Severe Vulnerabilities in Schneider Electric PLCs: Mitigation Strategies Alert

Schneider Electric, a leader in industrial automation and energy management, has reported severe vulnerabilities within its product line of programmable logic controllers (PLCs) under the Modicon brand—namely the M340, MC80, and Momentum Unity M1E processors. Cybersecurity watchdog CISA has flagged these issues, releasing detailed recommendations for mitigation strategies while the industry grapples with the potential impacts of these vulnerabilities.

---

Understanding the Scope of the Problem​

The Vulnerabilities​

Let's break down these two prominent threats:

1. Improper Enforcement of Message Integrity (CWE-924): This flaw undermines the ability of the communication channel to verify data integrity. Effectively, an attacker within the logical network can exploit this by retrieving sensitive information—like password hashes—potentially causing a denial-of-service (DoS) alongside compromising confidentiality and integrity. This vulnerability is tracked as CVE-2024-8933.
2. Authentication Bypass via Spoofing (CWE-290): Here, the critical issue arises during communication sessions between the engineering workstation and controllers. A Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) attack introduces itself between the two ends, facilitated by the inherent limitations of the Diffie-Hellman algorithm. The system’s inability to fend off MITM attacks means an attacker could compromise session security, leading to DoS. This is identified under CVE-2024-8935.

Both vulnerabilities possess a high-risk score under the CVSS system:

• CVE-2024-8933: 7.5 (CVSS v3.1; Network-accessible, Complex attack vector, High impact to confidentiality, integrity & availability)
• CVE-2024-8935: 7.7 (CVSS v4.0 adds subtle weight to potential privileged access within attack vectors)

---

Impact Analysis​

These vulnerabilities shine a spotlight on sectors that form the backbone of global critical infrastructure—energy, critical manufacturing, and commercial facilities. Widely deployed across industrial control systems (ICS) worldwide, including factories, power plants, and datacenters, Schneider's PLCs play pivotal roles in systems automation. A breach could transcend localized incidences to cause broad-scale operational disruptions, data compromises, or potential safety hazards.

---

Who’s at Risk?​

Affected Product Lines​

If your setup includes the following models, you’ll want to scrutinize:

• Modicon M340:
  • All firmware versions (CVE-2024-8933).
  • Specifically, firmware versions post-SV3.60 (CVE-2024-8935).
  []Modicon MC80:
  
  • All versions are susceptible (CVE-2024-8933).
  []Momentum Unity M1E Processors:
  • All existing versions (CVE-2024-8933).

By their nature, these devices—designed for industrial environments—are prime candidates for malicious activities if basic cybersecurity best practices are neglected.

---

Technical Deep Dive​

Improper Enforcement of Message Integrity (CVE-2024-8933)​

Here, the crux lies in how a compromised logical network allows an adversary to intercept and manipulate project uploads/downloads between controllers and users. This undermines several security goals:

• Confidentiality: Exposure to sensitive password hashes.
• Integrity & Availability: Leads to disruptions, likely through project or file injection attacks.

Central to this vulnerability is the need for physical/logical proximity to the network (a challenge for attackers but no impossible feat, especially with insider threats or unsecured points of ingress).

Authentication Bypass by Spoofing (CVE-2024-8935)​

Diffie-Hellman, while a robust foundational cryptographic protocol, requires additional safeguards to prevent adversary-in-the-middle manipulation. Schneider's reliance on this protocol without robust MITM defenses exposes a weak underbelly. The attacker impersonates endpoints in communication, gaining unauthorized access or even injecting destructive commands.

---

Mitigation Measures to Deploy Immediately​

Schneider Electric acknowledges the severity of these vulnerabilities and aims to incorporate fixes in the next firmware rollouts. Until then, implementing the following practical mitigations is urgent.

Immediate Actions​

1. Network Segmentation: Design your ICS network to segregate sensitive control systems from lesser-secure environments:
   • Deploy firewalls, and block unauthorized access to Port 502/TCP.
   []Access Control Lists (ACL): Utilize Schneider-specific guidelines to fine-tune settings per model:
   
   • Refer to the Modicon M340 User Manual for Messaging Configuration.
   • Check out MC80's User Manual for configuring ACL specifics.
   []Secure Remote Communication:
   • Leverage external firewalls (e.g., EAGLE40-07) to enable Virtual Private Network (VPN) access. Ensure firmware of VPN hardware is regularly patched.
   • Explore guidance in the Modicon Controller Cybersecurity User Guide.
2. Enable Memory Protection (M340-specific):
   • Configure input bit-level protection features to deny unauthorized writes to system memory.

---

General Preventative Strategies​

Beyond device-specific mitigations, Schneider and CISA recommend robust industry practices for ICS setups:

• Deploy physical security measures like locked cabinets for controller protection.
• Keep systems disconnected from external business/IT networks.
• Mandate air-gapped solutions or periodic sanitization for mobile data devices (USB/CDs) used within ICS networks.
• Regularly patch VPN endpoints, ensuring they're isolated to ICS-only traffic.

---

CISA Guidance on Defense​

CISA emphasizes adding layers of defense:

• Protect control systems from internet access completely.
• Establish stringent firewall rules to isolate internal traffic.
• Ensure prolonged session monitoring for atypical behaviors (e.g., anomalies during user-to-device connections).

For a more structured approach towards ICS cybersecurity postures, download CISA's "Improving Industrial Control Systems Cybersecurity with Defense-in-Depth Strategies" paper.

---

Looking Ahead​

Firm Updates​

Schneider's remediation rollout, scheduled for imminent firmware iterations, promises bolstered defenses explicitly addressing these gaps. Users relying on older versions must maintain vigilance through manual measures.

Reporting Incidents​

If your Schneider systems face suspected intrusion attempts, report details to CISA immediately to collaborate on mitigation efforts and to ensure the broader ecosystem is safeguarded.

---

Final Thoughts and Call for Vigilance​

The Schneider Electric vulnerabilities serve yet another wake-up call in cybersecurity for industrial control systems. Digital threats targeting foundational automation modules, like PLCs, can cascade into catastrophic failures if preemptive measures aren't swiftly executed. By enforcing network segmentation and leveraging manuals specific to Schneider controllers, users can thwart most attacks even with vulnerabilities in play.
Remember, cybersecurity is as much about technology as it is about culture—empower your teams, educate users, and embrace robust ICS safety protocols to stay ahead.
Got thoughts or tips for additional security methods? Drop your insights in the discussion and let's fortify industrial networks together!

---

Source: CISA Schneider Electric Modicon M340, MC80, and Momentum Unity M1E