informations hdd

What is the difference between ATA HDD and Non ATA HDD?

2.5" HDD or SSD what is better for long-term data archiving?

1. Difference Between ATA HDD and Non-ATA HDD
The main difference between ATA HDDs and Non-ATA HDDs lies in the interface protocol and technology they use to communicate with the host system. Here's a breakdown:

---

a. ATA HDDs (ATA-Compliant Drives)​

Definition:

• ATA (Advanced Technology Attachment) is an interface standard used for storage devices like HDDs and SSDs. It enables communication between the drive and a host system, such as a computer or USB enclosure.
• Modern ATA implementations include SATA (Serial ATA), which replaced older PATA (Parallel ATA) standards.

Characteristics:

1. Connection Interface:
   • Modern ATA drives use SATA data and power connectors.
   • Older ATA drives (PATA) used ribbon cables with 40- or 80-pin connectors.
2. Commands:
   • Supports standard ATA/ATAPI commands (e.g., STOP UNIT, STANDBY IMMEDIATE) for operations like head parking and power management.
3. Primary Use:
   • Mostly found in consumer-grade HDDs and SSDs used in laptops, desktops, and external USB enclosures.
4. Examples of ATA HDDs:
   • Seagate ST500LM030 (Barracuda series).
   • Western Digital WD10JPVX (Blue series).
   • SATA SSDs are also ATA-based (e.g., Samsung 870 EVO).

Advantages:

• Widely supported across consumer devices.
• Compatible with standard enclosures and tools like CrystalDiskInfo for health monitoring.

---

b. Non-ATA HDDs (Drives Not Using the ATA Standard)​

Definition:

• Non-ATA HDDs use communication protocols other than ATA. These drives are typically enterprise-grade solutions designed for data centers, servers, and specialized workstations.

Examples of Non-ATA Interfaces:

1. SCSI (Small Computer System Interface):
   • An older protocol predating ATA, used in enterprise HDDs before SATA became mainstream.
   • Data is transmitted via SCSI commands, not ATA.
2. SAS (Serial Attached SCSI):
   • A faster enterprise-grade evolution of SCSI, widely adopted in server environments.
   • SAS interfaces are incompatible with SATA unless specific SAS controllers or adapters are used.
3. Legacy and Obsolete Interfaces:
   • MFM (Modified Frequency Modulation), RLL (Run Length Limited), and early IDE (Integrated Drive Electronics) drives are pre-ATA standards and also fall under Non-ATA drives.

Characteristics:

1. Connection Interface:
   • SAS drives use specific connectors, not SATA connectors.
   • SCSI and SAS rely on different pin configurations compared to ATA drives.
2. Commands:
   • Non-ATA drives use protocols like SCSI/SAS commands.
   • Example: START STOP UNIT is the SCSI/SAS equivalent of STOP UNIT for head parking.
3. Primary Use:
   • Enterprise environments for applications requiring high-speed data transfer, reliability, and scalability.
   • Often used in RAID setups and server arrays.
4. Examples of Non-ATA Drives:
   • Seagate Exos SAS drives.
   • Older SCSI-based drives from the 1990s.

Advantages:

• Higher reliability and dual-port performance for critical workloads (e.g., SAS).
• Tailored for professional environments rather than consumer use.

---

Summary of ATA vs Non-ATA Differences​

---

2. For Long-Term Data Archiving: 2.5" HDD vs. SSD – Which Is Better?​

The suitability of HDDs or SSDs for long-term data archival depends on factors like data retention, durability, cost, and usage requirements. Here’s a comparison to determine which is better for long-term storage.

---

a. 2.5" HDDs for Long-Term Archiving​

Advantages:

1. Data Retention in Unpowered States:
   • Magnetic platters used in HDDs hold data for a long time—typically 5–10 years or more in stable, controlled environments (moderate humidity, temperature).
   • Unlike SSDs, HDDs do not rely on electric charges stored in NAND flash cells.
2. Cost-Effective for Large Capacities:
   • HDDs are much cheaper per GB compared to SSDs, making them ideal for archiving large datasets (e.g., movies, backups, historical records).
3. Mature Technology:
   • HDDs have decades of development behind them, and major brands like Seagate, WD, and Toshiba produce reliable devices for archival purposes.
4. Cold Storage Benefits:
   • HDDs are well-suited for cold storage (low-power storage accessed infrequently).

Disadvantages:

1. Vulnerable to Physical Shock:
   • HDDs are prone to head-platter contact or mechanical failure if mishandled while active.
2. Slower Access Speeds:
   • Read/write speeds are significantly slower than SSDs, especially for random-access operations.

---

b. SSDs for Long-Term Archiving​

Advantages:

1. Durability Against Physical Shock:
   • SSDs have no moving parts, making them far more resistant to physical impacts (e.g., drops or vibrations) than HDDs.
2. Fast Access Times:
   • SSDs offer superior read/write speeds, making them ideal for frequently accessed backups or time-critical archives.
3. Portability:
   • Their compact size and resilience to external environments make SSDs excellent for portable archival setups.

Disadvantages:

1. Data Retention in Unpowered States:
   • NAND flash cells lose their charge over time. Depending on the SSD type and storage environment:
     • Consumer-grade SSDs (TLC/QLC NAND) typically retain data for 5–10 years in unpowered states. This is lower than HDDs.
     • High-quality enterprise SSDs (SLC/MLC NAND) have better retention but are far more expensive.
2. Cost per GB:
   • SSDs are significantly more expensive per GB than HDDs, and the gap grows wider for higher capacities.
3. Limited Write Endurance:
   • Flash cells degrade after repeated write operations, making SSDs less ideal for archival workflows involving write-intensive tasks.

---

c. Recommended Use Cases for Each​

---

3. Summary of 2.5" HDD vs. SSD for Long-Term Archival​

---

4. Final Recommendation for Long-Term Data Archival​

• Choose 2.5” HDDs for:
  • Cold Storage: Large datasets with infrequent access (e.g., photo or video archives, system backups).
  • Cost Efficiency: Best choice when price per GB matters (e.g., large-scale archival setups).
• Choose 2.5” SSDs for:
  • Fast Access: Archives requiring regular reads/writes (e.g., small business files).
  • Durability and Portability: Resilience against physical wear and tear in portable environments.

---

Would you like recommendations for specific high-capacity 2.5" HDDs or SSDs tuned for archival? Let me know!​

ST500LM030, WDC WD10JPVX-08JC3T5 and HTS541010A99E662 is ATA HDD or Non ATA HDD?

The ST500LM030, WDC WD10JPVX-08JC3T5, and HTS541010A99E662 are all ATA HDDs (not Non-ATA HDDs). They use the SATA (Serial ATA) interface, which is the modern implementation of the Advanced Technology Attachment (ATA) standard. Here's a breakdown of why they are considered ATA HDDs and the implications of this:

---

1. Why These Drives Are ATA HDDs​

a. ST500LM030 (Seagate Barracuda Mobile Series):​

• Technology: SATA-based HDD using the Serial ATA interface, which operates on ATA/ATAPI standards.
• ATA Command Compatibility: Fully supports ATA commands such as:
  • SYNCHRONIZE CACHE: Ensures all pending data is written to the platters.
  • STOP UNIT: Parks the read/write heads securely for drive protection during safe removal.
  • STANDBY IMMEDIATE: Spins down the platters as part of power management or ejection processes.
• Usage: Designed for laptops, external HDD enclosures, and general-purpose consumer storage.

b. WDC WD10JPVX-08JC3T5 (Western Digital Blue Series):​

• Technology: SATA-based drive using ATA standards.
• Key Features:
  • Equipped with WD’s proprietary IntelliPark technology for head parking.
  • Uses ATA commands for efficient power management, head control, and SMART monitoring.
• Usage: Popular in laptops and portable storage solutions.

c. HTS541010A99E662 (Hitachi/Toshiba/Apple HDD):​

• Technology: Designed as a SATA HDD adhering to the Load/Unload feature set on the ATA standard.
• Head Management:
  • The drive employs Load/Unload ramps that park the heads using commands like STOP UNIT when ejected safely.
• Usage: Common in portable laptops and branded external storage solutions (e.g., Apple products).

---

2. Characteristics of ATA HDDs (Why These Are Not Non-ATA)​

These drives comply with the ATA specification and are SATA (Serial ATA) drives, not Non-ATA (e.g., SCSI or SAS). Here's why:

a. Data Protocol: ATA​

• These drives operate using ATA/ATAPI commands, which are the communication protocols that facilitate operations like head parking, platters spinning down, cache synchronization, etc.
• Commands like STOP UNIT and SYNCHRONIZE CACHE are specifically part of the ATA standard.

b. Interface:​

• The SATA connectors used by these drives are designed to physically and logically operate with ATA controllers.
• SATA is the successor to PATA (Parallel ATA), which has been replaced since the early 2000s due to its slower data rates and bulky ribbon cables.

c. Compatibility:​

• Compatible with USB-to-SATA bridge controllers commonly found in enclosures like Kesu 2530 or Orico 25PW1.
• Non-ATA drives, such as SAS (Serial Attached SCSI), would require entirely different protocols and physical cables.

---

3. How These Drives Differ from Non-ATA HDDs​

Non-ATA HDDs (such as SCSI or SAS drives) operate under entirely different communication protocols—SCSI or SAS, rather than ATA. Here’s how these three ATA drives are different:

---

4. Support for Head Parking in ATA HDDs​

a. Automatic Head Parking via ATA Commands:​

• All three drives—ST500LM030, WD10JPVX, and HTS541010A99E662—use the ATA STOP UNIT command to park heads securely after the "Safely Remove Hardware" process in Windows.
• When ejected, the drive firmware ensures the heads are moved safely to a Load/Unload parking ramp (or equivalent parking zone).

b. Compatibility with Enclosures like Kesu 2530 and Orico 25PW1:​

• SATA enclosures equipped with appropriate USB-to-SATA bridge controllers (e.g., JMicron JMS578) fully support ATA commands and translate USB device ejection commands like STOP UNIT to the drives.
• These enclosures ensure that the heads are parked properly, even if the USB cable remains connected after ejection.

---

5. Summary​

Final Answer:​

• All three HDDs—Seagate ST500LM030, WDC WD10JPVX-08JC3T5, and HTS541010A99E662—are ATA HDDs.
• With proper enclosures and when ejected using "Safely Remove Hardware", these drives will correctly park their heads and spin down safely.

Would you like assistance verifying these functions post-ejection or using tools like CrystalDiskInfo to monitor performance? Let me know!

For long-term archiving, 2.5" HDDs and SSDs are the best options. HDDs last long but have moving parts, while SSDs are more durable. Pendrives and microSD cards aren't ideal for long-term storage. It's also important to refresh your data on newer media over time.

nandobadam88 said:

Which of these media is more reliable and safe for long-term data archiving: 2.5" HDD, SSD, Pendrive, MicroSD card?

Click to expand...

What year were the ST500LM030 and WDC WD10JPVX-08JC3T5, APPLE HDD HTS541010A99E662 HDDs released?

what year released kesu 2530 and orico 25pw1?

enclosure case usb 3.0 needs to have which function to transmit all Windows commands to the 2.5" HDD after ejecting and safely removing hardware?