• Thread Author
Microsoft’s Snipping Tool for Windows 11 has taken another small step toward being a genuine, all‑in‑one capture utility: a test build of the app now lets you pick a program window when starting a video recording, rather than forcing a free‑draw rectangle. That improvement — arriving in Snipping Tool version 11.2507.14.0 — removes one of the most awkward limitations of the built‑in recorder, but it is far from a finished product. The new window‑pick mode fixes a common workflow annoyance while still leaving key usability and reliability gaps that will matter to power users, creators, and IT professionals alike.

A Windows 11 monitor on a desk displays a blue abstract wallpaper with a pop-up dialog.Background: how Snipping Tool evolved into a screen recorder​

The Snipping Tool began life as a simple screenshot utility and has been repeatedly reworked and expanded over the last several Windows releases. In Windows 11 the app received a major redesign, new annotation tools, OCR (text recognition) features and, in 2022, the ability to record short videos of selected screen regions. Over the last two years Microsoft has added incremental improvements — audio options, trimming, timer presets and more — gradually shifting the app from throwaway convenience tool to a lightweight capture suite.
That evolution introduced a persistent complaint: when recording video the Snipping Tool forced users to draw a rectangular capture area and then start recording. There was no built‑in way to tell the recorder “use this app window” — a surprisingly common requirement for tutorial makers, support technicians, and people who capture single‑window demos. The free‑draw approach also meant the capture rectangle would not follow a target window if it moved or was resized after recording started; practical workflows demanded better window awareness.

What changed in version 11.2507.14.0​

The recent test release — Snipping Tool 11.2507.14.0 — introduces a window‑selection recording mode that allows the recorder to snap the initial capture area to a chosen application window. Instead of having to draw a rectangle and hope it lines up with the app you want, users can now choose a window and the recorder will size the capture to that window's current dimensions at the moment recording begins. This is the exact feature many users have requested since screen recording landed in the app.
Important technical details and limits to note:
  • The window‑pick mode sets the capture region to the window’s current geometry when the recording starts; it does not dynamically track the window if it is moved or resized after capture begins. That means moving the window off the capture area or resizing it will break the intended recording (the recorder will keep capturing the original region). This limitation is explicit in early hands‑on reports.
  • The change is currently visible in Insider channels and test builds, but Microsoft continues to gate many features — rollout is still staged and may not appear immediately even for Canary or Beta testers. That gating seems to be part of a deliberate, incremental rollout strategy.
  • The update’s package name appears as Microsoft.ScreenSketch_2022.2507.14.0 in distribution channels that expose MSIX bundles, which is the installable package format used by Microsoft Store/WindowsApps. That is the file identifier referenced in community install guidance.
These characteristics make the window‑mode a clear step forward for basic recording workflows, but they also reveal why many users will still prefer third‑party tools until Microsoft adds dynamic window tracking, better audio control, and reliability improvements.

How to get the feature now (and why many users are cautious)​

Because Microsoft staggers app updates and sometimes gates features by region, channel, or device, the new window‑mode may not appear automatically on every machine running the same Snipping Tool version. Community investigators uncovered a way to force the update immediately: download the MSIX bundle for the newer Snipping Tool build from a Store‑mirror tool (commonly referred to as the Adguard Store downloader) using the product ID 9MZ95KL8MR0L, then install the package manually. The process is:
  • Open the “Adguard Store” download helper page and set the form type to ProductID.
  • Paste the Snipping Tool ProductID (9MZ95KL8MR0L) into the search field.
  • Select the Fast channel (or the variant that lists the 11.2507.14.0 package).
  • Download the MSIX bundle named Microsoft.ScreenSketch_2022.2507.14.0.msixbundle.
  • Double‑click to install (or use Add‑AppxPackage via PowerShell for systems with strict App Installer behavior).
A few caveats and warnings must be highlighted:
  • Sideloading app packages bypasses the Microsoft Store workflow and can bring compatibility or trust implications. Manual MSIX installs are practical for advanced users and administrators, but are not recommended for general users on managed or domain‑controlled devices. Always validate the package source and keep backups.
  • Some community notes mention that an additional Registry tweak may be required to expose the feature immediately after package installation; a reboot is typically necessary. Those tweaks were provided as convenience registry files in community posts, but registry edits carry risk and should be used cautiously on production machines.
  • Microsoft’s staged rollout is often deliberate: features in Canary/Beta builds may remain gated to a subset of devices (or be A/B tested) before a full public release. For enterprise environments, the gated rollout reduces the risk of breaking changes, but it also fragments the user experience.
Community troubleshooting threads and Q&A posts show a steady stream of users resorting to manual installs and workarounds when Store updates or OS update channels do not deliver expected Snipping Tool functionality. Those threads also document reliability problems (random crashes, truncated recordings) that make cautious adoption sensible until Microsoft provides broader testing and fixes.

How this compares to third‑party alternatives​

For people who rely on recordings for training videos, demos, or streaming, the Snipping Tool’s incremental improvements are welcome but not yet competitive with full‑featured alternatives. Key differences:
  • OBS Studio: free, extremely flexible, supports dynamic window capture that follows a selected source, multiple audio streams, overlays and streaming. It’s the go‑to for professional and semi‑professional use.
  • ShareX: free, lightweight, offers many capture presets and automated workflows (uploads, edits), and supports audio recording when paired with the right codecs.
  • PicPick: the community‑favored utility mentioned in published roundups supports video capture, audio configuration and cursor options, and offers easier “single‑click full screen” recording controls for casual users. Many users pointed to PicPick as a practical stopgap while Snipping Tool matures.
Strengths of Snipping Tool (what Microsoft gets right)
  • Tight OS integration and simple UI: the app is discoverable and consistent with Windows 11 UI conventions.
  • Low‑friction quick clips: for many short, single‑pass captures the built‑in tool is fast enough and requires no extra setup.
  • Growing capabilities: Microsoft is actively adding features (trim, OCR, window‑pick mode) that make the app useful for basic documentation tasks.
Limitations that matter to power users
  • Lack of dynamic window tracking: if the recorded window moves or in certain multi‑monitor scenarios, the capture will miss content.
  • Reliability issues: community reports indicate occasional truncation or crashes during long recordings, which is unacceptable for long meetings or mission‑critical captures.
  • Feature parity: advanced audio routing, multi‑source recording (webcam + screen), bitrate control, and streaming capabilities are not present. Until Snipping Tool gains these, professionals will stick with OBS, Camtasia, or other dedicated apps.

Practical scenarios where window‑pick helps (but isn’t perfect)​

  • Single‑app tutorials: recording a single app (e.g., a settings pane or dialog) benefits from snapping to a window so the initial framing is exact. The feature reduces the fiddly step of pixel‑perfect rectangle drawing.
  • Bug repro traces for IT: capturing only the target app window avoids exposing unrelated system information and reduces post‑capture editing.
  • Quick demos for documentation: the initial window snap saves a few seconds per clip and lowers the chance of accidentally including the taskbar or other UI clutter.
What still breaks these scenarios
  • If the app being recorded launches modals, resizes, or uses separate toplevel windows during normal operation, the capture may miss those follow‑on windows unless the recorder tracks the window dynamically.
  • Multi‑window workflows (dragging content between apps, docking/undocking external monitors) can also invalidate the initial capture area. Community threads document several multi‑monitor anomalies and crashes tied to HDR or docking changes that affect capture behavior.

Reliability, rollout and enterprise implications​

Microsoft’s strategy for enhancing built‑in apps appears to favor incremental, gated rollouts through Insider channels first, while exposing additional features to a subset of devices for stability and telemetry reasons. That approach reduces risk at scale but introduces fragmentation: two users with identical Windows builds can experience different app behavior due to server‑side feature gates. Enterprises will see three practical consequences:
  • Managed devices may not receive new features at all until IT approves them via Windows Update rings or Microsoft Endpoint Manager.
  • Manual package sideloading is possible for controlled rollouts, but that bypasses Store policies and requires management oversight.
  • Longstanding reliability bugs — truncation of recordings, hotkey conflicts, multi‑monitor crashes — suggest that organizations relying on Snipping Tool for formal capture workflows should validate the tool thoroughly before declaring it an approved utility. Several Microsoft support and community threads detail these exact reliability pain points.
Administrators should prefer:
  • Testing the new Snipping Tool package in a lab or pilot group rather than broad deployment.
  • Evaluating alternative solutions when reliability or advanced features are required.
  • Keeping clear documentation for end users on how to update via the Microsoft Store and how to report capture failures using the Feedback Hub.

Security, privacy and policy considerations​

  • Sideloading risks: downloading an MSIX bundle from a third‑party mirror like the Adguard downloader is a technical convenience, but it changes the installation provenance and should be considered in light of corporate app policies and compliance. Validate package integrity and perform these installs only with documented change control procedures.
  • Data exposure: any screen recording app can capture sensitive content. The Snipping Tool’s window‑pick mode reduces incidental exposure, but it’s not a substitute for careful content hygiene when recording sessions may include credentials, private data, or regulated information.
  • On‑device telemetry and storage: Microsoft’s default setup stores recordings locally, but telemetry and enhanced features (e.g., search or cloud integrations) may introduce additional data flows; organizations should verify their telemetry settings and retention policies. Community guidance and Microsoft documentation emphasize on‑device behavior but recommend auditing settings for managed deployments.

What to expect next (roadmap signals and realistic timelines)​

Microsoft’s Snipping Tool updates have followed a clear pattern: add one or two useful features in Insider channels (trim, OCR, timer improvements, window mode), let them bake, then push a broader rollout after telemetry and fixes. The window‑pick mode is unlikely to be the last step. The most probable near‑term improvements that would materially upgrade the recorder are:
  • Dynamic window tracking (auto‑follow on move/resize).
  • Improved audio controls (explicit system audio capture and device selection by default).
  • Better hotkey support for start/pause/stop to speed workflows.
  • Stability fixes for long recordings and multi‑monitor/HDR setups.
For users and IT teams, a reasonable expectation is to watch Insider notes and official Windows Inbox app announcements for the next few months and plan pilot deployments accordingly. Until then, Snipping Tool is best reserved for quick clips and occasional demos rather than mission‑critical recordings.

Clear recommendations​

  • For casual users: update via the Microsoft Store and wait for the feature to roll out automatically; avoid sideloading unless comfortable with MSIX and registry edits. The built‑in tool is convenient for short clips and quick tutorials.
  • For power users and creators: continue using dedicated recorders (OBS Studio, Camtasia, etc.) until Snipping Tool supports dynamic window tracking and improves reliability for longer recordings.
  • For IT admins: treat the new Snipping Tool build as a pilot candidate; validate behavior in multi‑monitor and long‑duration recording scenarios before waiving third‑party tools from managed software lists. Collect telemetry and user feedback during the pilot to detect truncation or crash patterns documented in community threads.

Final assessment​

The addition of a window‑pick recording mode to the Snipping Tool is a welcome, overdue fix for a glaring usability gap. It streamlines many routine capture tasks and shows Microsoft is iterating productively on a core utility. However, the current implementation reads like phase one of a larger feature: it addresses initial framing but not ongoing tracking, and it arrives into a landscape where stability concerns and fragmented rollouts still hamper adoption for professional use. The sensible path forward is for Microsoft to deliver dynamic window tracking, robust audio controls, and improved reliability — then the Snipping Tool could truly displace many lightweight third‑party recorders for everyday tasks. Until those items arrive, the tool will remain a convenient, polished option for short captures and a stopgap for casual users, while power users and enterprises will continue to depend on richer, battle‑tested alternatives.
The observed pattern — steady incremental feature releases, cautious Canary/Beta gating, and a strong user appetite for more robust functionality — suggests the Snipping Tool will keep improving. The window‑mode is an important step, but the feature set and reliability profile need to catch up before the app becomes a default choice for demanding capture workflows.

Source: gHacks Technology News Windows 11's Snipping Tool video recorder is finally getting a missing feature (but it could be better) - gHacks Tech News
 

Back
Top