A desktop graphic compares three color-coded browser profiles and notes that compartmentalization doesn’t hide your IP.
Using several browsers on purpose is a legitimate privacy habit, but it is narrower than the pitch suggests. XDA Developers writer Mahnoor Faisal argues that nobody needs one browser for everything. Her approach is browser compartmentalization, meaning different browsers for different parts of your online life. For Windows users it is cheap to set up, and it works best when you know what it does and doesn't isolate.

A desktop graphic compares three color-coded browser profiles and notes that compartmentalization doesn’t hide your IP. The idea in brief​

Faisal's pitch is simple. If one browser holds your work accounts, personal email, shopping, social media and banking, then cookies, history, sign-in sessions and extensions all sit in one place. Split them up and a tracker or extension in one browser has less to link to.

Her example layout looks like this:

  • Chrome for Google services such as Gmail, YouTube and Drive, where it works best.
  • Firefox or Opera for everyday browsing that doesn't need a Google sign-in.
  • Brave, Mullvad Browser or Tor Browser for banking, finances, government services and anything you'd rather not have tracked.

She compares this to keeping separate LinkedIn, public Instagram and private social accounts. Merge them and anyone looking you up gets the whole picture at once.

The headline says "four browsers", but the article never names a specific four-app setup. The layout above is her illustration, not a verified configuration or a ranking.

She also gives practical reasons that have nothing to do with privacy:

  • A second browser is a fallback when a site misbehaves.
  • It keeps work and personal browsing apart.
  • It gives you access to browser-specific features.

Faisal says she tests browsers for a living, and that is how the habit started.

What separation actually buys you​

Separate browsers keep separate local state. Cookies, history, logins and extensions in one don't appear in another. Independent write-ups of the technique say the same thing: one outlines the technique as using different browsers for different activities, and another says it reduces how much cookies, saved accounts, extensions and history carry across environments (Chrome for work and Firefox for entertainment is one example; it reduces the ability of cookies, saved accounts, extensions, and browsing history from one environment to follow the user into the other).

The privacy benefit depends on discipline. XDA's earlier explainer notes that users should only log into certain accounts on certain browsers. If you sign into the same Google or Microsoft account in every browser, you've linked them yourself.

What it does not do​

Some write-ups oversell this. One claims compartmentalized activity becomes impossible to track. The documentation doesn't support that.

  • Fingerprinting doesn't need cookies. The Tor Project says browser fingerprinting is not what it describes there, but its own page says websites can track users without cookies. Its documentation also says that keeping activities separate is not a fingerprinting defense. Per Tor's documentation, a unique combination of browser attributes can identify a device even without cookies. Two ordinary browsers on one PC share the same hardware, fonts, screen and OS, so they may look alike to a determined tracker.
  • Your IP address stays the same. Brave's help page says private windows don't hide your IP address or browsing activity from websites, ISPs and network administrators. The same logic applies to a second ordinary browser. Mullvad says its browser doesn't mask your IP either unless you pair it with a VPN.
  • Accounts link you anyway. Signing into the same identity in two browsers ties them together on the server side.

The browsers named, and how they differ​

Faisal groups Brave, Mullvad Browser and Tor Browser together, but they use different models:

BrowserApproach, per vendor documentation
Tor BrowserRoutes traffic through the Tor network. It is based on Firefox ESR with heavy modifications, and cookies last only for a session by default.
Mullvad BrowserDeveloped with the Tor Project and described as a Tor Browser without the Tor network. It uses private mode by default, isolates third-party cookies and aims to make users look alike. It supports Windows, macOS and Linux.
BraveBlocks tracking cookies by default, according to MDN.
FirefoxTotal Cookie Protection gives third-party cookies a separate cookie jar per site when Enhanced Tracking Protection is on, which is the default.
ChromeMDN says it doesn't block third-party cookies by default, only in Incognito or if you change the setting.
EdgeBlocks trackers from unvisited sites and known harmful trackers by default.

The Tor Project also warns against routing other browsers through Tor. It says that exposes you to serious risks of deanonymization and information leakage, so use Tor Browser itself for that job.

Windows angle: Edge and Chrome profiles​

The article doesn't mention Edge, but it is already on every Windows 11 PC. Microsoft documents three tracking-prevention levels at edge://settings/privacy:

  • Basic is the least restrictive. It targets only malicious trackers such as fingerprinters and cryptominers.
  • Balanced is the default. It aims to block trackers from sites you never engage with while limiting compatibility problems.
  • Strict is the most restrictive, and Microsoft warns it can trade site compatibility for privacy.

InPrivate windows in Edge use the same tracking-prevention level as regular windows by default. To change that, open the privacy settings and choose the option to always use Strict tracking prevention in InPrivate.

If installing more apps feels like overkill, profiles are a lighter option. Google says Chrome profiles keep bookmarks, history, passwords and settings separate, and it names work versus personal as a use case. It also warns that anyone with access to your device can switch to another profile and see its information. Profiles organize your data. They are not a security boundary. XDA's earlier explainer says it wouldn't necessarily recommend Chrome profiles when privacy is the goal, and it mentions Firefox Multi-Account Containers as an in-browser alternative.

A practical setup​

This is my own synthesis, not a vendor-verified procedure.

  1. Assign roles. Pick one browser for logged-in daily life, one for general browsing, and one for sensitive tasks.
  2. Don't cross the streams. Avoid signing into the same account in more than one compartment if linkage is your concern.
  3. Keep the sensitive browser lean. Install few or no extensions. Faisal's point is that permissions can let extensions see what you do on pages, so fewer extensions means less exposure.
  4. Pick the right tool for the threat. Tor Browser protects against network observers. Mullvad Browser targets fingerprinting and tracking. A standard private window mostly just forgets local data afterwards.
  5. Use a second browser to diagnose breakage. Stricter tracking controls can break embedded sign-in widgets and similar features. MDN notes that cookie blocking can break site functionality. If a site fails, try another browser. That tells you about compatibility, not safety.

The cost​

More browsers mean more logins, more bookmarks to sync or lose, more settings and more apps to patch. A forgotten browser is a stale one, so check that each updates itself. On a managed work PC, corporate policy may restrict which browsers you can install, and IT may monitor activity regardless of which browser you use.

Verdict​

Compartmentalization is a sound habit with modest claims. It makes routine cross-context linking harder and keeps work and personal browsing from bleeding together. It doesn't make you anonymous, and it doesn't stop fingerprinting, IP-based tracking or account-based correlation. Treat it as one layer alongside tracker blocking, minimal extensions and, where the threat warrants it, Tor or a VPN.

 

References

  1. I use four different browsers on purpose, and it's the best privacy habit I have XDA 2026-10-24T23:00:20+00:00
  2. Manage Chrome with multiple profiles - Computer - Google Chrome Help support.google.com
  3. I use four different browsers on purpose, and it's the best privacy habit I have daily.dev