Hi Garett,
Good —
non-heatsink is the right version for a laptop, and updating the
BIOS first was exactly the right move. Crucial says Gen5 NVMe drives are
backward compatible with Gen4 systems, but compatibility still depends on the laptop/platform, and HP’s published specs for the
16-ar0000 series list factory SSD options only as
PCIe Gen4 x4 NVMe in
512 GB, 1 TB, and 2 TB capacities. That does
not prove your 4 TB T710 cannot work, but it does make the SSD itself a remaining compatibility suspect if recovery/install still fails. (support.hp.com)
What I’d do next
1. Try HP Cloud Recovery Tool first
This is the best next test because it creates
HP’s own recovery image for supported consumer PCs, which is more model-specific than a generic Windows install. HP says the tool is for
consumer PCs, requires a
blank 64 GB USB drive, works best with
AC power, and recommends keeping the PC on a stable internet connection during creation. (support.hp.com)
2. Use this exact process
- Put the original SSD back in if needed so you can run Windows normally.
- Download and run HP Cloud Recovery Tool as administrator.
- Use a blank 64 GB or larger USB.
- Keep the laptop plugged into AC power the whole time.
- If possible, use the most stable connection available while it builds the media.
- After the recovery USB is created, shut down.
- Reinstall the Crucial T710.
- Boot the HP and use
Esc, then F9, to select the recovery USB. HP’s Startup Menu and Boot Device Options are accessed that way on consumer notebooks. (support.hp.com)
3. If the recovery USB boots
That is a
good sign. Then:
- Choose the recovery/install option for a full reinstall.
- On the disk selection screen, delete all partitions on the new SSD.
- Install to the resulting Unallocated Space.
- Let the process finish without forcing restarts. Microsoft’s reinstall guidance says to delete the target disk’s partitions until only Unallocated Space remains, then continue.
What the result means
If HP Recovery works
Then your issue was probably:
- The earlier install media.
- Partitioning/cloning leftovers.
- A driver/setup mismatch during generic install.
If HP Recovery also BSODs or loops
Then I would move the spotlight back to the
T710 itself. Since the BIOS is updated, the drive is non-heatsink, and HP’s own recovery image would remove most software/media variables, a repeated failure after that would strongly suggest a
drive compatibility issue with this model. That’s an
inference, but it is the most likely one based on HP’s documented Gen4 storage configs and Crucial’s own note to verify platform compatibility. (support.hp.com)
One quick check before you start
In BIOS, see whether the new SSD is detected with the expected size. If the BIOS sees the T710 consistently, that’s better than not seeing it at all, but it still doesn’t guarantee Windows setup compatibility. HP’s BIOS menu includes storage/boot-related information and boot options, so it’s worth confirming before running recovery.
My recommendation if this still fails
If HP Recovery fails on the T710 after the BIOS update, I would seriously consider returning it and switching to a
PCIe Gen4 x4 NVMe M.2 2280 drive. Staying closer to HP’s documented storage class gives you the best odds. HP officially lists
up to 2 TB Gen4 for this series. (support.hp.com)
After you try HP Recovery, post back with
one of these three outcomes:
- USB boots and recovery starts
- USB does not appear in F9
- Recovery starts but BSODs again
If you want, I can also give you a
very short HP Recovery Tool checklist before you begin.