gjbnh

New Member
Joined
May 6, 2009
Messages
206
I was wondering what others have experinced with this. The first time I ran it under Win 7 7127, it found 78 System Optimisations, and 6350 Security Defense isuses;!! Even if half of them are false positievs, that is unbeleiveable! :eek:
 

Solution
gjbnh,

I really would not trust this program whatsoever.

I just ran the Pro version on my Windows 7 machine. I have 84 system optimazations found and 5228 Security Defense problems found.

These Security Defense is a total joke. It just lists the various types of malware that exist out in the wild. It's supposedly giving you protection from these. If you have a good anti-virus program, spyware detector and personal firewall, there is no need for this.Also, it detected a dll of mine as a porn pop up. This is absolutely false and if I was to remove it I would break the program and it would not start.

I'd go so far as to state if you fixed all these so-called problems Windows would not even boot.

I never belied in these...

reghakr

Essential Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2009
Messages
14,186
gjbnh,

I really would not trust this program whatsoever.

I just ran the Pro version on my Windows 7 machine. I have 84 system optimazations found and 5228 Security Defense problems found.

These Security Defense is a total joke. It just lists the various types of malware that exist out in the wild. It's supposedly giving you protection from these. If you have a good anti-virus program, spyware detector and personal firewall, there is no need for this.Also, it detected a dll of mine as a porn pop up. This is absolutely false and if I was to remove it I would break the program and it would not start.

I'd go so far as to state if you fixed all these so-called problems Windows would not even boot.

I never belied in these "optimization" programs either, especially when they want to modify Windows services. These services have changed in Windows 7 and this is an possible way to prevent the computer from booting.
 

Solution

gjbnh

New Member
Joined
May 6, 2009
Messages
206
I agree somewhat. Under Vista it seems to find some regisrty errors after they have been cleaned, after Vista has re-created them after rebooting. But given the shear number of reports Security Defense findings in Win 7, I think it is safe to say that at least some of them are legit. Even if 3/4's of them are false positives, it speaks volumes that MS STILL hasn't gotten the secuirty think right. So I will take it's findings with a grain of salt, but where there is SO MUCh smoke, there IS fire.
 

reghakr

Essential Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2009
Messages
14,186
gjbnh,

As I stated above the Security Defense findings are simply thousands of malware and spyware related entries that exist everywhere. It's not a list of problems on your computer.

Anyone that installs this program will get a huge number under that category.

As for
it speaks volumes that MS STILL hasn't gotten the security think right

Not true whatsoever. there are many security enhancements in Windows 7.
 

gjbnh

New Member
Joined
May 6, 2009
Messages
206
I will look into the security defense thing some more, and I agree with you on the secuirity improvements. The performance increases are awesome too. :) And I know this is still "beta".