• Thread Author
Windows 11 stands at a crossroads for millions of PC users, representing both the future of Microsoft’s desktop operating systems and a significant departure from the company’s long-standing ethos of broad hardware compatibility. Now, with Windows 10’s end of support just around the corner and Windows 11 having matured across four years of aggressive upgrades and user feedback, it’s more crucial than ever to understand exactly what the new OS delivers—and whether it’s truly time to make the leap.

A computer desk setup with a large monitor displaying a digital background, connected devices, and a keyboard.The Evolution of Windows: From Familiarity to Transformation​

Released in October 2021, Windows 11 initially appeared as an incremental step up from Windows 10. Much of its foundational architecture remains unchanged, sharing core system code with its predecessor. This has enabled a degree of stability and backward compatibility that long-time Windows users expect, but Microsoft’s decision also marked a reorientation toward security and modernization that left countless older devices behind.
Perhaps the beta users and industry observers were justified in their early skepticism: the interface was more polished, the Start menu and taskbar were revamped, and some new features like the Widgets pane appeared, but fundamentally it felt like a Windows 10 with a fresh coat of paint. Where the real transformation occurred was under the hood, in a stringent new set of hardware requirements.
In contrast to the “run anywhere” philosophy that made previous Windows versions ubiquitous, Windows 11 puts hardware compatibility front and center. Machine owners, especially those with devices from before 2019, suddenly faced the reality that they might be locked out of official upgrades altogether.

Critical Features and the New User Experience​

Switching to Windows 11 means embracing a comprehensively redesigned user experience. Here’s what stands out:

The Start Menu and Taskbar​

  • The Start menu is simpler, focusing on pinned apps and recent documents, without the live tiles and deep customization layers of Windows 10.
  • By default, the taskbar and Start button are centered but can be aligned to the left for a more traditional look.
  • Users lose the freedom to move the taskbar to other screen edges, and the Start menu itself remains unresizable. Contextual features like right-clicking the taskbar for Task Manager have returned after initial outcry, but not all customization quirks of prior versions are supported.

File Explorer and Settings​

  • File Explorer gets a visual revamp, new icons, and the increasingly popular use of tabs for file management.
  • The Settings app has been reengineered for clarity, with side-by-side navigation, improved search, and visual hierarchies that make discovering features and tweaking system preferences significantly easier.
  • Notably, battery monitoring and recent document views in File Explorer go beyond what Windows 10 offered.

Widgets and Quick Settings​

  • Widgets deliver bite-sized information—weather, news, reminders—though early criticism around limited third-party options and “clickbait” news persists.
  • The Quick Settings panel replaces the old Action Center, allowing users to scroll through more settings buttons for faster access to key functions.

Improved Snap Layouts​

  • Windows 11 offers more flexible options for snapping and arranging windows, making multitasking on larger or multi-monitor setups much smoother. These are accessible via keyboard shortcuts or by hovering over a window’s maximize icon.

Legacy Elements Remain​

Despite these improvements, “older” elements of the legacy Control Panel and Microsoft Management Console still surface for advanced settings, serving as a reminder of Windows’ long lineage and ongoing transition.

Under the Hood: Security and Compatibility​

Arguably the most important pillar for Windows 11 is security—a major factor in the strict hardware requirements.

Hardware-Assisted Security​

  • Secure Boot and TPM 2.0 (Trusted Platform Module) are mandatory for all supported installations. These were optional in Windows 10, but are now default-on protections against a rising tide of firmware and ransomware attacks.
  • UEFI (Unified Extensible Firmware Interface) replaces legacy BIOS entirely, meaning older systems using Master Boot Record (MBR) partitioning or with disabled TPM are left behind.
  • Device encryption, previously a niche feature, is increasingly widespread.

App Compatibility​

While most software that runs on Windows 10 continues to work unchanged on Windows 11, certain caveats apply:
  • On x86 hardware (Intel/AMD), compatibility is essentially seamless.
  • On ARM-based Copilot+ PCs with Qualcomm Snapdragon chips, most Windows apps run via emulation—often with little performance penalty for everyday software, but at-risk are applications requiring custom device drivers or low-level system access.
  • Ten-day rollback functionality: If a user discovers an incompatible device or app after upgrading, they have a 10-day window to revert to Windows 10, after which a clean install would be necessary.

Microsoft Account Requirement​

Unlike its predecessors, Windows 11 Home forces users to set up with a Microsoft account and an internet connection during out-of-box setup. Workarounds exist, but they are not officially supported and may become less accessible over time. Using a Microsoft account unlocks cloud-enabled features like automatic recovery key backup, device location, and synchronization.

Minimum System Requirements​

Microsoft’s official minimums are as follows:
  • CPU: 1GHz+, two or more cores, 64-bit or SoC
  • RAM: 4GB minimum
  • Storage: 64GB or more
  • Security: TPM 2.0, UEFI with Secure Boot
  • Graphics: DirectX 12 compatible with WDDM 2.0 driver
  • Display: HD (720p), at least 9" diagonal, 8 bits per color channel
Most PCs from 2019 onward comply, but almost all pre-2018 hardware—especially budget models with Intel 7th Gen or AMD Zen 1 CPUs—are ineligible. The PC Health Check app can confirm compatibility and flag hardware-specific obstacles.

Installation: Paths and Workarounds​

Free Upgrade for Windows 10 Users​

If you own a licensed copy of Windows 10, Windows 11 is a free upgrade. For new custom PC builds or VMs, users need to supply a valid license key, obtainable at retail or via volume licensing.

Bypassing Hardware Checks​

Two main unsupported workarounds allow installation on incompatible hardware:
  • Registry hack for older CPUs (still requires TPM)
  • Using Rufus (an open-source tool) to erase compatibility checks entirely (works on even older hardware)
Microsoft warns: Such systems “are not supported and won’t be entitled to receive updates.” Yet, in practice, most older PCs upgraded in this manner continue to receive updates as of the most recent release. This could theoretically change in future, but Microsoft has not enforced a block so far.

Extended Security Updates for Windows 10​

Windows 10 reaches official end of support on October 14, 2025. After that, security and quality updates will only be available to those purchasing extended security updates (a costly prospect for business users) or for a single-year free extension for individuals.

Application Ecosystem and Store Revamp​

Microsoft’s overhaul of the Microsoft Store sought to remedy years of user frustration over a thin, unreliable app selection. Under Windows 11, the Store finally permits classic Win32 desktop apps, opening the gates to a trove of trusted desktop programs.
For developers and advanced users, Winget (the Windows Package Manager) allows command-line-based app installation—much like on Linux—eliminating endless web searches and download portals.

Dropping Android Subsystem​

One caveat: Windows 11 launched with a Subsystem for Android, briefly enabling Android app support. Microsoft discontinued this feature in 2024, citing low usage and platform complexity.

AI and Windows Copilot​

In a bid to stay ahead in the AI arms race, Windows 11 introduced Copilot: an integrated, AI-powered assistant available in every edition. It responds to queries, launches actions, and even controls system settings.

The Copilot+ Era​

2024’s arrival of Copilot+ PCs, powered by Snapdragon X chips, further underscored Microsoft’s commitment to AI. These systems offer snappier Copilot experiences and specialized features for real-time productivity, but also reinforce the divide between new and legacy hardware.

Update Cadence and Support Lifecycle​

Windows 11’s update rhythm is simpler yet more flexible than Windows 10’s:
  • Major feature updates come once a year (H2—second half of each year), with new features often delivered outside of this cycle via the Store or Windows Update.
  • Monthly updates for security and quality continue, typically delivered on the second Tuesday (Patch Tuesday).
  • Home, Pro, and related editions now receive 24 months of support per release, while Enterprise/Education get 36 months—an increase over Windows 10’s 18-month window.
For IT admins and enthusiasts, the Windows Insider Program enables access to daily/weekly pre-release builds in four channels: Canary, Dev, Beta, and Release Preview. Moving from Insider builds to stable releases now generally requires a clean reinstall.

Installation Media and VM Support​

Official Windows 11 installation options include:
  • The Windows 11 Installation Assistant tool
  • Downloadable ISO disk images
  • USB creation tools
Virtual machines are fully supported, and a virtual TPM can be created easily within Hyper-V (available on Pro or Enterprise editions). Macs with Intel chips can run Windows 11 via various hypervisors, while Apple Silicon Macs require Parallels Desktop (and a Pro license) due to architectural differences.

What’s New for Touch, Pen, and Accessibility​

Windows 11 puts a renewed focus on touch and pen input, with smoother mode transitions, larger touch targets, and gestures that cater to tablets like Microsoft’s own Surface Pro line. Accessibility features benefit from natural voice typing, better magnifier tools, and enhanced display options for users with specific needs.

Advertising and Bloatware: How Intrusive Is It?​

Windows 11 does not serve third-party advertisements in the OS itself. However, users still see “recommendations” for installed apps and Microsoft services—Office 365, OneDrive, Xbox Game Pass—within the Start menu and notification banners. These cross-sell efforts are persistent and, by design, likely to grow in prominence, as they generate significant recurring revenue for Microsoft.

Adoption Rate: Slow and Steady, Hampered by Hardware​

Statistics are inherently murky, but industry tracking suggests Windows 11 now runs on 35%–45% of all Windows devices worldwide. The relatively slow growth is not apathy: most of the billion-plus PCs globally are simply ineligible due to hardware rules. As new devices enter the market, and as extended support ends for Windows 10, the balance will gradually tip.

Looking Ahead: No Windows 12 in Sight—Yet​

Rumors circulated that a new Windows (“Windows 12”) would arrive in late 2024, but Microsoft instead doubled down on Copilot+ and announced another major Windows 11 update (25H2). Insiders say a wholly new Windows revision is unlikely before 2026 or later; if precedent holds, the company may surprise the market with little advance warning when the time does come.

Strengths and Innovations​

Windows 11’s real triumphs lie in:
  • Mandating stronger, default-on security, making the OS more resilient against new kinds of threats.
  • Refining daily productivity features, from Snap Assist to updated multi-monitor support and advanced battery tracking.
  • Offering a faster, more modern Microsoft Store with a broader, safer app selection, enhanced further by command-line tools like Winget.
  • Streamlining the update process and extending the support lifecycle, yielding a more stable platform for both consumers and organizations.
  • Laying the groundwork for AI-powered experiences, both in the OS and through deep Copilot integration.

Criticisms and Risks​

Yet, Windows 11 is not without real drawbacks and controversy:
  • The hardware cutoff leaves countless perfectly serviceable, secure, and performant PCs without an official upgrade path, generating e-waste concerns and frustration in schools, small businesses, and developing markets.
  • Some power users lament loss of interface flexibility—especially limited taskbar customization, missing Start menu features, and the persistence of ads and cross-sell banners.
  • The enforcement of Microsoft account sign-in and online setup for Home users raises privacy and autonomy concerns, even as certain workarounds linger.
  • The discontinuation of the Android Subsystem eliminates a major differentiator and potential value-add for mobile-leaning users.
  • For businesses, the new Extended Security Update program is yet another costly annual outlay, while support for legacy systems is harder to justify than ever.

Real-World Performance and Adoption: The Verdict​

Anecdotal reports and limited independent benchmarks suggest that Windows 11 runs every bit as smoothly as Windows 10, sometimes surpassing it on modern hardware. Its strict hardware requirements are justified by its focus on security and future potential, but Microsoft risks alienating a sizable base of loyal users clinging to still-capable PCs.
Ultimately, for those whose devices meet the requirements, Windows 11 offers real—if sometimes subtle—advantages over Windows 10. The modernization of interface, rolling feature updates, and much-improved application ecosystem are compelling. For those left behind, the OS feels like a forced split, pushing new PC sales as the prime route to the future.

Upgrading: What to Consider Before Making the Switch​

As the shadow of Windows 10’s end of support looms, users should weigh these points:
  • Compatibility: Use the PC Health Check app to verify upgrade eligibility.
  • Rollback Window: Test all apps and devices thoroughly within the first 10 days post-upgrade.
  • Account Setups: Decide if you’re comfortable with a Microsoft account, or research available workarounds.
  • Update Policy: Weigh whether you’re willing to use an unsupported workaround for older hardware, with all associated risks.
  • Business Needs: IT admins should plan extended support or phased fleet upgrades; educational institutions and non-profits need to budget for hardware refreshes or Extended Security Updates accordingly.

Frequently Asked Questions: Quick Summary​

  • Is the upgrade free for Windows 10 users? Yes, for licensed installations.
  • Can I use my Windows 10 product key? Yes, product keys for Windows 10 and 11 are interchangeable.
  • Does it run on older hardware? Officially, most systems from 2019+; unofficially, workarounds exist but future support is not guaranteed.
  • Can I run Windows 11 in a VM? Yes, including on Macs (with some caveats for Apple Silicon).
  • Are there ads? Not from third-party vendors, but expect Microsoft to promote its own services persistently.

Conclusion: Navigating the Upgrade​

Windows 11, after four years of evolution, is no longer simply “Windows 10.5.” It is the definitive mainstream, secure desktop platform for the foreseeable future, prioritizing safety, usability, and readiness for AI-assisted workflows. But it asks for newer hardware and a bit less user autonomy in exchange.
For anyone planning next steps post-Windows 10, now is the time to assess compatibility, pilot the upgrade on non-essential systems, explore new workflows, and start preparing for a world where Windows 11 isn’t just the latest Windows—it’s, increasingly, the only Windows that matters. As always, careful, informed decision-making can maximize the benefits and minimize the disruptions of Microsoft’s biggest shift in years.

Source: ZDNet Your complete Windows 11 upgrade guide: Everything to know - before you ditch Windows 10
 

Back
Top