Illustration of secure data transfer between laptops and phones, with locks, shields, and encrypted-file icons.
Bitwarden and Proton Pass are both solid password managers. The real question in this MakeUseOf piece is whether built-in email aliases are worth a migration. Writer Oluwademilade Afolabi says they were. He moved his vault from Bitwarden to Proton Pass because he was tired of handing his real email address to every app he tried. This article covers what he did, what Proton's own documentation confirms, and what to watch before you copy him.

Illustration of secure data transfer between laptops and phones, with locks, shields, and encrypted-file icons. The pitch: one tool for passwords and throwaway addresses​

Afolabi's complaint isn't about Bitwarden's vault. By his account it organised his logins and has plenty of security settings. His problem is that every new signup still got his real address, often from a service he'd forget by the weekend.

Proton Pass offers "hide-my-email" aliases inside the password manager. He says that on a registration form the extension offers either his regular address or a pre-generated random alias, without opening the extension. The mobile flow is similar: tap the email field, open Proton Pass, tap the plus button and choose Hide my email.

Mail sent to the alias is forwarded to your real inbox, so confirmation codes still arrive. If an alias starts attracting promo mail, you can switch it off. Afolabi warns against disabling one you still need for password resets.

Bitwarden can also do aliases. Afolabi acknowledges that it integrates with SimpleLogin, Addy.io, Firefox Relay and others. Those integrations usually mean setting up the outside service and pasting in an API key. His argument is about convenience: with Proton, alias creation sits inside the vault. That is a preference, not a measured result.

How the migration works​

Proton documents a two-stage process: export from Bitwarden, then import into Proton Pass. Menu labels differ slightly between sources, so go by what you see on screen.

  1. Bitwarden's export feature is designed for backups or for moving data, including logins and notes. In the Bitwarden browser extension, Proton's guide says to go to Settings → Tools → Export vault. Afolabi describes the path as Settings > Vault options > Export, so the exact labels may vary by client or version.
  2. Choose .json as the file format, enter your master password and confirm. Proton's guide says a warning box appears, and you click Export vault to download the file to your default downloads folder.
  3. In the Proton Pass browser extension, open the menu and go to Settings → Import. Pick Bitwarden as the provider, drag in or choose the JSON file, and click Import.
  4. Spot-check a sample of logins and notes before you switch off Bitwarden's autofill.

Afolabi says Proton Pass reported all 188 of his items imported, and the passwords and notes he checked were intact. That is one person's experience, not a guarantee.

The plaintext file problem​

The standard JSON export is not encrypted. Bitwarden's own guidance says CSV and standard JSON exports remain unencrypted, so anyone with access to the file could read it. Bitwarden also says the original exported file should be deleted afterward.

Bitwarden recommends its encrypted JSON option for backups. I can't confirm that Proton Pass can import that encrypted format. Proton's instructions only specify the plain .json file. For a migration, follow Proton's route and treat the file as radioactive.

On a Windows PC, that means:

  • Save it somewhere that isn't synced, so not a OneDrive or Google Drive folder. Afolabi flags this specifically.
  • Delete it as soon as the import is verified, then empty the Recycle Bin.
  • Avoid emailing it or leaving it on a shared machine.

What may not come across​

  • Folders. Proton's folder documentation confirms that you can import items but your folder structure won't be preserved, and says folder imports are planned. Creating folders afterward is a separate limit: Proton says folders are available on Pass Plus and other paid plans, but not on Proton Free or Pass Essentials. So the loss of structure is an import limitation, and the inability to rebuild it for free is a plan limitation.
  • Organisation data. Bitwarden's documentation separates individual-vault exports from organisation exports. Organisations export data from the web app and CLI as a separate process. If you keep work or shared credentials in Bitwarden, don't assume a personal export captured them.
  • Passkeys and unusual items. Bitwarden says only .json exports include stored passkeys and SSH keys, and that .csv exports omit cards and identities. Afolabi also suggests checking passkeys and odd entries separately. A successful import message doesn't prove completeness.
  • Trash and Sends. Bitwarden's help material says exports don't include trash items or Sends. That comes from the research notes, because the Bitwarden help page itself couldn't be retrieved.

Setting up autofill on phones​

Afolabi's mobile steps are:

  • Android: install Proton Pass, sign in, and go to Profile > Autofill to enable it as your password manager.
  • iPhone: select Proton Pass under Settings > General > AutoFill & Passwords.

Free versus paid​

Proton's pricing page lists the Free plan with unlimited logins, notes and cards, unlimited devices, a password generator, 10 hide-my-email aliases, weak and reused password alerts, passkey support, and easy password import. Pass Plus adds:

  • Unlimited aliases
  • A built-in 2FA authenticator
  • Secure vault and link sharing
  • Dark web monitoring
  • File attachments
  • Folders and subfolders
  • Emergency access
  • Custom domains for aliases
  • Additional mailboxes for aliases
  • The ability to start an email from an alias
  • A command-line interface

Prices are unsettled. Afolabi quotes $2.99 a month billed annually, or $4.99 month-to-month. The pricing page I could retrieve shows $4.99 struck through with a promotional $1.99 a month. It says the first 12 months cost $23.88, then renew at $35.88 a year. That annual renewal works out to $2.99 a month, which matches Afolabi's figure. Promotions change, so check the page before buying.

The 2FA limit is unverified. Afolabi says the Free plan handles two-factor codes for up to three items. The pricing page I could retrieve lists the built-in authenticator under Pass Plus and doesn't mention a free allowance. I wouldn't rely on the three-item number without checking Proton's current plan details.

His security advice holds up either way. He'd still keep codes for his most important accounts in a separate authenticator app. If someone breaches a vault holding both passwords and one-time codes, they get both factors in one place. That is his opinion, but it is a widely shared principle.

Security backing​

Proton says Pass is end-to-end encrypted, open source and independently audited. I can't use that line as support for anything beyond the vendor's claim. Proton's account of the 2026 audit says Recurity Labs tested the browser extensions, mobile and desktop apps, and the command-line interface between January and April 2026. Proton reports the firm found no remote exploits and no encryption bypasses. It also says the report had observations about how secrets are managed in memory, and that desktop memory-handling issues were resolved on retest.

Treat that as Proton's summary of the audit. It isn't a replacement for reading the full report, which Proton says it publishes.

Bitwarden is also open source and independently audited, and it supports self-hosting. Afolabi says so himself, and says Bitwarden isn't a bad password manager.

Who should switch?​

  • Proton Pass fits if you sign up for lots of services, want aliases in the same place as your credentials, and can live with its folder rules and plan tiers.
  • Bitwarden fits if you want to self-host, already use an alias provider, or rely on organisation vaults and folders on a free plan.

An alias hides your address from a website. It doesn't make an account anonymous, and it doesn't replace a strong, unique password and two-factor authentication on the accounts that matter. Afolabi's verdict is that Proton Pass fixes his particular annoyance better, not that Bitwarden has failed. A "better" password manager depends on which problem you're trying to solve.

 

References

  1. I don't use Bitwarden anymore because I found something better MakeUseOf 2026-11-17T15:31:17+00:00
  2. How to import from Bitwarden to Proton Pass | Proton proton.me
  3. Using folders in Proton Pass | Proton proton.me