VIDEO Testing the effectiveness of a spear throw against padded armor

[whoosh]

 

[ChatGPT]

Testing the Effectiveness of a Spear Throw Against Padded Armor Recently, a captivating YouTube experiment titled "Testing the Effectiveness of a Spear Throw Against Padded Armor" delved into whether a thrown spear could penetrate the layers of padded clothing or armor commonly used in historical duels. The video presents a thorough analysis using various spear types, tests against different barriers, and offers insights into the effectiveness of weaponry against protective gear.

Overview of the Experiment​

The video kicks off with the host showcasing three different spear designs, including a lightweight javelin intended for throwing and two other spear points custom-made for this test. The primary focus is to examine their ability to pierce through multiple layers, simulating what would happen in an actual combat scenario involving padded garments like a gambeson.

Methodology​

The host constructed a target that consisted of:

• Cardboard layers forming the base,
• Ballistic gel (known for mimicking human tissue) atop the cardboard for authenticity in penetration testing,
• An additional yoga mat to increase the difficulty of penetration. Ultimately, the total layered target measured around 45 mm thick, simulating both the complexity of hitting a target in battle and the challenge posed by protective clothing.

  Key Findings​

  Throughout the various tests, the results were quite informative:
• When thrusting the spear against the barriers, it became evident that the padded armor significantly reduced the injury potential. The penetration depth observed across attempts indicated that while a spear could indeed reach and cause damage, the protective gear mitigated most lethal potentials.
• The historical context invoked in the video emphasized that, while a thrown spear could injure, it would require the element of surprise or an ideal striking angle to achieve a potentially fatal result. Interestingly, one of the heavier spear types performed notably better in terms of penetration depth, validating the idea that mass and design do play a crucial role in effectiveness.

  Analysis​

  This experiment sparks intriguing discussions about weaponry effectiveness and armor durability in historical contexts. It challenges common beliefs about the invulnerability of armor while also showcasing the importance of tactical knowledge and physical conditioning in successful spear throwing.

  Community Engagement​

  What are your thoughts on the effectiveness of weapons like spears against padded armor? Does this experiment change your perspective on historical combat techniques? Feel free to share your insights or beliefs about similar weapons and armor scenarios in historical contexts! For those interested in more on historical weaponry or martial arts, check out related forum threads on ancient combat techniques.