VIDEO I was Wrong - AMD is in BIG Trouble

whoosh

Cooler King
Staff member
Joined
Apr 15, 2009
Messages
47,255
:iee:
 


I was Wrong - AMD is in BIG Trouble In a recent YouTube video titled "I was Wrong - AMD is in BIG Trouble," the content creator dives deep into the ongoing thermal issues associated with the AMD 7900 XTX graphics cards, emphasizing a significant problem that many users have faced. The video arises from earlier discussions and feedback from viewers, highlighting the pitfalls of initial assumptions regarding the cause of overheating issues related to these graphics cards.

Key Highlights:​

  • Initial Misdiagnosis: The creator initially believed the overheating might be due to mounting pressure or thermal paste issues. However, after receiving numerous reports from viewers, it became clear the problem was more complex.
  • Case Compilation: A total of 48 confirmed cases were gathered following the initial video, with hotspot temperatures reaching as high as 110 degrees Celsius. A variety of setups—including both horizontally and vertically mounted cards—showed similar overheating problems, indicating that the issue was not confined to a particular installation method.

Insights from Testing:​

  • The creator acquired multiple cards from viewers, conducted tests under different conditions, and noted that all the cards exhibited high hotspot temperatures. Their performance degradation during intensive gaming tests was also documented.
  • Specifically, temperature tests indicated that while GPU temperatures were manageable in the 60 to 70 degrees Celsius range, hotspot temperatures frequently exceeded acceptable limits, especially under horizontal mounting setups.
  • The exploration expanded to consider whether the mounts’ orientation or the cooler’s mechanical design contributed to overheating. The creator even conducted tests to eliminate gravity as a contributing factor by using specialized mounts, yet temperatures remained alarmingly high.

Potential Solutions Explored:​

  • A series of modifications to the mounting processes were tested, including adjustments to standoff heights and testing without the mid-plate of the cooler, aiming to improve the pressure distribution and contact between the GPU and cooler. Despite these efforts, the temperatures continued to peak at troubling levels.
  • The crux of the issue appears to lie with the vapor chamber cooling system in the graphics cards. The creator posits that the vapor chamber might be experiencing design flaws or inadequate pressure levels that fail to dissipate heat effectively.

Community Reactions and Looking Forward:​

The video ended with significant implications for AMD, suggesting that they might face substantial backlash, including a potential recall of affected models. The creator pointed out the historical context of similar issues within the industry, like NVIDIA's 12V connector debacle, and noted that AMD's undoing in this regard could have widespread ramifications, potentially affecting all partner brands utilizing the same design.

Final Thoughts:​

As the community awaits AMD's response to this brewing issue, the creator invites further discussion on the matter, urging affected users and enthusiasts to share their own experiences. It's a poignant reminder of how crucial quality control is in hardware production and the lasting impacts that thermal management issues can have on user satisfaction and brand reputation. For those interested in challenging the status quo regarding product reliability in the tech world, this thread could catalyze engaging discussions. Share your thoughts or experiences with the 7900 XTX cards or any similar thermal troubles!
 


Back
Top