A Windows monitor shows USB drive removal settings and a file copy marked 100% complete, with a flash drive plugged in.
Most Windows users have a habit they never think about: before pulling out a USB stick, they click the Safely Remove Hardware icon in the system tray and wait for permission. A new MakeUseOf feature by Rob LeFebvre argues that, on most modern Windows PCs, this step stopped being mandatory years ago. Microsoft's own documentation mostly agrees. Mostly is the important word here. The click is optional for many drives, not for all of them, and the safe answer depends on one setting that most people have never opened.

Here's what changed, what didn't, and how to check your own drive in under a minute.

A Windows monitor shows USB drive removal settings and a file copy marked 100% complete, with a flash drive plugged in. The 2018 change most people missed​

Windows has two removal policies for external storage. Microsoft says it defines two main policies, Quick removal and Better performance, that control how the system interacts with external storage devices such as USB thumb drives or Thunderbolt-enabled external drives. The key date: beginning in Windows 10 version 1809, the default policy is Quick removal. In earlier versions of Windows, the default policy was Better performance. Microsoft's management page applies to both Windows 11 and Windows 10.

Microsoft did not announce this when the update shipped. Version 1809 arrived in October 2018, but Born's Tech and Windows World reported that Microsoft announced on April 4, 2019 a change in USB removal policy from Windows 10 version 1809 an later. That six-month gap helps explain why the eject habit outlived the reason for it. Most people heard about the change from tech news, if they heard about it at all.

Some veteran admins dispute the "new default" framing. When Slashdot covered the change in 2019, several commenters said removable drives had shown Quick removal for as long as they could remember. Those are anecdotes, not documentation. Microsoft's official position is the one above: Better performance before 1809, Quick removal from 1809 on.

Section summary: Since Windows 10 version 1809, Windows 10 and 11 have defaulted to Quick removal for external drives. Microsoft only documented the change months after it shipped.

What the two policies actually do​

The old advice existed because of write caching. To speed things up, Windows can hold data in memory and write it to the drive later. Microsoft's Win32 file-caching documentation calls this "lazy writing." It also notes that if a failure happens before the cache is flushed, the cached data is lost. If you pull a drive while data is still waiting in memory, that data never reaches the drive.

Here's how Microsoft describes the two policies on its removal-policy page:

PolicyWrite cachingSafely Remove required?Trade-off
Quick removal (default since 1809)Windows doesn't cache disk writesNo, per MicrosoftCan slow system performance
Better performanceWindows can cache writes to the deviceYes, mandatoryFaster, but you risk data loss if you skip ejecting

Microsoft is blunt about Better performance: if you use the Better performance policy, you must use the Safely Remove Hardware process to remove the device. If you remove or disconnect the device without following the safe removal instructions, you risk losing data. The eject step protects the integrity of data on the device by making sure that all cached operations finish. Microsoft also recommends turning on "Enable write caching on the device" if you choose Better performance.

Under Quick removal, Microsoft says you can remove the device without using Safely Remove Hardware, because Windows isn't holding write operations in cache.

Section summary: On Quick removal, the eject click is optional. On Better performance, skipping it can cost you data.

The catch: the default isn't proof of your setting​

The headline claim breaks down here. The setting belongs to each drive, not to the whole PC. Microsoft says you can change the policy setting for each external device, and the policy that you set remains in effect if you disconnect the device and then connect it again to the same computer port.

That raises an obvious question: who has been changing these settings? Possibly you, a previous IT admin, or a "speed up your USB drive" guide you followed in 2021. Any of them could have switched a drive to Better performance. The setting stays on that drive and port until someone changes it back, and nothing on screen tells you. "Windows defaults to Quick removal" describes a new drive in an untouched setup. It doesn't tell you what your drive is set to.

Microsoft's own advice also contradicts itself. Its consumer support article, "Safely remove hardware in Windows," still tells users to always eject USB flash drives and external hard drives before disconnecting them, to avoid losing data. It doesn't mention removal policies. So it's not quite right to say Microsoft has dropped the eject advice. Its admin documentation says the click is optional on Quick removal, and its consumer help page still says to always do it. If you want one rule, the policy page is the more precise source.

How to check your drive's removal policy​

This is Microsoft's documented procedure for Windows 10 and Windows 11:

  1. Connect the drive to your PC.
  2. Open File Explorer and note the drive's letter or label (for example, "USB Drive (D🙂").
  3. Right-click Start and select Disk Management.
  4. In the lower pane, right-click the drive's label and choose Properties.
  5. Select the Policies tab and see which option is selected.
  6. No Policies tab? Microsoft notes that some recent Windows versions arrange the tabs differently. Select Hardware, pick the removable drive from the All disk drives list, then select Properties. The Policies tab should now appear.
  7. Select the policy you want to use.

If it worked: you'll see either Quick removal or Better performance selected. If it says Better performance, keep ejecting that drive every time, or switch it back to Quick removal.

Common snags:

  • The drive doesn't appear in Disk Management. Windows isn't recognising it. Fix the connection first: try another port or cable.
  • You changed the setting but it seems to have reset. The setting is tied to the device and the port it's plugged into. Plugging into a different port may not keep it, so check again there.
  • Another route: MakeUseOf says MSI lists a path through Device Manager > Disk drives > your drive > Properties > Policies. Microsoft's policy page only documents the Disk Management route, so treat that one as the official procedure.

Quick removal doesn't make unplugging mid-copy safe​

"Ready to remove at any time" means Windows isn't holding writes back in memory. It doesn't mean nothing can go wrong. MakeUseOf makes the same point: pulling a drive during an active write can still corrupt data, and unplugging while an app still has a file open can lose or damage that file. Even Microsoft's file-caching documentation says file system metadata is always cached, so caching never disappears completely.

The working rule for a Quick removal drive:

  • Wait until the copy or save has actually finished.
  • Close any documents or apps using files on the drive.
  • Then unplug.

If the drive has an activity light, this is a good time to watch it.

When to keep clicking eject​

  • The drive is set to Better performance. This is the one case where Microsoft says safe removal is mandatory.
  • You don't know the setting and can't check right now. Ejecting costs two seconds. Recovering a corrupted file costs a lot more.
  • The drive also gets used on a Mac or Linux machine. The Windows policy only controls what Windows does. On those systems, follow their own removal guidance. MakeUseOf notes that macOS still warns when you pull a drive without ejecting it.
  • You tuned a fast external SSD for speed. MakeUseOf reports that MSI suggests Better performance with write caching for heavy transfer work on fast Thunderbolt SSDs. If you go that way, ejecting is part of the deal.

If you've been weighing whether to switch drives to Better performance for speed, our earlier coverage of Quick removal vs Better performance found that speed gains vary from drive to drive. Measure your own drive before deciding the trade-off is worth it.

When Windows says the device is "in use"​

Everyone has seen the eject attempt that ends with Windows refusing because the device is still in use. Microsoft's PowerToys includes File Locksmith, which shows which processes are using a file or folder:

  1. Install PowerToys and enable File Locksmith.
  2. In File Explorer, right-click a file or folder on the drive and choose Show more options.
  3. Select Unlock with File Locksmith.
  4. Review the processes it lists. Processes running under another account may only appear if you restart the tool as administrator.
  5. It's better to close the offending app normally. End task is available, but forcing an app to quit can interrupt whatever it was doing.

File Locksmith only finds processes holding files open. It won't explain every reason an eject fails.

A note for Windows 10 users​

The removal-policy guidance still covers Windows 10. Separately, Microsoft's support pages note that Windows 10 support ended on October 14, 2025. PCs still work, but they no longer get free security fixes through Windows Update. The eject advice holds either way, but the security situation on an unsupported machine is a bigger worry than a USB stick.

The verdict​

The headline says the advice is obsolete. Microsoft's documentation supports a narrower claim: the eject click is no longer required everywhere, but it isn't obsolete in every situation. On a default Windows 10 or 11 setup, with a drive set to Quick removal, Microsoft's policy page says you can skip Safely Remove Hardware, as long as you let transfers finish and close open files first. On a drive set to Better performance, the old advice still applies in full.

Take 30 seconds to check the Policies tab on the drives you use most. Then you'll know which ones need the click.

 

References

  1. The oldest USB advice on your PC is finally obsolete MakeUseOf 2026-10-24T11:30:18+00:00
  2. Windows default media removal policy | Microsoft Learn learn.microsoft.com
  3. Windows 10 V1809: Changes removal policy for USB mediaBorn's Tech and Windows World borncity.com