The report comes from Reddit user AkariYukawa and was written up by Neowin. The machine runs Windows 11 Home build 26200, which is the version 25H2 build family. "When I close the lid" is set to Do nothing for both battery and plugged-in power. Even so, the user says the System event log shows the laptop entering Modern Standby with "Lid" given as the reason. The result is the one you'd expect from sleep: desktop apps pause and long-running jobs stop partway through.
This is one user's report, not a confirmed Windows 11 bug. Neowin noted that several people in the Reddit thread could not reproduce it, and it said the problem was not listed on the Windows Release Health dashboard. That means Microsoft is not tracking it publicly. It does not mean Microsoft has looked into it and dismissed it. The case still raises a fair question about what "Do nothing" actually promises on a Modern Standby laptop.
What was reported
- Device: Dell XPS 13 with Modern Standby
- OS: Windows 11 Home, build 26200
- Lid setting: Do nothing, on battery and plugged in
- What happened: The System log recorded a Modern Standby entry caused by the lid
- Effect: Desktop apps froze and long-running work was interrupted
A matching thread on Microsoft's Q&A forum carries the blunt title "When I close the lid: Do nothing" is a lie on Modern Standby laptops. Neowin thinks it was probably posted by the same person; that link isn't confirmed. The poster wants Microsoft to make "Do nothing" actually do nothing: lid closed, screen off, everything keeps running, on battery too, for as long as I choose.
The thread's AI-generated answer is worth reading, but it is not an official diagnosis. It said that an immediate lid-triggered Modern Standby transition while the effective lid action is Do nothing conflicts with Microsoft's documented lid-policy behavior; Windows 11 does not, however, provide a supported setting that guarantees unrestricted desktop execution with the lid closed on battery.
That answer contains both sides of the problem. If the log is accurate, Windows did something the setting said it wouldn't. But even a correctly honored "Do nothing" never promised that laptop programs would run forever on battery with the lid shut.
What Microsoft's documentation says
Microsoft's own documentation is a bit muddled here, and the documents seem to point in different directions.
Lid closing is listed as a normal way into Modern Standby. Microsoft's "Prepare software for modern standby" page says a system enters Modern Standby when the display turns off. It lists four triggers: pressing the power button, closing the lid, choosing Sleep, and the system idling out. Read quickly, closing the lid simply means standby. But that page describes Modern Standby in general. It does not say this transition should override a lid policy of Do nothing.
The lid setting itself is defined literally. As the Q&A answer notes, Value 0, Do Nothing, is explicitly described as: "No action is taken when the system lid is closed." Windows stores this as the Lid switch close action, and Microsoft documents four values: 0 = Do nothing, 1 = Sleep, 2 = Hibernate, 3 = Shut down.
Do nothing doesn't block every later sleep. The same answer points out that Do nothing does not promise that the computer can never enter standby afterward—for example, an independent idle timeout can still do so. Microsoft's EnableInputSuppression page gives an example: on AC power with the lid action set to Do nothing, the system stays active until the video idle timeout expires or the charger is unplugged. When AC is removed, Windows checks the battery lid policy again, and if that policy is Sleep, the laptop goes to sleep then.
That page is the most specific source on this case. It says input suppression, which stops stray input from waking a closed laptop, does not engage when the lid action for the current power source is Do nothing. It also says that starting with Windows 11 version 24H2, input suppression can apply on AC as well as battery; before that it applied only on battery. Microsoft also advises against turning input suppression off. If AC behavior needs to change, it recommends setting the AC lid action to Do nothing instead.
Why this matters: If Windows 11 is designed to respect Do nothing for the current power source, a log line saying "Lid" caused standby is the odd part of this report. A standby that started later from an idle timeout would be expected behavior.
Why the apps froze
Once a laptop enters Modern Standby, desktop app freezes are expected.
Microsoft's documentation describes standby entry as a series of phases. In one of them, the Desktop Activity Moderator (DAM) suspends desktop applications to save power. Microsoft says Windows stops desktop apps from running during any part of Modern Standby after the DAM phase. Third-party system services can keep running, but only in a throttled mode.
Apps can ask Windows to stay awake, but those requests have limits. Microsoft says power requests can hold off standby indefinitely on AC power but for only up to five minutes on battery. The Q&A thread raises the same point, quoting the documentation that a program's request to keep running is honored "for up to 5 minutes on DC power".
So the frozen apps don't prove anything on their own. They are what Modern Standby does. The open question is why standby started at all when the lid was set to Do nothing.
There's also a recent precedent for Microsoft treating lid-close standby more strictly. In Windows 11 24H2 and later, Modern Standby systems no longer support audio playback when standby is entered through an explicit user action. In that case, the suggested workaround was the lid setting itself: setting the laptop to "Do nothing" when the lid closes allows music playback to continue normally, although it may increase battery usage. That workaround only helps if Do nothing is actually honored, which is what's in doubt on this XPS.
How to check your own laptop
If your laptop stops work when you close the lid even though it's set to Do nothing, these checks narrow down the cause. Run the command-line steps in an elevated Command Prompt.
- Check both lid settings. Open Control Panel, go to Power Options, and select Choose what closing the lid does. Under When I close the lid, set the desired behavior separately for On battery and Plugged in. Then open the plan's advanced settings, expand Power buttons and lid > Lid close action, and make sure both values match. A work or school policy, or the manufacturer's power utility, may also change these settings.
- Confirm the laptop uses Modern Standby. Run
powercfg /a. On a Modern Standby system, Microsoft says the output lists Standby (S0 Low Power Idle), followed by either Network Connected or Network Disconnected. - Look for programs holding power requests. Run
powercfg /requestswhile your long-running job is active. Microsoft's Modern Standby documentation names this command as the way to see which apps are holding power requests. - Test battery and AC separately. The applicable lid setting depends on the current power source, so close the lid once on battery and once on AC, and write down the times.
- Generate a SleepStudy report. Run
powercfg /sleepstudy. It creates an HTML report covering the last three days. Add/duration Nto cover up to 28 days. Microsoft says the report shows each session's start time, duration, power source, and energy use, plus the most active components. Match your lid-close test times against it. Note that Microsoft says sessions shorter than ten minutes are not tracked in the summary. - Check the System log. Look in Event Viewer for the Modern Standby entry and its reason at the time you closed the lid. That entry is the evidence the Reddit user found.
What the results mean: If the log shows standby triggered by the lid within seconds of closing it, and Do nothing is set for the current power source, you're seeing the same thing as the XPS 13 owner. If standby starts minutes later, a display or sleep timeout is the more likely cause.
The suggested fixes have limits
PowerToys Awake. A Microsoft Q&A respondent recommended Awake, and Neowin calls it the first thing to try. It's a reasonable experiment, but don't count on it. Microsoft describes Awake as a tool that asks Windows to keep the PC awake without changing power plan settings. It works only while it's enabled and you're signed in. Microsoft also says it doesn't stop user-initiated actions such as manually putting the PC to sleep.
A lid close may count as one of those user-initiated actions, so Awake may not prevent this problem at all. Microsoft also says Awake is meant for temporary use, and for persistent needs it recommends configuring Windows power settings directly.
Disabling Modern Standby. Another Reddit user suggested this, and Neowin itself said it's unclear whether it would keep the laptop awake with the lid closed. On some machines, your laptop should have a setting in the BIOS that simply lets you switch Modern Standby's sleep mode — S0 Sleep — to S3 Sleep. Many modern laptops don't offer that option, and nothing so far shows it fixes this Dell's lid behavior. Treat it as a hardware-dependent experiment, not a cure.
Check firmware too. If Windows settings look correct and the laptop still misbehaves, look at a manufacturer utility, a work policy, or outdated BIOS and dock firmware next. Since only some users in the thread see the problem, a model-specific or firmware cause is plausible, though nobody has shown that yet.
Bottom line
This report points to two separate issues:
- A possible bug. A lid-triggered standby with the lid set to Do nothing contradicts how Microsoft documents the setting. If you can reproduce it with matching log entries and timestamps, file it in Feedback Hub with your SleepStudy report attached.
- A naming problem. Even when Do nothing works as designed, it only stops the lid from triggering sleep, hibernation, or shutdown. On battery, Modern Standby's timeouts and five-minute limit on power requests still apply. Microsoft's own Q&A answer says no documented setting guarantees that desktop programs will run indefinitely with the lid closed on battery.
For overnight renders, large downloads, or long builds on a Modern Standby laptop, the safest option today is to stay on AC power, check that the AC lid action is Do nothing, and confirm with SleepStudy and the event log that the laptop didn't go to sleep.
References
- Some Windows 11 laptops still sleep with the lid closed despite "Do nothing" Neowin · 2026-11-18T14:20:01+00:00
- Prepare software for modern standby | Microsoft Learn learn.microsoft.com
- EnableInputSuppression | Microsoft Learn learn.microsoft.com