Windows 11 vs Linux: Intel Arc B580 Graphics Showdown

Welcome to a showdown that feels like a heavyweight match between Windows 11 and Linux, brought to you by Intel’s fresh-off-the-press Arc B-Series “Battlemage” graphics cards. Geeky? Maybe. Exciting? Absolutely. Let’s dive in to explore how Intel’s latest GPUs, spearheaded by the B580, stack up when running graphics and GPU compute workloads across two very different operating shores: Microsoft Windows 11 and Ubuntu Linux.

A Brief Context: Intel Arc Battlemage Meets the Field​

Intel's Arc series has been carving out its niche in the world of GPUs, competing head-to-head with NVIDIA and AMD in gaming, workstation performance, and compute tasks. The newly released Arc B-Series "Battlemage," particularly the B580, brings to the table the next-gen Xe2 architecture, offering advanced ray tracing, improved AI performance, and general hardware beefiness.
In this analysis, Intel’s latest creation was unleashed on identical hardware under both Windows 11 and Ubuntu Linux 24.10. Each setup involved the latest Intel drivers, cutting-edge tools like Mesa 25.0 for Linux, and Linux kernel 6.13, to deliver a raw, edge-of-your-seat benchmarking experience. So, let’s break this down, highlight the stars, and point out where each side stumbles.

The Test Environment: A Level Playing Field​

First things first—can we all agree that any benchmarking war has to be fair? To ensure this, the following hardware and software settings were used for all tests:

• Hardware: Intel Core Ultra 9 285K processor, ASUS ROG Maximus Z890 HERO motherboard, 32GB RAM, and a WD_BLACK SN850X NVMe SSD.
• Graphics Cards: Arc A580 (Alchemist), Arc A770, and the shiny new Arc B580 (Battlemage).
• Operating Systems: Windows 11 Pro and Ubuntu 24.10 (fresh installs).
• Drivers:
  • Windows: Latest Intel GPU driver as of December 14, 2024.
  • Linux: Upstream Intel open-source driver stack with Mesa 25.0, utilizing the Oibaf PPA and kernel 6.13 Git.
• Consistency Note: No tweaking of OS defaults such as platform profiles or CPU governors. Vanilla performance ensured fair play.

Now that the battlefield is set, let’s roll out the numbers.

---

Key Benchmark Results​

Each OS underwent a barrage of tests, from real-world gaming benchmarks to compute-heavy workloads. Here’s how the two operating systems traded blows across key metrics:

1. Gaming Performance: DirectX 12 vs. Vulkan/OpenGL​

• Windows 11: Unsurprisingly, Intel Arc hardware shows better gaming performance thanks to DirectX, an API Microsoft has refined for decades. Titles like Counter-Strike 2 and HITMAN enjoyed smooth gameplay with minimal stuttering and rock-solid frame rates. On 3DMark Wild Life—a widely respected GPU stress test in the gaming world—Windows wins by a decent margin.
• Ubuntu Linux: Native Vulkan and OpenGL gaming optimizations have come a long way, but Linux still feels like Intel’s second fiddle in the gaming space. While Linux gaming is capable (thanks to Valve’s Proton/Steam Play), compatibility issues and raw DirectX performance favor Windows.

2. Synthetic Benchmarks: GravityMark, Unigine Suite​

• Windows: Impressively consistent performance, showcasing fine-tuned driver support for Intel GPUs.
• Linux: GravityMark and other Vulkan-focused synthetic benchmarks reveal a few inefficiencies in Linux drivers, particularly for Battlemage hardware. It’s not bad—it’s just not Windows.

Winner: Windows, but not by a landslide. Vulkan continues to shine on Linux, though driver-level optimizations on the Windows side maintain a clear edge.

3. Workstation Graphics: Blender (oneAPI), Vulkan Compute​

• Intel’s proprietary oneAPI framework shines on Linux. Blender tasks leveraging GPU acceleration for rendering showcase some of the best results under Linux, with Battlemage holding up against its generational peers.
• Conversely, Vulkan compute performance was comparable across platforms, pointing to raw hardware efficiency regardless of OS. However, Windows still had a slight performance boost with better-blended driver integration.

---

Strengths & Weaknesses by OS​

1. Windows 11: Unquestionable Gaming Superiority​

Nothing surprising here—DirectX API dominance, superior support for AAA games, and seamless driver integration favor Windows users. If you’re a gamer making the most of Intel GPUs, stay in Windows-land.
But it’s not all smooth sailing! Windows’ resource overhead occasionally impacts usable performance for workstation or compute-heavy applications, giving Linux a little breathing room.

2. Linux: The Underdog, But Gaining Ground​

Linux has made phenomenal strides, particularly in workstation workloads and Vulkan-native gaming titles. Intel’s open-source driver team deserves applause for delivering robust Mesa support and improvements in Blender workloads. That said, Linux struggles to match Windows’ polished gaming experience—particularly with DirectX-exclusive games entirely out of Linux’s purview.

---

What Does This Mean for You?​

The Intel Arc B-Series shines at being versatile hardware, doing remarkably well in gaming and workstation tasks. However, the software story splits the audience into two camps:

1. Gamers: Stick to Windows 11—it’s a no-brainer at this point. For titles like HITMAN and Counter-Strike 2, Windows offers unmatched stability and slightly better performance metrics than a Linux gaming stack.
2. Developers and FOSS Advocates: If Blender, Vulkan, or open-source applications are your thing, Linux offers a growing playground with signs of long-term potential.

---

Final Thoughts: The Verdict​

The Windows 11 vs. Linux battle for Intel Arc “Battlemage” GPUs paints an exciting picture. While Windows remains triumphant in gaming and performance consistency, Linux is clawing its way up for workstation and creative workloads. Intel’s proactive involvement in the open-source Linux stack keeps things interesting—Linux isn’t winning yet, but it’s no longer an afterthought.
In time, higher adoption of Vulkan, improved drivers, and better cross-platform support from Intel might just turn the tides. But for now, your choice of OS depends entirely on your workload. Are you a gamer? Windows wins. Are you a tinkerer, developer, or creative professional? Don your Linux hat, and you won’t be disappointed.

---

Source: Phoronix Windows 11 vs. Linux Benchmarks For Intel Arc B-Series 'Battlemage' Shows Strengths & Weaknesses Review