It seems that Microsoft has thrown a curveball into the tech world again, and this time, the stage is the European cloud-services market. The software leviathan has joined the Cloud Infrastructure Services Providers of Europe (CISPE) mere months after resolving an anti-competitive licensing dispute that had CISPE brawling with Microsoft in front of regulators. The move is shrouded in intrigue, a touch of skepticism, and significant implications for the future of cloud computing.
Let’s dissect this development with a blend of razor-sharp facts and expert insight on the underlying technologies, rivalries, and cascading effects this membership might bring.
Let's set the stage. For years, Microsoft has dominated software markets with its comprehensive portfolios, ranging from Windows Server OS to Azure cloud services. But that dominant position has come under fire, especially from entities like CISPE—a trade body representing cloud providers, including heavy hitters like AWS and a chorus of smaller European players.
CISPE's beef with Microsoft dating back to 2022 was simple yet explosive: Microsoft's licensing terms made it substantially more expensive to run Windows Server or other software on non-Azure cloud platforms. CISPE estimated this licensing scheme cost public and private sectors in Europe nearly €1 billion annually. Imagine having to pay exorbitant "taxes" just for the freedom to run software you already bought on infrastructure that isn’t Microsoft-owned. Understandably, CISPE called it a "software license tax"—a damning phrase.
This sparked a high-profile anti-trust complaint filed with the European Commission. In July 2023, however, the two parties hammered out a settlement. CISPE withdrew the complaint after Microsoft agreed to launch an enhanced Azure Stack HCI program tailored for European providers, complete with opportunities to level the cloud competition field somewhat. Oh, and there was an undisclosed cash payment handed over to sweeten the deal.
Fast-forward to the present, and Microsoft is now a member of this very organization that once wore the plaintiff’s hat.
Adding fuel to the fire, the UK’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) is also knee-deep in scrutinizing cloud services—part of broader action enabled by the Digital Markets Competition and Consumer Act. The timing complicates matters for Microsoft, which may need to tread carefully in these active regulatory waters.
What’s your take? Is Microsoft driving its cloud competitors into consolidation, or is this a genuine move to turn rivals into partners? The story continues, with plenty of chapters left to unfold. Share your thoughts on this tectonic shift in cloud politics!
Source: Computing UK Microsoft joins CISPE months after settling claim over anti-competitive practices
Let’s dissect this development with a blend of razor-sharp facts and expert insight on the underlying technologies, rivalries, and cascading effects this membership might bring.
A Quick Recap of the Tech Drama
Let's set the stage. For years, Microsoft has dominated software markets with its comprehensive portfolios, ranging from Windows Server OS to Azure cloud services. But that dominant position has come under fire, especially from entities like CISPE—a trade body representing cloud providers, including heavy hitters like AWS and a chorus of smaller European players.CISPE's beef with Microsoft dating back to 2022 was simple yet explosive: Microsoft's licensing terms made it substantially more expensive to run Windows Server or other software on non-Azure cloud platforms. CISPE estimated this licensing scheme cost public and private sectors in Europe nearly €1 billion annually. Imagine having to pay exorbitant "taxes" just for the freedom to run software you already bought on infrastructure that isn’t Microsoft-owned. Understandably, CISPE called it a "software license tax"—a damning phrase.
This sparked a high-profile anti-trust complaint filed with the European Commission. In July 2023, however, the two parties hammered out a settlement. CISPE withdrew the complaint after Microsoft agreed to launch an enhanced Azure Stack HCI program tailored for European providers, complete with opportunities to level the cloud competition field somewhat. Oh, and there was an undisclosed cash payment handed over to sweeten the deal.
Fast-forward to the present, and Microsoft is now a member of this very organization that once wore the plaintiff’s hat.
Friendly Ally or Trojan Horse?
Joining CISPE after a heated licensing dispute begs several questions. Is Microsoft truly warming up to competition, or is this just strategic maneuvering to soften its opponents? Let’s break this down:- Microsoft’s Role in CISPE
Microsoft is not entering CISPE as a voting member. This limits its power to sway policies directly, but adding the Redmond giant to the group fosters an image of inclusion for a body frequently criticized as “AWS's megaphone.” After all, AWS is also a member of CISPE, showing this isn’t just a club of small cloud players. - For Better or Worse?
Not everyone in CISPE might be thrilled about Microsoft’s membership. While the settlements sound promising, lingering resentment could brew among members who feel Microsoft’s very presence is counterproductive to CISPE’s mission of promoting competition and neutral infrastructure services.
Azure Stack HCI: Microsoft’s Ace?
As part of the settlement with CISPE, Microsoft pledged to enhance Azure Stack HCI, a hybrid cloud solution designed for hosting partner ecosystems. Let’s pause for a technical deep dive:What Is Azure Stack HCI?
Azure Stack HCI is a hybrid cloud platform that enables businesses and providers to operate on-premises data centers while seamlessly integrating with Azure services. Essentially, it’s an infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS) solution optimized for hosting virtual machines, containers, and databases locally. Here's how it works:- Hyper-Converged Infrastructure (HCI):
Azure Stack HCI packages compute, storage, and networking into a single solution, enabling businesses to deploy virtualized workloads cost-efficiently. - Azure Management Continuity:
Organizations can extend Azure’s cloud-native features such as resource scaling, VM management, and AI-driven analytics onto their local data centers via this stack. - Targeted at Competition:
By making a tailored offering in Europe (with a possible price adjustment), Microsoft was able to address CISPE’s gripe about anti-competitive pricing. Whether this is a mere gesture or breakthrough remains debatable.
The Cloud Wars Continue
Meanwhile, other disputes are escalating. Google's September 2023 anti-trust complaint with the European Commission borrows a page from CISPE’s playbook. Google argues Microsoft is stifling competition through licensing deals that harm non-Azure clouds and cloud-agnostic innovation. To spearhead its own market interests, Google joined the Open Cloud Coalition to advocate for interoperability across platforms.Adding fuel to the fire, the UK’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) is also knee-deep in scrutinizing cloud services—part of broader action enabled by the Digital Markets Competition and Consumer Act. The timing complicates matters for Microsoft, which may need to tread carefully in these active regulatory waters.
What’s Next? Big Decisions & Bigger Consequences
Microsoft’s membership in CISPE is an undeniable milestone, but the tech industry’s competitive landscape is still fraught with key unresolved battles:Upcoming Dynamics
- European Regulator Scrutiny
With Microsoft under the European Commission’s microscope, any misstep in fulfilling its settlement (e.g., enhancements to Azure Stack HCI) could spark renewed complaints—not just from CISPE but also from rivals like Google or even AWS. - CISPE's Hypocrisy?
Will CISPE risk alienating members or losing credibility by sheltering one of its biggest oppressors? If Microsoft doesn’t deliver as promised, CISPE could face uncomfortable repercussions. - Economic Influence via CMA Leadership
Doug Gurr’s appointment as interim CMA chair may add dynamism to ongoing investigations into big tech practices. It isn’t hard to connect the timing of his appointment to larger economic objectives, heightening the drama for potential CMA rulings against Microsoft. - Broader Implications
If licensing terms become significantly more favorable for European providers (or if a rebound complaint arises), it could signal broader shifts in power for the EU’s cloud services market.
Bottom Line: A Double-Edged Sword?
Microsoft joining the group that once derided it is either a masterstroke of diplomacy or the perfect way to divide and conquer rivals from within. While nobody can fault a giant like Microsoft for aiming to dominate, achieving that through mutually beneficial solutions (like fair pricing and innovation-focused settlements) might be the smarter long-term play. But as it stands, skepticism abounds.What’s your take? Is Microsoft driving its cloud competitors into consolidation, or is this a genuine move to turn rivals into partners? The story continues, with plenty of chapters left to unfold. Share your thoughts on this tectonic shift in cloud politics!
Source: Computing UK Microsoft joins CISPE months after settling claim over anti-competitive practices
Last edited:
