Yeah, that is not really duplex printing. Thanks for clarifying. You are right, my HP mechanically turns the paper over to print on the other side. This is controlled by the printer itself. In your case, besides your manual paper manipulation, the printer "software" (
NOT to be confused with the printer "driver"), controls the timing based on your manual inputs.
My Canon PIXMA MP550 cannot use level 5 and 1... there are every time with any setting... "grayed" because it doesn't support them.
That might have to do with the paper type you have told the printer it has loaded. For example, for high-quality photo paper, it might let you print with the highest quality.
Still, none of that explains your problem.
Speaking of paper, I note some paper has different coatings on each side. Have you tried different types of paper?
In theory, you should be able to go total manual and get good results. That is, tell the printer to print just one page, then you reload that page back in the paper tray then start another print job for the second page/side. This would be a real PITA with a large documents, however.
Did I tell you I really like my HP?