series X techradar.com