SteamOS Outperforms Windows 11 in Handheld Gaming: The Future of Portable PCs

Handheld gaming PCs have seen a renaissance in recent years, with devices like the Lenovo Legion Go and Asus ROG Ally capturing the imagination of gamers craving portability without sacrificing power. Yet, as this new form factor matures, an uncomfortable truth is emerging: Microsoft’s Windows 11—the operating system that comes pre-installed on the majority of these devices—may actually be holding the ecosystem back. According to exhaustive benchmarks and reports, SteamOS, Valve’s Linux-based competitor, is outperforming Windows 11 in critical areas, compelling many enthusiasts to reconsider what should power their gaming handhelds.

The Benchmark Battle: Windows 11 vs. SteamOS on Handhelds​

A clear and striking example comes from a series of recent benchmarks conducted by respected tech YouTuber Dave2D, comparing the Lenovo Legion Go S running Windows 11 with the same hardware outfitted solely with SteamOS. In this controlled comparison, the only variable was the operating system; everything else—CPU, GPU, memory—remained unchanged. The results were as dramatic as they were illuminating.
Take, for example, the graphically intense "Cyberpunk 2077," where SteamOS delivered a performance uplift of up to 25% compared to Windows 11. The Witcher 3 also saw a notable boost, running at 76 frames per second (fps) under SteamOS compared to just 66fps on Windows 11. Other titles demonstrated similarly robust improvements, with only a few exceptions—like Marvel’s Spider-Man 2, where Windows 11 achieved a negligible 1fps advantage (63fps on SteamOS versus 64fps on Windows).
Significantly, these gains aren’t limited to arcade shooters or niche indie games. The tested titles represent demanding, AAA-class experiences, underscoring the robust game compatibility and performance tuning found in SteamOS. And while individual results will vary based on game optimization and updates, this direct head-to-head speaks volumes about the real-world experience for handheld users.

Understanding the Underlying Reasons​

Why does SteamOS, built on Linux, outperform Windows 11—a platform traditionally regarded as the home of PC gaming? Several critical factors are at play:

1. Streamlined User Experience​

SteamOS is purpose-built for gaming. It launches directly into the Steam Big Picture/Deck UI, bypassing the complexities of desktop environments and the resource-hogging processes present in Windows 11. On a desktop PC, these background processes—ranging from update checkers to background telemetry apps—might be negligible. But on a mobile device with tighter hardware constraints and a premium on battery life, they can stifle both performance and responsiveness.

2. Lighter Operating System Footprint​

Windows 11 is an impressively capable OS, but its design caters to a wide array of use cases—office productivity, content creation, security, and, only incidentally, handheld gaming. That breadth comes at the cost of bloat: unnecessary background tasks, pre-installed apps, and a focus on multitasking that gaming handhelds don’t require. SteamOS, meanwhile, is stripped down—focused on getting the most out of hardware for gaming, and little else.

3. Superior Integration with Gaming Hardware​

Valve has spent years optimizing SteamOS for the unique requirements of small form factor gaming. Features like seamless controller mapping, native support for variable refresh rate displays, and a consistent, legible UI on small screens are all present out of the box—whereas Windows requires extensive manual configuration (and, often, third-party tools) to replicate a similar experience.

4. Native Support for Proton and Game Compatibility Layer​

One of SteamOS’s secret weapons is Proton, the compatibility layer that allows Windows games to run on Linux. Over the years, Proton has matured remarkably, with thousands of titles now functioning flawlessly. While there are still edge cases—especially with anti-cheat software or niche mods—Valve’s focused development has alleviated many early concerns regarding compatibility and stability.

The User Experience: Handheld Pain Points with Windows 11​

Gamers who’ve lived with Windows 11 on handheld devices frequently cite several glaring pain points:

• Awkward UI Scaling: Windows 11 treats handheld gaming PCs as ultra-small laptops, resulting in too-small icons, menus, and poorly optimized touch controls.
• Input Inconsistencies: Many games and apps expect keyboard-and-mouse input, requiring users to toggle between virtual keyboards or connect external peripherals for even basic tasks.
• Inefficient Boot-Up Process: Compared to the almost-instantaneous resume of the Steam Deck or devices running SteamOS, Windows 11’s startup and resume times feel sluggish, compounded by update prompts and system checks.
• Battery Drain: Background processes and unnecessary services eat into battery life, which is at a premium on any portable device.
• Bloatware: Pre-installed apps and services, which might be useful on a desktop or 2-in-1, clutter the experience for handheld gamers.

Comparative Table: SteamOS vs. Windows 11 on Handhelds​

Feature	SteamOS	Windows 11
Boot Time	Fast, straight to gaming UI	Slower, desktop first
Controller Integration	Seamless, out of box	Requires tweaks
Battery Drain	Minimal, gaming-focused	Higher, many background tasks
Game Compatibility	Nearly all Steam games via Proton, except some anti-cheat protected titles	Universal, but with bloat
Modding Simplicity	More complex, varies by game	Easiest, Windows standard
Discord/Game Overlay	Needs workaround (e.g. Vesktop)	Natively supported

The Case for Switching: Growing Community Sentiment​

This performance gap isn’t an isolated case. Echoing Dave2D’s findings, a broad swath of the enthusiast community is voicing similar experiences. Bazzite, a SteamOS “clone” or fork, has emerged as a popular alternative for those willing to tinker, and the move away from Windows is gaining steam (pun intended). Enthusiasts report not just higher frame rates, but a smoother, more consistent experience—one that feels purpose-built for gaming rather than retrofitted.
Even outside handheld gaming, some traditional desktop PC gamers are taking notice. Benchmarks from other sources, such as YouTuber EliteBossSlayer, demonstrate that in titles like Final Fantasy 7, SteamOS’s performance edge isn’t limited to battery-powered portables; it’s making inroads on full-fat gaming desktops as well.

Notable Strengths of SteamOS for Gaming PCs​

Among the clear advantages that SteamOS offers are:

• Optimized Resource Management: Every watt and core is prioritized for gaming, extending both performance and battery life.
• Seamless Interface: The UI is designed for controller and touch input, which translates to less fiddling and a more console-like experience.
• Frequent, Focused Updates: Valve has demonstrated a commitment to rapid, gaming-centric updates, often rolling out fixes and optimizations faster than Microsoft.
• Vibrant Community Support: An active group of developers and tinkerers are constantly extending functionality, porting new games, and building workarounds for stubborn apps or compatibility issues.

The Risks and Limitations: Why Not Everyone Has Switched​

Despite SteamOS’s advantages, the migration isn’t frictionless, and several hurdles keep Windows 11 relevant—at least for now.

1. Game Mods and Anti-Cheat Roadblocks​

Many PC gamers see game modding as an essential part of the hobby, and here, Windows 11 enjoys a clear advantage. Modding tools and utilities almost universally target Windows environments, and while many work on SteamOS/Proton, not all do—especially those requiring deep file system access or Windows-specific dependencies.
Similarly, certain high-profile multiplayer games employ anti-cheat systems that are incompatible with Linux-based operating systems. This limitation alone can force dual-boot setups or push users to stick with Windows for specific titles.

2. App and Overlay Compatibility​

Social tools like Discord are central to the modern multiplayer experience. While custom solutions like Vesktop and other wrappers exist for Linux, they lag behind the seamless, native support found in Windows. Frequent Discord updates can break these workarounds, requiring constant tinkering and reducing reliability. This is a non-starter for streamers or gamers who frequently share gameplay with friends.

3. Simplicity vs. Tinkering​

PCs, by their nature, are customizable. But not every gamer wants to become a part-time system administrator. While SteamOS is getting easier to install and configure, there’s still a steeper learning curve than simply sticking with the out-of-box Windows experience. Tasks like managing storage partitions or troubleshooting driver issues remain more involved.

4. Exclusivity and Software Ecosystem​

Windows 11 is, by design, the default for most commercial software—including proprietary launchers, productivity apps, and specialized tools. While this matters less for a dedicated gaming handheld, it can tip the scales for those looking for a multi-role device.

Critical Analysis: Is Windows 11 Truly a Detriment, or Just Not Optimized Yet?​

The claim that “Windows 11 is a detriment to handheld gaming PCs” isn’t hyperbolic—it’s supported by hard numbers, user reports, and technical analysis. Yet, it’s important to recognize the broader context. Microsoft has historically optimized Windows for desktops and laptops—not the niche but growing subset of handheld gaming PCs. Much of the poor experience results from this misalignment: UI elements, power management, and software priorities don’t reflect the needs of portable gaming.
SteamOS represents what the experience could be, and as the genre of handheld PCs matures, user demand is pushing both Microsoft and the hardware OEMs in that direction. There’s already evidence that the conversation is shifting; Microsoft insiders have hinted at greater interest in “gaming mode” features, and the company is likely acutely aware of the narrative Storm brewing around SteamOS.
It’s equally true, however, that Microsoft holds trump cards: universal game compatibility, the broadest support for mods, and easy access to apps like Discord, OBS, and more. For users who play a variety of online games or stream to friends, the friction of switching—at least for now—remains appreciable.

What Could Change? The Path Forward for Windows 11 and Handhelds​

For Windows 11 to stay relevant (or even dominant) in the handheld space, significant changes must be made:

• Introduction of a Portable Mode: Microsoft could develop a streamlined UI, stripped of unnecessary components, optimized for touch and controller input.
• Background Process Management: Reducing or throttling non-essential background activities when in “gaming mode” could recapture lost performance and battery life.
• Hardware-driven Optimizations: Collaborations with AMD, Intel, and device makers could deliver tailored drivers, power management tweaks, and seamless controller mapping.
• One-click Game Mode Hot-swaps: Building easy ways for users to boot into a “pure gaming” environment (mirroring SteamOS’s approach) would narrow the experience gap.
• Support for Proton-Like Compatibility: While this seems unlikely, taking lessons from Proton’s success—improving compatibility layers, containerization, and easy sandboxing of games and mods—could improve cross-platform play.

Should You Switch? A Practical Checklist​

For gamers contemplating a switch—or perhaps considering dual-booting their handheld—here’s a quick checklist weighing strengths and limitations:

• Best for Steam Library Players: If your primary library lives in Steam, and you mostly play single-player or Linux-compatible multiplayer titles, SteamOS offers a smoother, more efficient experience.
• Must-have Mods or Specific Apps? Stick with Windows if modding is central to your hobby or you require certain apps and overlays (e.g., Discord, OBS, Xbox Game Pass) that aren’t fully supported on Linux.
• Happy to Tinker? Enthusiasts who enjoy tweaking and troubleshooting will find SteamOS richly rewarding and supported by a vibrant community.
• Craving Simplicity? If you want a “just works” system for non-Steam games, emulation, and third-party platforms, Windows remains the safer (if less optimized) bet.

Conclusion: The Future of Handheld Gaming PCs Is at a Crossroads​

There is no denying that the story of handheld gaming PCs is closely tied to their operating systems. While hardware innovation from AMD and others is pushing boundaries, it is the software layer that determines whether that power translates into portable gaming bliss or frustration. SteamOS, with its focused, light, and gamer-first approach, is making a compelling case—so much so that Windows 11 now appears to be a legacy choice, rather than the future.
Pressure is mounting on Microsoft to make Windows 11 not just work on handhelds, but excel. Until that day arrives, expect to see more users dual-booting, more OEMs experimenting with Linux alternatives, and a continual drumbeat of benchmarks highlighting the gulf between a generalized PC OS and a purpose-built gaming platform. For users, these developments are all positive—competition breeds innovation, and the days of “good enough” may finally be behind us.
As always with PC gaming, the answer is not one-size-fits-all. But at this pivotal juncture, one truth is clear: SteamOS has broken the myth of Windows as an unassailable gaming platform—especially for those who value performance, battery life, and a frictionless handheld gaming experience. The ball, as they say, is now in Microsoft’s court.

---

Source: TechRadar Microsoft's Windows 11 is a detriment to handheld gaming PCs – and a recent SteamOS comparison highlights that

 

[ChatGPT]

In a market once dominated by the monolithic presence of Microsoft Windows, the boom of handheld gaming PCs has triggered a technological and cultural shift that few anticipated just a few years ago. The Lenovo Legion Go S, one of the latest challengers to Valve’s Steam Deck, now finds itself at the center of a dramatic performance debate: is SteamOS fundamentally faster—and simply a better fit—than Microsoft’s Windows 11 on gaming handhelds? Recent benchmarks and hands-on reports strongly suggest that the answer is yes, serving as a wake-up call for both gamers and industry giants alike.

Lenovo Legion Go S: The Contender Steps Onto the Scene​

The Lenovo Legion Go S arrives amid rapidly expanding interest in “portable PC gaming,” an industry previously invigorated by devices like the Valve Steam Deck and the Asus ROG Ally. Sporting an AMD Ryzen Z2 Go APU, the Legion Go S targets a segment hungry for mobility, performance, and console-like simplicity. Unlike more traditional laptops, these devices are built for a specific, demanding audience—PC enthusiasts who want uncompromised access to their entire game libraries on the go.
Of particular note for this latest round of reviews is that Lenovo offers configurations of the Legion Go S running either Windows 11 or Valve’s Linux-driven SteamOS. This dual-platform approach sets the stage for what may become one of 2025’s most critical gaming technology comparisons.

Head-to-Head Benchmarking: SteamOS vs. Windows 11​

Tech reviewer Dave2D, known for his measured and methodical approach, recently conducted a series of head-to-head tests using identical Lenovo Legion Go S units, one running SteamOS and the other Windows 11. His findings rapidly gained traction, not just because they contradicted years of established wisdom, but because they did so decisively.
In games like Cyberpunk 2077, the SteamOS-powered Legion Go S delivered an average of 59 frames per second, compared to just 46fps on the Windows 11 device. This nearly 30% performance gain is no minor footnote—it’s an astonishing difference, especially considering both systems were using the same hardware, tuned with comparative graphics and power profiles. This narrative continued across four more high-profile games (Helldivers 2, Doom Eternal, Spider-Man 2, and The Witcher 3), with SteamOS delivering frame rates 9–11fps higher on average than Windows 11.
These findings assure portable gamers that any perceived barriers around using a Linux-based handheld are quickly eroding, and nowhere more so than with SteamOS on AMD’s latest silicon. For the first time in years, Linux is not only a viable gaming platform, but—in this form factor—possibly the superior one.

Understanding the Performance Gap: Reduced Overheads and the Power of Proton​

Dave2D and others point to two central reasons for SteamOS’s dominance: “reduced overheads” on the Linux-based system, and growing sophistication in Valve’s Proton compatibility layer.

Reduced OS Overheads​

Windows 11, while powerful as a general-purpose operating system, comes with system services, background processes, and a graphical stack optimized for desktop PCs, not purpose-built gaming hardware. Each of these background tasks consumes crucial CPU cycles and memory, chipping away at the total performance budget—a problem magnified on mobile devices constrained by power, cooling, and battery life.
Meanwhile, SteamOS is designed from the ground up to serve as a dedicated gaming interface. Its cut-down, highly optimized Linux environment minimizes resource overhead. SteamOS’s underlying kernel is stripped of unnecessary services, while its graphical stack is tuned for fast context switches and low-latency rendering. These changes translate directly into more consistent frame rates and visibly smoother gameplay, especially in demanding AAA titles.

The Maturation of Proton​

The Proton compatibility layer, Valve’s fork of the Wine project, enables SteamOS to run native Windows games on Linux almost transparently to the user. Since the introduction of the Steam Deck, Valve’s investment in Proton has accelerated rapidly. Newer versions consistently improve performance, graphics compatibility (DX11, DX12, and even some Vulkan support), and game stability. Where Proton once lagged behind Windows in compatibility and efficiency, it now often matches—and, in some cases, surpasses—native Windows implementations for a broad swath of the Steam library.
Reports from both Valve and independent testers now confirm that significant numbers of top Steam releases (including many anti-cheat–protected multiplayer titles) run identically or better on Proton than on Windows.

The Linux Gaming Revolution: Not Just Hype​

To longtime Windows devotees, the notion of “Linux for gaming” may recall a long list of caveats: spotty driver support, limited game compatibility, or manual tweaking. But SteamOS’s impact—bolstered by the powerful Proton layer—should dispel most lingering doubts.
In practice, devices like the Legion Go S and Steam Deck running SteamOS benefit from multiple tangible advantages:

• Faster Boot Times: Streamlined OS kernels with fewer background services enable handhelds to suspend, resume, and cold boot in a fraction of the time required by Windows 11.
• Improved Battery Life: With lower system overhead, more energy is reserved for gaming workloads, translating to fewer dropped frames and longer sessions between charges.
• Consistent Game Performance: Anecdotal and benchmark evidence shows both higher average frame rates and reduced frame time variance, leading to smoother gameplay.
• Minimal Input Lag: SteamOS’s bare-bones windowing system and focused design reduce input latency—a crucial difference in fast-paced genres.

Moreover, the open-source nature of SteamOS empowers enthusiast users. Advanced tinkerers and communities are already developing kernels, drivers, and overlays specific to new hardware like the Legion Go S and ROG Ally, further driving the pace of improvement.

Challenges for Windows: Why Is Microsoft Falling Behind?​

Despite decades of technical dominance and developer goodwill, Windows 11 is on its back foot in the highly competitive handheld gaming market. Several core challenges contribute to this vulnerability.

1. Legacy Baggage​

Windows 11, built upon the foundation of prior releases, carries over layers of compatibility shims, scheduler complexity, and non-gaming system services. While this ensures robust application compatibility in traditional environments, it becomes a burden on tightly constrained mobile hardware. Even when running in a so-called “game mode,” Windows cannot entirely shed its desktop DNA.

2. Suboptimal Drivers and Power Management​

Many Windows drivers and graphics stacks are optimized for desktop or laptop use, often prioritizing feature-richness or stability at the cost of power efficiency. By contrast, Linux drivers (especially when bundled with SteamOS) are custom-tuned for the handheld hardware they ship on, providing leaner power states, aggressive thermal management, and lower idle consumption.

3. Lack of a Handheld-Centric UI​

Where SteamOS offers a “big picture” interface built from the ground up for handheld control schemes, Windows 11’s UI can feel unwieldy and unintuitive for users forced to navigate touchscreens with virtual keyboards or analog sticks. Microsoft has thus far failed to deliver a compelling, cohesive gaming interface for handhelds, putting Windows users at a constant ergonomic disadvantage.

4. Fragmented Ecosystem​

The Windows handheld ecosystem is fractured. Many devices ship with incomplete or inconsistent driver support, requiring users to cobble together firmware updates, third-party overlays, or configuration hacks to achieve the “console-like” experience that SteamOS delivers out of the box.

The Implications: Swinging Momentum and the Future of Handheld Gaming​

With SteamOS now officially available for more third-party handheld devices—even those initially shipping with Windows, such as the Asus ROG Ally—portable gaming is at a true inflection point. Valve’s push to make SteamOS more “universal” means that players and OEMs no longer need to settle for the lesser experience. For many, Windows’ main selling points (broader game compatibility, validated drivers, familiarity) are evaporating as SteamOS and Proton overcome previous barriers.

Is Linux Gaming a Real Threat to Windows?​

Not long ago, the idea of Linux mounting a credible attack on Windows’ 95% market dominance in PC gaming would have seemed far-fetched. Yet, as more devices like the Legion Go S demonstrate marked performance gains simply by virtue of operating system choice, it’s clear that Microsoft can no longer take gamer loyalty for granted.
Handheld PC gaming is projected to grow quickly, with analysts at multiple firms pointing to year-over-year increases in hardware shipments and renewed interest from the traditionally console-only consumer segment. The “plug-and-play” simplicity that SteamOS delivers is a major part of this growth, and the message is resonating: gamers want devices that just work, without hours of driver updates or obscure BIOS tweaks.

What Does This Mean for OEMs?​

For hardware partners like Lenovo, Asus, and others, the new calculus is clear—SteamOS is both viable and desirable, and the marketplace will reward those who embrace it early. By offering users a choice of operating system (with SteamOS rapidly becoming the “higher performance” option), OEMs can differentiate their devices and ride the coattails of Valve’s software and compatibility investment.
For Microsoft, the stakes could not be higher. Unless it delivers a radically improved Windows experience for handhelds—including reduced bloat, a touch- and stick-friendly UI overhaul, and energy-efficient drivers—its presence on gaming handhelds could dwindle to near-irreversible lows.

The Rumored Xbox Handheld: Microsoft’s Last Stand?​

Reports suggest that Microsoft may respond with its own handheld, possibly in partnership with Asus. Details are scarce, but any potential “Xbox handheld” will need to overcome the same hurdles of Windows overhead, interface adaptation, and consistent performance. Absent breakthrough innovation or a pared-down version of Windows specifically designed for portable gaming, even a Microsoft-first handheld may find itself lagging behind the competition.

Risks and Limitations: The SteamOS Hype and Cautionary Notes​

While the momentum behind SteamOS feels unstoppable right now, it is essential to note potential risks, limitations, and uncertainties.

1. Game and Driver Compatibility Edge Cases​

Despite Proton’s maturity, there remain notable edge cases. Some games with complex anti-cheat mechanisms or custom launchers may be unplayable or require community workarounds under Linux. For gamers who rely on non-Steam titles or peripherals with Windows-only drivers, Windows remains a safer—if less performant—bet. This is slowly changing, but the process is not yet complete.

2. Commercial Support and Warranty Concerns​

With the international nature of SteamOS community development, firmware and driver support may lag official Windows releases. Device warranties could potentially be voided if users flash or overwrite the factory Windows install with a third-party OS, depending on OEM policy. Buyers should proceed with caution and check vendor policies before making irreversible changes.

3. Development and Update Cadence​

Valve’s commitment to SteamOS and Proton is robust, but as with any open-source project, the broader update and security posture may not be as rapid or predictable as Windows. For users in tightly regulated or business environments, this could be a factor—although it is less of a concern for the hobbyist gaming crowd.

Critical Analysis: SteamOS’s Strengths and Where Windows Must Adapt​

The takeaway is clear: for handheld gaming right now, SteamOS offers a combination of performance, battery life, and user interface intuitiveness that Windows has not yet matched. Its reduced system overhead, fast-resuming experience, and superior frame rates on identical hardware make it the current operating system of choice for both enthusiast and casual handheld gamers.
But this competitive edge is fueled by a unique convergence of factors—a community pushing open standards, hardware vendors hungry for differentiation, and a major player (Valve) willing to champion an alternative approach to PC gaming. Should Microsoft marshal the resources and strategic focus necessary to reimagine Windows for handhelds, it may yet reclaim relevance in this slice of the market. But that window is closing, and quickly.

What Happens Next: A Cautiously Optimistic Future for Handheld Gaming​

In the immediate term, Linux-powered devices like the Legion Go S and Steam Deck will continue to set performance and usability bars—and consumer expectations—for the segment. For gamers, the future has never seemed brighter. Competition is driving better devices, faster updates, and more player freedom than ever before.
For Microsoft, this is a warning and an opportunity: iterate or become obsolete. If the company cannot deliver a serious, handheld-specific response within the next few cycles, it risks surrendering one of the last untapped PC frontiers to Valve and the broader Linux/open-source ecosystem.
As for the average gamer? The days of slow, under-optimized handheld gaming are fading fast. For those willing to explore outside the default Windows ecosystem, the combination of SteamOS and Proton is already redefining what portable PC gaming can achieve—delivering a future where the best handheld titles play just as smoothly, and sometimes better, than they do on the desktop. And that’s a win for everyone.

---

Source: PCGamesN This Steam Deck rival proves that SteamOS is much faster than Windows for gaming