The trigger: a $12 renewal bump
The 1Password price increase took effect on March 27, with Individual annual plans rising from $35.88 to $47.88 and Family plans from $59.88 to $71.88. That is how 9to5Mac reported it in February 2026. The new price applies at the next renewal on or after that date. Renewals before March 27 stayed at the old rate until the following one.
Mahmood's roughly $239 over five years is simple arithmetic: $47.88 multiplied by five, assuming no further increases. It is not a forecast. He also says his real usage was narrow: browser autofill, 2FA codes stored beside logins, Watchtower alerts and a few passkeys. He never used shared vaults, Travel Mode or sharing links. That is his own audit, and your list may look different.
The migration path
His switch relies on 1Password's own export format and KeePassXC's import support.
- Export: 1Password's support documentation says 1Password 8 exports to its unencrypted .1pux format or to CSV. The CSV option covers only a limited set of fields. 1Password describes .1pux as a ZIP archive built on JSON, which preserves the data structure more accurately than CSV.
- Import: KeePassXC's user guide lists 1Password .1pux among its supported import formats. Mahmood describes the route as Database, then Import, then 1Password Export, then checking the preview and finishing.
- Result, per the author: each 1Password vault became a KeePassXC group. He reports that logins, notes, tags, attachments, favorites, archived items and TOTP codes came across, with no QR rescans. I couldn't independently confirm field-by-field fidelity, so test your own vault before you cancel anything.
The security step that matters most
Both 1Password and KeePassXC warn about the same thing. The exported file is not encrypted. 1Password says exported files are stored in plaintext, so anyone with access can read your passwords. It says not to email them or store them online, and to delete them when you are done.
Practical handling:
- Export to a local folder, not a synced one such as OneDrive or Desktop sync.
- Import into KeePassXC and spot-check several entries, including ones with TOTP and attachments.
- Delete the .1pux file and empty the Recycle Bin. Mahmood advises doing exactly that.
- Keep your 1Password subscription active until you've verified the import and made a backup of the new vault.
The exact menu path for exporting varies by platform. 1Password's documentation gives different steps for Mac, Windows and Linux, so follow the instructions for your own app.
Passkeys: the real catch
Passkeys do not travel with a desktop export. 1Password's help page says passkeys can be exported only from its iOS and Android apps "at this time". For desktop exports, it advises creating new passkeys on each site and saving them somewhere else. 1Password's iOS and Android apps use the Credential Exchange standard, which it says can move passkeys directly to other supported apps. That standard needs iOS or iPadOS 26 or later, or Android 14 or later.
So Mahmood's re-registration advice is correct for the desktop route he took. It doesn't mean KeePassXC can't hold passkeys. Its user guide has a dedicated Passkeys section covering browser passkey support, creating a new passkey and logging in with one. That works through the KeePassXC-Browser extension.
The 2FA comparison with Bitwarden
Mahmood says he passed over Bitwarden partly because its free plan doesn't generate 2FA codes inside the vault. That is true if you read it narrowly. Bitwarden's plan page lists the integrated authenticator (TOTP) as a Premium feature. Bitwarden's own press release says it also offers a free standalone authenticator app. Bitwarden Authenticator is a separate standalone app anyone can install for free. The integrated version is a TOTP field inside a login item, available to Premium or organization accounts.
The accurate version is that free Bitwarden won't show codes next to your logins, but a free separate authenticator app exists. That is a convenience gap, not a missing capability.
Pricing also matters here. One 2026 pricing roundup puts Bitwarden Premium at $1.65 a month, or $19.80 a year. That is well below 1Password's $47.88. Bitwarden also gives you hosted sync and a managed experience that KeePassXC does not. "Free" and "cheap" are different trade-offs.
What KeePassXC asks of you
KeePassXC is built for people who don't want an online service holding their passwords. Its documentation says it deliberately has no built-in cloud sync. It suggests putting the database file in a Dropbox, Google Drive, OneDrive, Nextcloud or similar folder and letting that service sync it. It also says it has no mobile app of its own. For Android it recommends KeePassDX, which matches what Mahmood uses.
His setup, in summary:
- Vault location: a single .kdbx file in OneDrive, which he already pays for through Microsoft 365.
- Safety net: OneDrive version history for bad saves or accidental deletions, plus an offline copy on a USB drive.
- Mobile: KeePassDX opening the same file on Android.
- Alternative: Syncthing, if you want to keep the vault off the cloud entirely.
Some caveats are my own analysis, not his claims. Cloud sync of a single file is simple, but it's not a purpose-built sync engine. Editing the vault on two devices at once can produce conflict copies, so open and save deliberately and check that the sync client has finished before switching devices. OneDrive version history is a safety net. It is not a substitute for a backup you have tested.
There is no account, so there is no recovery. Mahmood says no one can reset a forgotten master password. KeePassXC's FAQ also warns that if you use a key file and lose it, you lose the database. Back up the key file separately.
The KeePassXC FAQ is also candid on one more point. Storing TOTP secrets in the same database as your passwords weakens the benefit of two-factor authentication, though the team says it is still better than no 2FA. Its security advice is to keep TOTP secrets in a separate database with a different password. Mahmood's one-vault setup trades some of that separation for convenience, and that is a trade each reader should make knowingly.
Windows features worth knowing
- Health Check: Mahmood says the Database Reports feature flagged two old accounts that shared a weak password. He uses it as his Watchtower stand-in. It is not a one-to-one match for Watchtower's breach alerts, and I haven't compared their coverage.
- Windows Hello: he enabled it so he doesn't type the master password every time. Treat that as a convenience layer. Your master credentials must still be strong, remembered and backed up.
- Edge: KeePassXC's documentation covers its browser extension, and the extension is the route for autofill and passkeys.
- Screenshot protection: by default, KeePassXC blocks recordings and screenshots of its window on Windows and macOS. This will surprise anyone writing a how-to, and it protects you in meetings.
Who should and shouldn't switch
| Situation | Better fit |
|---|---|
| One person, Windows and Android, comfortable managing a file | KeePassXC with a synced .kdbx |
| Shared family vaults | 1Password or another hosted manager |
| Need a recovery path if you forget the master password | A hosted manager |
| Heavy passkey use, especially from the desktop app | Plan for re-registration, or use mobile export |
| Want free, hosted sync | Bitwarden Free, with a separate authenticator app |
Mahmood's own judgments, that KeePassXC is the better open-source pick and that 1Password's apps are more polished, are opinions. His claim that the switch cost one afternoon is a single data point. A large vault with many passkeys will take longer.
Bottom line
The save is real: $47.88 a year drops to nothing. What you pay instead is time, backup discipline and sole responsibility for your master password. The plaintext export is the most dangerous step, and the passkey gap is the most irritating. Both are manageable if you plan for them. If those trade-offs sound unappealing, a cheaper hosted manager is the safer middle road.
References
- I ditched 1Password for an open-source password manager and I'm not paying again MakeUseOf · 2026-10-31T14:31:16+00:00
- 1Password announces big price increases coming next month - 9to5Mac 9to5mac.com
- About the 1Password Unencrypted Export format | 1Password Support support.1password.com