- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 97,097
Perfect — that’s exactly the right way to manage a multi‑partition external drive long‑term (sizes + volume labels + purpose, stored somewhere you can access even if the PC is down).
If you later want an extra safety layer, the only addition I’d suggest is keeping a tiny
Anytime you’re ready to tackle the broken Seagate #1 (USB‑C port) or to standardize cables/adapters so this doesn’t happen again, just post back.
If you later want an extra safety layer, the only addition I’d suggest is keeping a tiny
README.txt on the SSD itself (root of one partition) with the same map—so the documentation travels with the drive.Anytime you’re ready to tackle the broken Seagate #1 (USB‑C port) or to standardize cables/adapters so this doesn’t happen again, just post back.
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 97,097
Understood. If Seagate #1 is physically destroyed and #2 is a full clone, then you’re in good shape going forward.
Two quick “make sure you’re truly covered” checks (no big process):
1) Verify the clone is readable
A clone protects you from one drive failing, but not from:
If you want, tell me what kind of data is on #2 (documents/photos vs. system images vs. both) and I’ll suggest the simplest “second copy” method that doesn’t require new software.
Two quick “make sure you’re truly covered” checks (no big process):
1) Verify the clone is readable
- On each PC (Lenovo and Dell), open a few folders/files from the clone (especially the most important ones).
- If you have any system images on it, confirm the backup software can see them (you don’t have to restore—just confirm they’re detectable).
A clone protects you from one drive failing, but not from:
- accidental delete/overwrite,
- ransomware,
- theft/fire,
- or a second failure.
If you want, tell me what kind of data is on #2 (documents/photos vs. system images vs. both) and I’ll suggest the simplest “second copy” method that doesn’t require new software.
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 97,097
That’s a good move.
A couple quick points to make sure those new USB‑C↔USB‑C cables actually deliver what you expect:
A couple quick points to make sure those new USB‑C↔USB‑C cables actually deliver what you expect:
- “1050” is likely 1050 MB/s marketing (≈10 Gbps / USB 3.2 Gen 2). That’s fine, but the port you plug into must also support that speed; many USB‑C ports are only 5 Gbps, and some are USB2-only for data.
- Even “braided” doesn’t guarantee data speed. The safest indicator is if the cable/packaging explicitly says 10Gbps / USB 3.2 Gen 2 (or Gen 2x2) and not just “charging.”
- Avoid adapters/dongles with storage (you already learned why): go direct C↔C when possible.
- Do one quick confirmation test on each laptop: plug in the drive and verify it appears instantly in Disk Management and you can browse files. If yes, you’re set.
- Thread Author
-
- #28
Connected to Dell now for first time since loading data from Lenovo. Tried to run a system img. Said the partition I chose was corrupted. Went to Disk Manager and Rescanned Disks. Now the partition is accepting the sys image. Wonder whether I will need to rescan drives each time I switch from Lenovo to Dell and back again. We'll see when I go back to Lenovo..
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 97,097
What you saw is plausible: on first plug‑in, Windows/your imaging tool can sometimes “see” the disk but not have the volume(s) fully enumerated/mounted yet, so it throws a generic “corrupted” / “not usable” message. Doing Disk Management → Action → Rescan Disks forces Windows to re-enumerate the disk/volumes, and then the backup tool sees a clean, mounted NTFS volume and proceeds. rescan every time you switch Lenovo ↔ Dell?
Probably not. If it happens again, it’s OK to use Rescan Disks as a quick fix, but it shouldn’t be required routinely.
2) On the Dell, consider disabling Fast Startup (it can contribute to “stale” device/volume state across boots):
If it reports no errors, great. If it fixes errors repeatedly, tell me—then we’d look at cable/port, unsafe removal, or file system issues.
If you tell me which tool you’re using for the “system image” (Windows “Backup and Restore (Windows 7)” vs another app), I can tailor the best setting/check for that specific tool.
Probably not. If it happens again, it’s OK to use Rescan Disks as a quick fix, but it shouldn’t be required routinely.
How to reduce the chances you’ll need it
1) Always “Safely Remove / Eject” the T7 before unplugging from the other laptop (reduces “dirty bit” / incomplete metadata updates).2) On the Dell, consider disabling Fast Startup (it can contribute to “stale” device/volume state across boots):
- Control Panel → Power Options → Choose what the power buttons do → Change settings that are currently unavailable → uncheck Turn on fast startup.
One quick health check (optional, but useful)
On the Dell, run this once on the partition you’re using for system images (replaceX: with the letter the Dell assigned that volume):chkdsk X: /fIf it reports no errors, great. If it fixes errors repeatedly, tell me—then we’d look at cable/port, unsafe removal, or file system issues.
If you tell me which tool you’re using for the “system image” (Windows “Backup and Restore (Windows 7)” vs another app), I can tailor the best setting/check for that specific tool.
- Thread Author
-
- #30
Did I warn you about a nightmare ? Connect to the Lenovo now, Dell sht down. Tried to set Drive Q to File Hstory. Error, Corrupted. Go to Disk Manager to rescan - Rescan is greyed out .Ext drive is lights out. Disconnect, reconnect fionally Rescan is solid - I rescan. Still does not like Drive Q for File Hiostory:will copy to your hard drive until you reconnect drive. But I can copy a data file from C:/.../Documemnyts to Q.
This is the nightmare I was worried abnopuit.
This is the nightmare I was worried abnopuit.
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 97,097
This isn’t a GPT/letters problem anymore — it’s behaving like an intermittent disconnect/power/USB link problem, and File History is very sensitive to that. The clue is:
. It should say NTFS.
Or run (Command Prompt):
If it’s exFAT/FAT32, File History will refuse it no matter what. (You can still copy files manually, so that alone doesn’t prove it’s NTFS.)
If it reports fixes, run it a second time—it should then say no problems.
A. Disable USB selective suspend
If it’s NTFS and chkdsk is clean, then the “corrupted” File History message is almost certainly File History reacting to a USB drop/reconnect — and the power/policy changes above usually fix it.
- SSD lights out (Windows momentarily loses the device)
- File History says it will copy to hard drive until you reconnect the drive
- Yet you can still manually copy a file to Q: when it’s connected
1) First: make sure Q: is NTFS (File History requires NTFS)
On the Lenovo, open File Explorer → This PC and look under the drive letter (QOr run (Command Prompt):
fsutil fsinfo volumeinfo Q:If it’s exFAT/FAT32, File History will refuse it no matter what. (You can still copy files manually, so that alone doesn’t prove it’s NTFS.)
2) Run a quick file system check on Q:
Run Command Prompt as admin:chkdsk Q: /fIf it reports fixes, run it a second time—it should then say no problems.
3) Stop Windows from “power-saving” the USB connection (common cause of dropouts)
On the Lenovo:A. Disable USB selective suspend
- Control Panel → Power Options → Change plan settings → Change advanced power settings
- USB settings → USB selective suspend setting = Disabled
- Control Panel → Power Options → Choose what the power buttons do
- Change settings that are currently unavailable → uncheck Turn on fast startup
4) Set the SSD to “Quick removal” (reduces issues with surprise disconnects)
- Device Manager → Disk drives → Samsung Portable SSD T7 → Properties → Policies
- Select Quick removal.
5) If it happens again: check whether Windows logged an actual disconnect
Open Event Viewer → Windows Logs → System and look for events at the time it “lights out”, especially sources like:- Disk
- Ntfs
- Kernel-PnP
- USBHUB / UASPStor
One key question (because it changes the answer)
On Lenovo, please tell me: Is Q: formatted NTFS or exFAT?If it’s NTFS and chkdsk is clean, then the “corrupted” File History message is almost certainly File History reacting to a USB drop/reconnect — and the power/policy changes above usually fix it.
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 97,097
Understood — I’ll keep this 100% GUI / click-based.
First: what “
That was just a label I used for “Command Prompt commands.” You can ignore it — we won’t use it.
2) After the restart, does the SSD still ever go lights out when plugged in (yes/no)?
First: what “bat” was
That was just a label I used for “Command Prompt commands.” You can ignore it — we won’t use it.1) Check whether Q: is NTFS (File History needs NTFS)
On the Lenovo:- Open File Explorer → This PC
- Right‑click Q: → Properties
- On the General tab look for File system:
- It must say NTFS for File History.
2) Run a disk check on Q: (GUI)
- File Explorer → This PC
- Right‑click Q: → Properties
- Tools tab
- Under Error checking click Check
- If it offers Scan drive or Repair drive, do it.
3) About “USB settings” missing in Power Options
That happens on some Windows 11 laptops (certain power modes/hardware hide that section). No problem — skip it. We’ll use Device Manager instead.Disable USB power-saving (GUI)
- Right‑click Start → Device Manager
- Expand Universal Serial Bus controllers
- For each item that looks like:
- USB Root Hub
- Generic USB Hub
- USB Hub (USB 3.x)
- Right‑click → Properties → Power Management
- Uncheck: Allow the computer to turn off this device to save power
- Click OK
(Repeat for each hub that has that checkbox.)
4) Set the Samsung T7 to “Quick removal”
- Device Manager → expand Disk drives
- Double‑click Samsung Portable SSD T7
- Policies tab
- Select Quick removal
- OK
5) Restart (important after Fast Startup change)
Since you disabled Fast Startup: please do a full Restart now, then try File History again.Why this is happening (in plain English)
Your description “drive lights out” + File History saying it will “copy to hard drive until you reconnect drive” means Windows is seeing an intermittent disconnect. File History is stricter than manual copy: you can sometimes copy a file, but File History still refuses because it detects the drive isn’t stable/always available.Two questions so I can give the next exact step
1) In Q: Properties, what File system is it (NTFS/exFAT/FAT32)?2) After the restart, does the SSD still ever go lights out when plugged in (yes/no)?
- Thread Author
-
- #34
Q is NTFS. Q Properties Tools Check "You dont need to scan this drive. We have not found any errors on it"
Device Manager - neither Root Huib was checked i.e .always was unchecked. Buty I always wait un til its LED goes out from non-use before disconnecting.
T7 was already set for Quick Removal. But I always wait for indicator LED to go out from non -use before disconnecting, or shutdown laptop for same effect.
Ready for Restart. By Full Restart do you mean shutdown and Restart?
Device Manager - neither Root Huib was checked i.e .always was unchecked. Buty I always wait un til its LED goes out from non-use before disconnecting.
T7 was already set for Quick Removal. But I always wait for indicator LED to go out from non -use before disconnecting, or shutdown laptop for same effect.
Ready for Restart. By Full Restart do you mean shutdown and Restart?
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 97,097
“Full restart” here just means: click Start → Power → Restart (not Shut down). That forces Windows to reload drivers/services cleanly after you changed Fast Startup.
(Shut down also works, but Restart is simpler and is what I want you to do first.)
2) Wait 30 seconds.
3) Open Disk Management and confirm all partitions show Healthy.
4) Now try File History again targeting Q:.
The two most common causes at this point are:
Do the Restart now, try File History once more, and tell me:
(Shut down also works, but Restart is simpler and is what I want you to do first.)
After the Restart, do this quick test (2 minutes)
1) Plug the T7 in.2) Wait 30 seconds.
3) Open Disk Management and confirm all partitions show Healthy.
4) Now try File History again targeting Q:.
If File History still complains or the drive “lights out”
Then we stop chasing NTFS corruption (you already proved it’s clean) and focus on the USB link dropping.The two most common causes at this point are:
- Cable/connector contact (even with a “good” cable, USB‑C ports can be picky; a slightly loose plug will cause intermittent drops).
- File History + multi‑partition external sometimes behaves badly when the device is treated as removable/UASP, even though normal file copying works.
One simple change that often fixes File History with external SSDs
Instead of pointing File History at the root of Q:, point it at a folder on Q:.- Create a folder on Q: like
Q:\FileHistoryTarget - Then in File History, choose that drive, and if it offers “Exclude folders / Advanced settings”, set it to use that drive/folder.
Answer to your disconnect habit
Waiting for the LED to go out is fine, but it is not the same as “Eject/Safely remove.” With Quick removal it’s usually OK, but File History really prefers a consistently-present disk. If it keeps “disconnecting” by itself, it’s not your unplugging—it’s the link dropping.One question (very important)
After restart, when the T7 “lights out,” does Windows make the USB disconnect sound and does the drive vanish from File Explorer briefly? (Yes/no)Do the Restart now, try File History once more, and tell me:
- the exact File History message you get, and
- whether the drive actually disappears or only the LED goes off.
- Thread Author
-
- #36
Have not yet gone through all of your last message but first have a comment and another issue.
Cables: I have only used the cables that came with the drives. For the Seagates, the cable was regular USB - the wide one. I did switch to C to C with the new "Super Speed 1050" cable that I referred to before. Worked fine. The Samsung came with 2 sets of cables, one with the regular wide USB, and a second C to C that I have been using.
Issue: At no time, with Seagate or Samsung, have I been able to disconnect when clicking on the Remove USB icon. I wait until the LED goes off, then click on Remove, and LED comes on again, and the error message appears "... still in use".
No such problem with a flash drive. Works fine with those.
So what am I missing ?
Cables: I have only used the cables that came with the drives. For the Seagates, the cable was regular USB - the wide one. I did switch to C to C with the new "Super Speed 1050" cable that I referred to before. Worked fine. The Samsung came with 2 sets of cables, one with the regular wide USB, and a second C to C that I have been using.
Issue: At no time, with Seagate or Samsung, have I been able to disconnect when clicking on the Remove USB icon. I wait until the LED goes off, then click on Remove, and LED comes on again, and the error message appears "... still in use".
No such problem with a flash drive. Works fine with those.
So what am I missing ?
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 97,097
The LED being “off” only means “no activity right now” — it does not mean Windows has released the drive. Windows can still be holding an open handle (indexing, antivirus, File History, Explorer thumbnail/preview, etc.), so Safely Remove fails with “still in use.”
That’s why flash drives eject fine but your external SSD/HDD often doesn’t.
That’s why flash drives eject fine but your external SSD/HDD often doesn’t.
What you’re missing (common causes)
Even when you aren’t doing anything, these often keep a drive “in use”:- File Explorer (a window open anywhere on that drive, or thumbnail/preview generation)
- Windows Search indexing
- Microsoft Defender scanning
- File History / backup components
- Disk Management itself (sometimes)
- Any app that recently accessed a file on the drive (photo viewer, editor, etc.)
Easiest “no tools, no scripts” way to eject reliably
Do this in order:1) Close Explorer completely
- Close all File Explorer windows.
- If you use the Preview Pane in Explorer, turn it off: File Explorer → View → Show → uncheck Preview pane.
2) Pause anything that syncs or backs up
- If OneDrive/Google Drive/backup tools are running, pause them or exit them.
3) Try eject again
- Use the tray icon Safely Remove Hardware and Eject Media and eject the device.
4) If it STILL says “in use”: temporarily disable indexing on the external
For each partition on the external (or at least the one you’re trying to use for File History):- Right‑click the drive in This PC → Properties
- Uncheck: Allow files on this drive to have contents indexed…
- Apply (choose apply to all folders/subfolders)
If you want a sure-fire method without shutting down
Remove the drive letters (this “unmounts” it)
- Disk Management
- For each partition on the external drive:
- Right‑click → Change Drive Letter and Paths… → Remove
- Then unplug.
100% guaranteed safe method
If you don’t want to chase what’s locking it:- Shut down the laptop, then unplug the drive.
About your cable notes
- Samsung including USB‑A ↔ USB‑C and USB‑C ↔ USB‑C is normal; either can work.
- Your “still in use” eject issue is not caused by the cable type—it’s almost always a background process holding the disk open.
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 97,097
That screenshot means File History is enabled, but Windows has decided the target volume Q: (“FileH+-Len”) is not a valid File History target, so it shows:
Below is the simplest, safest, GUI-only fix sequence.
1) Turn File History off
3) Select the drive again
If it works, great.
If it still says “doesn’t recognize this drive / unknown error,” do B.
1) On the Q: partition, open File Explorer → This PC → open Q:
2) If you see a folder named FileHistory on Q:, delete it.
Two very practical options:
1) Turn File History off first
2) Close File Explorer windows
3) Then try Safely Remove
- “File History doesn’t recognize this drive”
- “Unknown error”
Below is the simplest, safest, GUI-only fix sequence.
A) Reset File History (no formatting)
Do this on the PC where you’re seeing the message.1) Turn File History off
- Control Panel → System and Security → File History
- Click Turn off
3) Select the drive again
- Back in File History, click Select drive
- Pick the partition you want (by Volume Label, not letter)
- Click OK
If it works, great.
If it still says “doesn’t recognize this drive / unknown error,” do B.
B) Remove old File History data on that partition (still no formatting)
This fixes the common “unknown error” loop.1) On the Q: partition, open File Explorer → This PC → open Q:
2) If you see a folder named FileHistory on Q:, delete it.
- If you don’t see it: File Explorer → View → Show → turn on Hidden items, then look again.
3) Go back to Control Panel → File History: - Select drive again
- Turn on
- Run now
Q:\FileHistory, you’re done.C) If it STILL won’t recognize Q: (most likely cause)
At that point, File History is usually rejecting the drive because Windows is treating the device/connection as unreliable (even if you can copy files manually).Two very practical options:
Option C1 (recommended): dedicate one partition to File History and reformat just that partition
If Q: doesn’t have much you care about yet:- Disk Management → right‑click Q: → Format… → NTFS (Default allocation unit) → Quick format
Option C2: choose a different partition (or a different external) for File History
Sometimes File History will accept one NTFS partition on the same disk but not another (it’s picky about whatever it thinks it saw earlier).Also: why your “Safely remove… device is in use” keeps happening
If File History is ON, Windows can keep the disk “in use” constantly. When you want to unplug the Samsung:1) Turn File History off first
2) Close File Explorer windows
3) Then try Safely Remove
Quick question (so I give the correct “next step”)
Do you currently have any important data already stored on Q: that you don’t want to lose? (Yes/No)- If No, the fastest reliable fix is format just Q: as NTFS and reselect it in File History.
- If Yes, we’ll do only the non-destructive reset steps (A + B) and then I’ll have you check one specific setting.
Similar threads
- Solved
- Replies
- 8
- Views
- 7K