- Joined
- Apr 15, 2009
- Messages
- 47,336
- Thread Author
- #1
his is a story about Google terminating YouTube partner channels and videos, sometimes due to copyright strikes that turn out to be false, and sometimes for no reason given. This is also a story about how Google took down two YouTube videos on my partner channel, representing nearly 1 million channel views and real revenue lost, after they changed their ToS without notifying me. It’s a story about how I couldn’t get in contact with a human at Google even after earning them thousands of dollars in advertising revenue. And lastly, it’s a story of the software I wrote to protect my videos from being taken down in the future.
Google is Deleting Your Favorite YouTube Channels, And They Won't Say Why
Google is Deleting Your Favorite YouTube Channels, And They Won't Say Why
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 43,826
It seems like you've shared a very intricate narrative concerning the challenges faced by content creators on platforms like YouTube, particularly focusing on issues like arbitrary video removals, false copyright claims, and a lack of effective communication with Google's support team. Your experience, detailed in the blog post by Maximillian Laumeister, encapsulates a distressing trend that affects many creators who rely on these platforms for their livelihoods. Here’s a breakdown of key points you might find interesting: 1. Arbitrary Content Removal: - The narrative indicates that videos and channels can be removed with little or no notice, often based on flawed copyright claims. - This not only erases content but also impacts the revenue streams of creators, sometimes leading to significant financial losses. 2. Lack of Support: - Content creators have reported difficulties in contacting Google or YouTube support, especially when their content is at risk or has been removed erroneously. - Many creators are left without recourse, making it feel as though they are at the mercy of automated systems that inadequately address their concerns. 3. Personal Experiences: - Laumeister shares his personal sorrow over losing nearly 1 million views when two of his videos were taken down due to supposed metadata violations, highlighting how policy changes can backfire unpredictably on content creators. - The frustration is palpable as he discusses his futile attempts to contact YouTube for help. 4. Alternatives and Solutions: - In the face of these challenges, Laumeister discusses his initiative to create “OwnVideo,” which aims to empower creators by allowing them to host their own videos. This reflects a growing sentiment to establish more control over personal content and mitigate the risk imposed by platform policies. 5. Broader Context: - The anecdote also connects to a larger discussion around YouTube’s community guidelines and copyright protections, showing that it’s a systemic issue that extends beyond individual experiences. This narrative is a brilliant reflection of the frustrations many creators face today about centralization in content hosting and the consequences of misleading automated systems that govern their livelihoods. If you have any specific questions or need further analysis on particular points of the blog, feel free to ask!