Is Windows 11 Worth It? Pros, Cons, and Gaming Performance

  • Thread Author
As Windows 10 bows out gracefully from the limelight of supported operating systems, it’s time to scrutinize its successor, Windows 11. In a world where operating systems can create as many fans as they do foes, Windows 11 has found its way into the hearts (and desktops) of many. Yes, I’m here to convince you that Windows 11 really isn’t that bad, as suggested by a fresh take from PC Gamer.

A Deep Dive into Windows 11​

With nearly ubiquitous adoption in the PC market—where buying a new laptop or desktop typically comes with Windows 11 pre-installed—this operating system stands on a precipice of perspectives. At the time of writing, over 207,000 titles on Steam are compatible with Windows, overshadowing other operating systems like macOS and SteamOS. This alone makes it a go-to choice for gamers, who often find their experiences tied to the software they run.

The Initial Boot Camp​

Upon its debut, Windows 11 didn’t enter the scene unscathed. Critics aimed their digital pitchforks at its redesign—the relocation of the Start button to the center of the taskbar and other aesthetic changes. While these may seem trivial, they stirred passionate debates among users who very much preferred the "classic" look and feel of Windows.As an Epic Games fan biting into a new expansion pack, gaming preferences can be subjective!
Moreover, the separation of the Settings app from the Control Panel has led many users to throw their hands in the air, wondering why Microsoft added confusion to the mix. As for customization, let's just say that options feel a bit too confined for some users' tastes, with the taskbar's placement remaining static in a world where freedom can mean drag-and-drop.

Security Over Convenience​

Microsoft’s new hardware security requirements raised eyebrows faster than a game of hide-and-seek with a mouse. Old hardware enthusiasts found themselves alienated, but this adjustment—though annoying—pushes users towards improved security practices such as Secure Boot, shielding them from malware. It's a good shift, albeit difficult for those attached to their trusty, if aging, PCs.
While nostalgically reminiscing about your old hardware, remember that Windows XP once had to make similarly controversial changes when introducing enhanced security features. Change is hard, but security should, ideally, be paramount.

The Elephant in the Room: Performance​

Let’s shift gears—from aesthetics to what really matters: performance. Windows 11 offers several modern gaming enhancements like Auto HDR, a core scheduler tailored for newer Intel architectures, and smoother windowed gaming experiences. If only we could automate our handling of tangled cables too!
PC Gamer’s own tests suggest that in raw frame rates, Windows 11 often matches or exceeds the performance of competing operating systems, including streams on the Steam Deck. Additionally, it seamlessly coexists with dual-boots and can run side-by-side with other operating systems, giving users the freedom to experiment. Nothing like the flavor of choice, right?

Throwing Shade: Microsoft’s Data Practices​

On the flip side, the notorious reputation of Windows 11 isn't solely driven by its performance but also by privacy concerns. Critics have raised issues surrounding the operating system’s telemetry and ads that can feel a bit intrusive, especially during setups. You can simply turn off the Widgets feature in Taskbar Settings, but the shadow of potential data mining lingers ominously.

Real World Rules: Windows 11’s Growing Pains​

The reality is that not every user’s experience is equally positive. Yet, with over 48% of users already transitioning from Windows 10 to Windows 11, it’s clear that the new system is steadily gaining traction. Gaming development and driver support are increasingly centered on Windows 11, thus entrenching it as the mainstay in today’s gaming ecosystem.
And while you may hear rumblings about colorful performance issues or the latest security patch feeling lackluster, it’s essential to keep in mind that no operating system is without its glitches.

Conclusion: To Upgrade or Not to Upgrade?​

Sure, Windows 11 isn’t without flaws, but neither is it the fiend some critics have painted. The combination of improved gaming functionalities, robust security measures, and increasing adoption rates suggests you're not barking up the wrong tree by diving into Windows 11.
As we stand on the precipice of a new year, it’s essential to weigh these considerations carefully. Whether you’re a seasoned gamer, a casual PC user, or just someone hoping to keep your spreadsheets organized while tending to your vegetable garden (a subtle nod to PC Gamer's writer, Ian Evenden), there’s something exciting about what Windows 11 offers.
So let’s raise a cup of cocoa to Windows 11—not as a herald of doom, but as another chapter in the ever-evolving saga of computing. After all, what’s the worst that could happen? At the very least, you can always go back to playing "old faithful" on Windows 10—until that ship officially sinks below the waves of support, that is.

Source: PC Gamer Windows 11 really isn't that bad
 
Last edited:
The gaming landscape is always evolving, and with Microsoft’s recent launch of Windows 11, the million-dollar question remains: Is it worth upgrading for gamers? The stakes are high, as the choices made by millions of players could reshape their digital experiences. While Windows 11 comes with a variety of features designed to enhance gaming, the decision to upgrade requires a deep dive into what sets it apart from its predecessor, Windows 10.

Performance: Understanding the Game​

Let's start with the crux of the matter: performance. It’s tempting to believe that a new operating system will bring a noticeable performance leap, but the reality often lands somewhere in the middle. Testing reveals that the gaming performance between Windows 10 and Windows 11 is surprisingly similar. Benchmark results show that identical hardware can yield almost identical results, with Windows 11 boasting slightly better overall performance metrics in most tests. However, it’s critical to note that frame rate (FPS) performances can be a mixed bag; some games might perform better on Windows 11 while others may see a dip in FPS.
In essence, upgrading for raw performance may not be compelling enough unless you're dealing with specific features that can truly elevate your gaming. So, what are these features?

The New Gaming Arsenal: Windows 11 Features for Gamers​

Windows 11 introduces some impressive features that initially appeared in Xbox consoles and are designed to ramp up gaming on PCs:
  • DirectStorage: This ground-breaking feature allows games to load assets directly from the storage device to the graphics card, effectively slashing load times and minimizing CPU load. For those wielding NVMe SSDs, the performance gains can be substantial. If your gaming rig is decked out with a top-tier NVMe SSD and a compatible GPU, you can expect a noticeable decrease in loading screens, paving the way for immersive gameplay.
  • Auto HDR: Previously reserved for Xbox Series X, this feature enhances the visual experience by upscaling Standard Dynamic Range (SDR) content to High Dynamic Range (HDR). This means more vibrant colors and improved brightness in games that don’t have native HDR support, provided that you own an HDR-capable monitor.

How to Enable Auto HDR​

To maximize your visual experience, here’s a quick guide:
  • Open Settings (Windows Key + i).
  • Navigate to System > Display > HDR.
  • Enable both Use HDR and Auto HDR toggles.

Should Avid Gamers Hit the Upgrade Button?​

For avid gamers, the decision to upgrade hinges on their specific setups and needs. If your machine meets the recommended hardware specifications, particularly with a TPM 2.0 security chip, and is geared towards gaming (think speedy NVMe SSDs and compatible graphics cards), the upgrade could enhance your gaming experience.
However, if your current setup is working well with Windows 10, particularly if your hardware is on the lower end or doesn’t support the latest features, it might be wise to hold off. Windows 11 brings its own set of quirks, especially around hardware compatibility. Before going all out, check forums and community feedback to gauge any ongoing issues with drivers that may affect your system's performance post-update.

What About Downgrading?​

If you do decide to upgrade and encounter any significant issues, remember that you have a 10-day window to revert back to Windows 10 without losing your files. It’s best to run a variety of games post-upgrade to ensure everything runs smoothly.

Optimizing Windows 11 for Gaming​

Windows 11 comes with a built-in Game Mode, which helps to optimize the system for gaming. This can be turned on or off and can improve overall gaming performance if you've been experiencing sluggish performance:
  • Access Game Mode: Head to Settings > Gaming > Game Mode, toggle it on if it’s off.
  • Allocate Graphics: For systems with both integrated and dedicated graphics, set specific games to run on the high-performance GPU for optimal results.

Final Thoughts​

In conclusion, deciding to upgrade to Windows 11 as a gamer takes careful consideration. While the OS offers features like DirectStorage and Auto HDR that can enrich your gaming experience, the actual performance boost may not be as significant as you might hope unless your hardware is up to par. Always weigh the benefits against potential issues, and consider your personal gaming needs before making the leap.
With all this talk about features and performance, it’s clear that the gaming world is more competitive than ever, making every detail paramount. So, are you ready to upgrade, or will you stick with Windows 10 for now? Your gaming experience might depend on it.

Source: Lifewire Is Upgrading to Windows 11 a Win for Gamers? Here's What the Data Says
 
Last edited: