France Leading Europe's Digital Sovereignty Fight: Strategies to Reduce US Tech Dependency and Build

France’s digital minister, Clara Chappaz, has ignited a vigorous debate about Europe’s reliance on US tech giants by calling for a unified, “pack hunt” approach in tackling digital sovereignty. In a forceful speech at the Economy Ministry on 14 April, Chappaz not only denounced the continent’s dependency on US Big Tech but outlined a comprehensive strategy aimed at fostering innovation and resilient alternatives to dominant American cloud services.

Digital Sovereignty Under Threat​

Chappaz’s remarks come at a critical juncture. In a digital landscape where major players like Google Cloud, Microsoft Azure, and Amazon Web Services hold sway over as much as 80% of the European market, the risks of dependency become ever more apparent. The term “predators” used by the minister paints a vivid picture: a digital ecosystem where American tech entities are seen as hunting down opportunities and market shares at the cost of European digital autonomy.

• US Market Dominance: Chappaz highlighted the ubiquitous presence of US cloud providers, which stifles competition and leaves Europe vulnerable to external pressures.
• Historical Context: Revisiting the “idiotic” trade wars of the past, including those initiated by former US administrations, she reminded Europeans of the perils of over-reliance on tech ecosystems that may not always act in the bloc’s best interests.
• Call for Unity: The metaphor of hunting as a pack, reminiscent of President Macron’s previous use of animal imagery, underscores the need for a collaborative European approach. This isn’t a call for isolated national efforts but a rallying cry for the entire continent to join forces.

Addressing the Cloud Conundrum​

One of the central issues raised by Chappaz is the overwhelming dependency on US cloud services. The digital minister took particular aim at what she described as “sovereignty washing.” This term refers to US cloud companies partnering with European firms to market their services as sovereign, despite the inherent risks of foreign control.

The Role of the SecNumCloud Certification​

France’s response to this vulnerability has been both proactive and stringent. The French sovereign SecNumCloud cloud certification was emphasized as a critical tool in ensuring that cloud providers meet robust criteria for sovereignty. Key elements of this certification include:

• Ownership Restrictions: There is a strict cap on foreign control—no more than 24% of a company’s shares can be held by a single non-EU entity or 39% by multiple non-EU entities. This regulation directly targets the de facto situation faced by major US providers.
• Transparency and Security: The certification is designed to assure European clients that their data and digital services do not compromise national security or public trust.

By setting clear thresholds, France is taking an uncompromising stance against companies that seek to blur the lines between genuine sovereign service and mere branding exercises. This move is vital for reducing vulnerabilities in the contentious domain of cloud technology.

Strategic Measures on the Horizon​

The French government is not stopping at words. A series of concrete measures have been announced to mitigate the challenges posed by US tech dominance:

• Investment in Sovereign Cloud Solutions: Projects are being actively sought under the France 2030 investment plan. This initiative is aimed at boosting homegrown cloud services that can operate independently of US tech giants.
• Formation of an Industry Committee: A committee will be established to promote and coordinate investment in sovereign technological solutions. This group is expected to bring together key stakeholders from both the public and private sectors.
• Mapping Technological Dependencies: France is embarking on a detailed mission to map out its technological dependencies. The objective is to identify where the vulnerabilities lie and to develop future-proof strategies to reduce reliance on foreign tech services.
• Rallying European Companies: The minister acknowledged the growing trend among European companies seeking secure alternatives to US Big Tech. There is a noticeable surge in the number of clients approaching French cloud providers like OVHcloud and Scaleway, signaling a shift in sentiment and a renewed interest in locally controlled services.

These steps are not just about policy adjustments; they represent a broader, more strategic overhaul aimed at safeguarding European digital infrastructure. This approach is particularly crucial in light of potential US retaliatory measures, such as tariffs or regulatory pressures, which could be imposed if the EU enforces its digital tech rulebook with uncompromising strictness.

The Broader Implications for European Tech Policy​

Chappaz’s rhetoric is more than just political posturing. It shines a spotlight on the ongoing tug-of-war between US tech predominance and the EU’s aspirations for digital sovereignty. The call for a pack hunt is reflective of a broader strategic vision that includes:

• Strengthening Innovation Ecosystems: By nurturing homegrown technology and innovation, Europe can gradually reduce its dependency on foreign tech monopolies.
• Rebalancing Global Tech Governance: Europe’s struggle isn’t just about cloud services. It is emblematic of a larger debate about how technology should be governed in an increasingly multipolar world.
• Reinvigorating Trust in Digital Services: For citizens and businesses alike, the assurance of data sovereignty is intertwined with trust. Proactive measures to ensure that digital services are securely managed within Europe could reinvigorate that trust.

The Economic and Political Underpinnings​

The economic stakes are high. The digital economy is a cornerstone of modern economic growth, and when a handful of US companies dominate critical infrastructure, they can influence regulatory frameworks, hinder competition, and dictate market conditions. Politically, admitting dependency on external tech companies can be seen as a loss of autonomy—a condition that runs counter to the very spirit of post-war European unity and independence.

• Economic Sovereignty: Beyond the digital domain, economic sovereignty touches on national security, labor market stability, and technological innovation. Europe has an opportunity to assert itself as a major player on the world tech stage while insulating its markets from external shocks.
• Political Leverage: Maintaining control over vital digital infrastructures empowers European governments in negotiation settings, both within internal EU frameworks and on the global stage. This balancing act between reliance and independence is crucial in an era marked by geopolitical uncertainties.

Real-World Examples and Industry Response​

The shift in attitude is already visible. French cloud providers, notably OVHcloud and Scaleway, have reported a noticeable uptick in interest from businesses actively seeking alternatives to US services. This surge serves as a real-world indicator that the market is quietly gearing up for what might be a significant transformation in digital infrastructure.

• Technology Adoption Trends: European companies are increasingly scrutinizing the supply chains and operational frameworks of their digital service providers. This introspection is fostering a culture of due diligence that could ultimately pave the way for more resilient, locally-controlled tech solutions.
• Global Success Stories: The rise of sovereign digital projects in other regions, where countries are championing local alternatives to international tech giants, further reinforces the viability of Europe’s strategy. These success stories provide both a blueprint and a motivational force for European policymakers.

Addressing the Pack Hunt Metaphor​

One might wonder: why the emphasis on a “pack hunt”? The metaphor, initially adopted by President Macron in a different context, effectively captures the necessity of a united front. In the digital realm, no single nation can fend off the well-resourced, agile movements of major tech players. The “pack hunt” imagery reminds European stakeholders that concerted action is more potent than isolated efforts. The analogy is particularly apt in a landscape where collaboration not only enhances innovation but also strengthens regulatory enforcement and market influence.

• Collaborative Innovation: Just as a pack of wolves is more likely to corner a formidable prey, a united European tech community is better positioned to innovate, enforce regulations, and secure public trust.
• Collective Bargaining Power: When European nations pool their resources and strategically align their policies, they can counteract external pressures more effectively—be it from regulatory challenges or economic threats posed by tech monopolies.

Technological Dependency and Future Challenges​

The mission to map out France’s digital dependencies is perhaps one of the most crucial aspects of this evolving strategy. Identifying the precise points of vulnerability enables not just a reactive, but a proactive, framework for future policymaking. While dependency mapping may sound like a bureaucratic exercise, its outcomes could determine the success of future investments and regulatory measures aimed at reducing foreign control.

• Holistic Approaches: Beyond cloud services, a comprehensive understanding of technological dependencies will cover hardware, software, cybersecurity measures, and even AI research. The interconnected nature of these systems means that a vulnerability in one area can lead to a domino effect across the entire digital landscape.
• Integrating Measures Across the EU: While France is at the forefront of these initiatives, similar efforts are underway across the European Union. Harmonizing standards and sharing best practices could transform these isolated measures into a robust, continent-wide framework for digital sovereignty.

Concluding Thoughts and Future Directions​

As Europe navigates the turbulent waters of global tech politics, the call for a united pack hunt against US digital predators is a clarion call for recalibration and reinvention. France’s proactive stance illustrates the growing awareness of digital vulnerabilities and the need for a bold, decisive strategy to counteract them. The proposed measures—ranging from stringent certification standards to mapping out technological dependencies—set the stage for a fundamental transformation in how Europe manages its digital infrastructure.

• Innovative Resilience: The roadmap outlined by Chappaz reflects a balance between regulatory rigor and the encouragement of innovative spirit, suggesting that Europe is not content with merely being a consumer of tech but aspires to be a global leader in digital innovation.
• Collaborative Future: The emphasis on working as a pack underscores an enduring truth: collaboration has always been a cornerstone of European success. By harnessing collective expertise, resources, and vision, Europe can chart a course towards a more secure and sovereign digital future.
• Balancing Acts: As the continent moves forward, it will be critical to strike a balance between protecting digital integrity and fostering a competitive, open market for innovation. The interplay between regulation and market forces will undoubtedly shape the future of European tech.

In the grand scheme of global digital competition, France’s message is both timely and transformative. The industry is urged to not only adopt more secure and sovereign practices today but also to invest in a future where European technology stands as a robust alternative to its American counterparts. With strategic initiatives and a united front, the European tech community is poised to reinvent itself in a way that aligns with the broader goals of autonomy, security, and innovation.
In summary, the initiative spearheaded by France’s digital minister represents a vital turning point. It harnesses the spirit of collaboration, sets strict standards to defend digital sovereignty, and signals a broader realignment of priorities in the face of overwhelming external pressures. As European companies and governments rally behind this vision, the future promises a more resilient, self-reliant digital ecosystem that prioritizes the interests of its own citizens while standing firm against external digital predators.

---

Source: Euractiv Against US digital 'predators,' France digital minister calls for a European 'pack hunt' - Euractiv