The build
The author's Dell OptiPlex is a mini tower with two internal 3.5-inch bays and two external 5.25-inch bays. The source text says he removed the optical drive and bought two 5.25-to-3.5-inch bay adapters. That turned the external bays into regular hard drive slots.
- Drives: four 8 TB drives, which gives 32 TB of raw labeled capacity.
- SATA ports: the motherboard already had four, so he didn't need an extra controller. He says an HBA card would have been the fix if it hadn't.
- Power: the power supply was short of connectors for the two extra drives. A SATA power splitter solved it.
- Pool layout: he wanted all four drives in a RAIDZ1 pool.
- OS location: every SATA port was taken, so he ran TrueNAS from a flash drive. He plugged it into an internal motherboard USB header through a header-to-USB-A adapter, which he thought tidier than a drive hanging off the case.
The article doesn't give the OptiPlex model, CPU, RAM amount, TrueNAS version, network speed, power draw, benchmarks or time in service. Treat it as one person's working setup, not a measured comparison.
Why he prefers it to an appliance
His argument is about headroom. He says many dedicated NAS boxes use energy-efficient, underpowered CPUs with just enough RAM for file serving. His repurposed PC has spare RAM for Docker containers and the occasional virtual machine. He also says its older x86 CPU can handle some Plex transcoding.
Cost is the other half. He already owned the tower, so he only bought the drives and a few inexpensive adapters. No prices are given, so the savings can't be quantified. He also says appliances carry a premium for their compact design and convenience.
He doesn't dismiss appliances. He credits Synology and QNAP with hot-swappable bays, a quiet chassis and simple software. He recommends them to most ordinary consumers. He recommends the DIY route to home-lab and self-hosting people who already have spare hardware.
Where the documentation pushes back
The USB boot drive. The build worked for the author, but TrueNAS doesn't recommend it. The official installation guide says the installer recommends SATA, SAS, or NVMe flash media and discourages USB flash drives. The CORE hardware guide explains why. It says USB drive quality varies widely, and modern TrueNAS versions perform increased drive writes to the boot pool. The same guide says you do not need an SSD boot device, but a spinner or a USB stick is discouraged.
If you copy this build, the better-supported route is a small SSD for the OS. The installer also lets you select more than one drive to mirror the boot device for redundancy. A community forum reply notes that mirroring the boot pool can mitigate flash unreliability a little. That is a user's opinion, not official guidance. The catch is that this build used every SATA port for data drives. A boot SSD would need a spare port, an add-in controller, or an M.2 slot if the board has one. On a different machine, a mirrored pair of decent boot devices is a sensible target.
RAIDZ1 and large drives. TrueNAS describes RAIDZ1 as "Good capacity efficiency, single-disk fault tolerance". That's the documented trade-off, and it means one failed disk is survivable. Usable space will be well below 32 TB because one disk's worth goes to parity, plus ZFS overhead. The TrueNAS capacity calculator can estimate the exact figure.
Some third-party guides are more cautious about RAIDZ1 with big disks. One hardware guide says to avoid it with 8 TB-plus drives because resilver times can be long. Another says it keeps an array alive through a single disk failure. These are the opinions of individual publishers, not TrueNAS rules. The practical point is that rebuilding after a failure takes time, and a second failure during that window loses the pool. RAIDZ2 or mirrors are the more conservative choice for large drives.
RAID is not backup. The author doesn't say whether he keeps a separate copy of the photos and documents on this box. One redundant disk won't protect against deletion, malware, theft or a pool-level failure. One third-party guide lists an independent local or off-site copy for that reason. Keep a second copy of anything irreplaceable.
Checklist before you try it
- Check the physical fit. Look at bay adapters, drive spacing and airflow. Four 3.5-inch drives generate heat in a case designed for one or two.
- Count SATA ports and power connectors. The author needed a splitter for power. Make sure your supply can handle the load.
- Plan the boot device. Reserve a port or slot for a small SSD instead of defaulting to a thumb drive.
- Mind the memory and CPU. One TrueNAS page lists 8 GB RAM minimum for a basic system. Containers and VMs will want more. Any 64-bit x86 CPU qualifies, but whether an old one handles your Plex workload depends on the codecs and the number of streams.
- Be careful with add-in controllers. If you need more ports, TrueNAS and ZFS want direct access to individual disks. An HBA in pass-through mode is the usual answer, and a hardware RAID controller isn't. One third-party guide specifically recommends an HBA in IT mode.
- Verify your installer. TrueNAS publishes PGP signatures and SHA256 checksums for its ISO. On Windows, PowerShell's Get-FileHash command can check the hash. Rufus can write the installer. TrueNAS says to choose DD Image mode if Rufus asks.
The verdict
This is a real, practical option for anyone with a spare desktop, and the author's reasoning about CPU and RAM headroom holds up in principle. His boot-drive choice is the weak spot, and the vendor's own documentation steers away from it. The "better than an appliance" claim rests on one person's experience with no benchmarks, noise figures or power measurements behind it. If you value a quiet, compact box that works out of the box, an appliance still makes sense. If you already own the hardware and enjoy tinkering, an old office PC with a boot SSD and a separate backup is a good place to start.
References
- The best NAS I've owned is a 10-year-old office PC with four drives crammed inside XDA · 2026-10-23T12:00:20+00:00
- ZFS Capacity Calculator | TrueNAS Documentation Hub truenas.com
- USB or hardware RAID-1 for booting TrueNAS - TrueNAS General - TrueNAS Community Forums forums.truenas.com