A router links a laptop, TV, and external drive, with graphics illustrating secure wireless file sharing.
That USB port on the back of your router can turn a spare drive into a shared folder in minutes. It works, but it comes with trade-offs. Some are about performance. Others are about Windows compatibility and data safety. How-To Geek's Arol Wright argues the "free NAS" is a bad idea for anything beyond light use. The vendor documentation and Microsoft guidance support a more qualified version of that argument.

A router links a laptop, TV, and external drive, with graphics illustrating secure wireless file sharing. What the router feature actually is​

Router USB sharing is a real, vendor-documented feature. The names differ by brand, and so do the menus.

  • Netgear: ReadySHARE. Netgear's documentation says compatible routers can share a connected USB device with wired and wireless users. Windows users reach it by entering \readyshare in Explorer. The same page says a drive that needs its own power supply must be powered, and that a drive requiring special drivers will not be compatible. Netgear also says it can take up to two minutes before a newly attached drive is ready.
  • TP-Link: USB Sharing. TP-Link documents local access over Samba (SMB) and remote access over FTP. Its guidance says only FTP works remotely. It recommends enabling the Secure Sharing option so a login is required.
  • ASUS: AiDisk and the USB Application menu. ASUS documents FTP sharing, including an internet-facing mode that uses DDNS. It offers three access levels, from admin-only to no authentication.

Treat these as examples, not universal specs. Menu names, protocols and defaults vary by model and firmware.

Performance: what is documented and what is anecdote​

The central claim is that a router's CPU has to handle the file system, the Samba server and the network transfer together. That is plausible, and TP-Link's own troubleshooting guide supports part of it. It says USB transfer speeds depend on the router's CPU performance and on network connection stability. It adds that speeds may be lower than when the same drive is plugged straight into a computer. TP-Link's suggested fixes are:

  1. Update the router firmware.
  2. Use a router with better specs, such as USB 3.0 ports, and a good-quality drive.
  3. Use wired Ethernet instead of Wi-Fi.

Two caveats apply. First, I found no independent measurement showing that a large copy saturates a router CPU and degrades unrelated traffic like calls or gaming. That is a reasonable risk on weak hardware, but it isn't a measured universal outcome. Second, router performance varies widely.

  • A high-end example: TP-Link published a test of the Archer AX80 after a firmware update. It used a USB SSD and a PC on the router's 2.5G port. The company reported Samba reads up to about 290 MB/s and writes around 120 MB/s. That is one vendor-run test on one model, not a typical result.
  • A low-end example: A user on the same forum reported about 7 MB/s through a European AX80 on a gigabit wired link. The same HDD gave 80-90 MB/s when plugged directly into a laptop. That is a single anecdote, but it shows how far results can diverge.

So "a router NAS is slow" is true for many setups and false for some. Firmware, drive, port type and workload all matter.

The Windows angle: SMBv1 and SMB signing​

The article is right to flag SMBv1, but the details need care. Microsoft says SMBv1 is deprecated and was publicly deprecated in 2014. It also says the protocol has been uninstalled by default since Windows 10 version 1709, with the exact behavior depending on edition and install path. Windows 11 does not include the SMBv1 client or server by default after a clean install. Microsoft strongly recommends not reinstalling it, and says to update the server that still requires it. In practice, if a router share only works after you enable SMBv1 on a PC, that is a warning sign.

There is also a newer boundary that matters more for current PCs.

  • Microsoft's documentation says Windows 11 24H2 and Windows Server 2025 require SMB signing by default.
  • Microsoft says this can block connections to workgroup computers, guest-authenticated shares, and third-party SMB servers that don't support signing.
  • Its advice is not to disable SMB versions or signing as a workaround. Instead, enable signing on the server, or update or replace the device.

This was flagged before 24H2 shipped. The Register reported Microsoft's Ned Pyle warning that accessing some third-party NAS devices, or a USB drive plugged into certain routers, might fail. He said SMB signing is now required by default on all connections, and guest fallback is disabled on Windows 11 Pro.

Community reports show how this plays out on router shares. One TP-Link forum user on Windows 11 Pro 24H2 found Samba copies very slow. After changing three settings, speed rose from 7 MB/s to 154 MB/s. The user said they couldn't tell which setting made the difference. Those settings included enabling SMBv1 and relaxing signing and guest rules, which is the opposite of Microsoft's guidance. Treat that as a data point and not as a recommendation.

Be careful with the cause here. Forum threads blame 24H2 signing for slow NAS transfers, but those are user reports. They aren't a Microsoft-confirmed explanation for any specific router. The practical takeaway is narrower. If a router share fails or crawls on Windows 11 24H2 or later, signing and guest-access policy are the first things to suspect. Weakening them is a trade-off, not a free fix.

Remote access and backups​

Remote access is where the risk goes up. Both TP-Link and ASUS document internet-facing FTP. ASUS exposes controls for WAN access and anonymous login. Router firmware often gets few updates. Unless you have a specific need, leave remote access off. If you do enable it, use authenticated accounts with limited permissions.

A shared drive also isn't a backup. CISA's backup guidance recommends the 3-2-1 approach: three copies of data, on two media types, with one copy off-site. A single disk on a router can't meet that on its own. ASUS warns users to safely remove USB disks to avoid data corruption. TP-Link's forum also has users reporting drives that appear empty after moving between router and computer. Those are anecdotes, but they fit the case for keeping other copies.

A practical checklist​

  1. Check your model's manual. Look up supported file systems, protocols and permission options. TP-Link says NTFS is preferred for most users, and exFAT or HFS+ may suit macOS.
  2. Update the firmware first. Vendors have shipped USB-specific performance fixes, as the AX80 example shows.
  3. Test with a throwaway file. Do this before moving anything important.
  4. Use wired Ethernet for big copies. It's the simplest improvement TP-Link recommends.
  5. Turn on authentication. Use Secure Sharing or equivalent accounts, and keep remote FTP off unless needed.
  6. Don't enable SMBv1 on your PC to rescue an old router share. Update or replace the router or drive host instead.
  7. Keep a second copy elsewhere. Treat the router drive as convenience storage.

When to move on​

How-To Geek's rule of thumb holds up. Occasional document sharing, or streaming one video to a TV, is a fair use of a router USB port. Daily use, backup jobs, several simultaneous streams, or a Windows 11 24H2 client that can't connect cleanly all point to a dedicated device. That could be an entry-level NAS, a mini PC or a Raspberry Pi. The "ruined my network" framing is the author's experience, not a universal result. The risks are real, but how much they matter depends on your router and your use.

 

References

  1. Plugging a drive into my router gave me a free NAS. It also ruined my network How-To Geek 2026-10-31T18:30:15+00:00
  2. (Wireless Router) How to access a USB disk connected to ASUS router - AiDisk? | Official Support | ASUS UK asus.com
  3. Troubleshooting Guide for USB Storage Devices on Wi-Fi Routers - Home Network Community community.tp-link.com