HarmonyOS on Huawei Laptops: The Future of Chinese Operating Systems and Digital Sovereignty

Huawei’s dramatic shift in strategy, marked by the official debut of HarmonyOS as a desktop replacement for Microsoft Windows on its laptops, signals a profound transformation in the global operating system landscape. Once aligned closely with Western tech giants, Huawei now finds itself at the intersection of geopolitics, technology innovation, and domestic market momentum. Its response—an accelerated development and rollout of HarmonyOS—offers a fascinating case study in how global constraints can spawn indigenous innovation and redefine an entire digital ecosystem.

From Sanctions to Self-Reliance: The Forced Evolution of HarmonyOS​

The story begins with U.S. trade restrictions that severely limited Huawei’s access to American software and hardware, including the Microsoft Windows operating system. According to a report by Tom’s Hardware and corroborated by the South China Morning Post, Huawei’s license to use Windows expired in March last year, with no prospect of renewal under current international sanctions. This forced the Chinese tech behemoth’s hand, pushing it to accelerate its investment in HarmonyOS, an operating system whose roots date back to 2012 but which only began to see public deployment in 2019 with the launch of the Honor Vision smart TV.
By 2021, HarmonyOS had become commonplace on Huawei’s smartphones, transitioning older Android models to the new in-house platform as well. The progression from connected TVs to handsets was a logical one, but replacing Windows, entrenched for decades as the de facto desktop operating system, poses a far greater technological and cultural challenge. Huawei’s unveiling of a yet-to-be-named laptop running HarmonyOS 5—sometimes referred to as HarmonyOS Next—marks, for the first time, a direct challenge to Microsoft’s hold on the personal computing market, albeit initially in China.

Building a Cohesive Ecosystem: The Apple Model, With a Twist​

Huawei’s vision clearly borrows from the playbook of Apple, Inc., whose tightly integrated iOS, iPadOS, and macOS platforms have reigned supreme in offering users a seamless cross-device experience. HarmonyOS’s claim to fame is its ability to power an entire spectrum of consumer electronics: smart TVs, tablets, smartphones, wearables, and now, laptops. This unified approach means development and deployment of new features can, in theory, roll out across device types instantaneously, enhancing Huawei’s capacity for rapid ecosystem advancement.
Early indications suggest this strategy is resonating within China. HarmonyOS-powered smartphones have reportedly overtaken Apple’s iPhones in domestic market share, snagging a robust 19% compared to Apple’s 17% last quarter. Multiple industry analysts confirm this trend, emphasizing that the creation of a tightly integrated software ecosystem may further accelerate customers’ willingness to adopt HarmonyOS not only on their phones but also on laptops and, eventually, desktops.

HarmonyOS on Laptops: What We Know Today​

Despite the hype, publicly available technical details about the upcoming HarmonyOS-powered laptops remain scarce. Huawei has not disclosed specific CPU support, RAM capacities, or other core hardware specs. Historically, Huawei’s mobile computing lineup has relied predominantly on Intel and AMD processors. Theoretically, laptops equipped with such hardware should be capable of running other operating systems—including Windows, Linux, or dual-boot configurations—if not actively restricted by firmware or HarmonyOS itself.
Nonetheless, the company is clear about the core software proposition. Early demos and official statements confirm that the new HarmonyOS laptops will run a desktop environment designed from the ground up for this purpose, distinct from the mobile or tablet versions previously seen. Among the apps confirmed at launch are WPS Office—a robust, free alternative to Microsoft Office that is widely used and respected within China—and DingTalk, Alibaba’s popular enterprise collaboration suite. These apps, combined with the promise of native support for “thousands” of HarmonyOS mobile applications, could mitigate potential early adopter frustrations stemming from software availability issues.

Compatibility and App Ecosystem​

One of Windows’ enduring strengths is its immense compatibility with legacy software, peripherals, and development environments. HarmonyOS, in contrast, is still in the early stages of ecosystem maturity. However, Huawei is leveraging its deep integration across devices and existing dominance in China’s app development community to ensure that core productivity and communication apps are available from day one. This includes not only WPS Office and DingTalk, but also key banking, educational, and media apps that are mission-critical to Chinese users and enterprises.
Still, questions remain about the depth of app support for more specialized, professional software commonly found in fields like engineering, graphic design, scientific research, or advanced media production. Western software vendors—such as Adobe, Autodesk, and many others—do not currently offer native HarmonyOS versions of their programs, nor are they expected to do so in the short term due to ongoing international restrictions. This gap may limit the immediate appeal of HarmonyOS laptops for certain professional segments but is unlikely to be a dealbreaker for mainstream consumers or students.

Security, Privacy, and Independence: Core Selling Points​

Central to Huawei’s pitch is the promise of greater security, data privacy, and digital sovereignty. With U.S. sanctions framed in the context of national security concerns, Huawei has positioned HarmonyOS as an operating system free of foreign oversight. Chinese government agencies and state-owned enterprises have already signaled support for the use of domestic software platforms as a matter of policy, accelerating the move away from Western systems.
Independent security researchers are only just beginning to analyze HarmonyOS at the desktop level, and full reviews of its architecture, threat models, and privacy guarantees will undoubtedly continue to emerge over the coming months. Some early technical dives suggest that HarmonyOS is built on a microkernel architecture, enabling better isolation of core system services, which can enhance resistance to certain classes of exploits compared to traditional monolithic kernels like that of Windows or Linux.
However, there are caveats. Critics warn that transparency and code access remain concerns; HarmonyOS’s source code is not as freely auditable as that of mainstream Linux distributions. Additionally, for users outside China, issues of surveillance or government-mandated data access have long been a point of contention when it comes to Chinese software. These conflicting narratives—around Western and Chinese technology alike—underscore the increasingly geopolitical nature of operating system adoption.

Risks and Obstacles: The Hard Road Ahead​

While HarmonyOS’s rise highlights Huawei’s ability to swiftly marshal resources and talent, it also reveals a set of formidable challenges. The first is user inertia: Windows remains the default for enterprise productivity, gaming, and countless niche tasks. Even with a strong offering—and assuming no technical barriers to dual-booting or virtualization—many users will be reluctant to abandon familiar workflows, especially in global markets where local software compatibility matters less.
Second, the lack of internationally recognized software support will be a barrier for anyone whose work relies on specialized tools. This challenge is compounded by the possibility of ecosystem lock-in: as more device functionality becomes tied to unique HarmonyOS features—particularly those exploiting fast device-to-device communication and cross-platform synchronization—it may be increasingly difficult for users to later migrate to non-Huawei platforms.
Third, while HarmonyOS is primarily a domestic play for now, Huawei’s aspirations likely extend to international markets over time. Here, the company faces not only competitive resistance from Microsoft, Apple, and Google, but also ongoing regulatory and political scrutiny regarding privacy, security, and technology standards.

Opportunities and Strengths: The Case for HarmonyOS​

Despite the obstacles, Huawei is uniquely positioned to make the HarmonyOS transition work, at least in its home market:

• Device Breadth: Huawei’s hardware ranges from smartphones and wearables to laptops, tablets, TVs, and IoT devices, all of which can run HarmonyOS.
• Ecosystem-First Philosophy: By tightly linking app and account ecosystems, Huawei encourages brand loyalty and offers an integrated experience that could reduce platform churn.
• Government Backing: Policy support from Chinese authorities provides both top-down encouragement for businesses and long-term market protection, effectively guaranteeing early adoption rates.
• Developer Momentum: As more and more Chinese app developers pivot to HarmonyOS, the “app gap” relative to Google Play or Microsoft Store is expected to narrow, especially for everyday productivity, communication, media, and commerce.
• Increased Market Share: In overtaking Apple’s market share in China with HarmonyOS smartphones, Huawei has demonstrated its ability to rapidly convert existing user bases when ecosystem and pricing factors align.

Seamless Connectivity and Cross-Device Innovation​

Perhaps the most significant promise of HarmonyOS is its potential for frictionless interoperability. Early HarmonyOS devices, particularly in the smart home and mobile arenas, have already demonstrated “super device” functionality, allowing users to seamlessly transfer files, stream media, or execute tasks across screens with minimal setup. Extending this to the laptop form factor should, if executed well, make for an experience akin to Apple’s Handoff or AirDrop—but with deeper integration across even more device categories, including smart appliances, automotive systems, and smart city infrastructure.

The International View: Will HarmonyOS Succeed Outside China?​

At present, HarmonyOS’s prospects for significant penetration outside China remain limited. Western markets are likely to remain skeptical, both due to entrenched brand loyalty (particularly towards Windows and macOS) and lingering concerns about privacy, security, and political entanglements. Software compatibility with established international standards remains a sticking point; unless Huawei or third-party developers invest heavily in app porting or emulation, adoption outside China will continue to lag.
However, this does not preclude HarmonyOS from becoming a major force within the world’s most populous digital market. Given China’s sheer consumer base and top-down mandate for technological self-sufficiency, HarmonyOS could, within a few years, be powering hundreds of millions of laptops, tablets, and other smart devices—all without recourse to Western software infrastructure. In doing so, it would represent one of the first truly viable alternatives to the Windows-macOS duopoly in computing history, at least at scale.

Looking Ahead: The Future of HarmonyOS and Digital Sovereignty​

Huawei’s HarmonyOS campaign is more than a technical or commercial maneuver; it is emblematic of broader shifts in global technology supply chains and the rising importance of digital sovereignty. The move away from Western platforms isn’t purely a matter of politics or sanctions. It reflects a realignment in the relationship between governments, corporations, and consumers—a desire for control over core technology, protection of domestic industries, and assurance that local values and priorities are embedded in digital infrastructure.
If HarmonyOS’s desktop push succeeds, the reverberations will be felt not only in China but in other regions contemplating greater independence from global tech giants. Companies in Russia, India, and elsewhere are reportedly watching the HarmonyOS experiment closely, considering their own responses to platform risk and technological dependency.

Critical Takeaways​

• For Chinese consumers: HarmonyOS laptops represent a compelling, ecosystem-driven alternative to Windows-powered devices, especially for those prioritizing local language support, domestic app ecosystems, and integration with other Huawei hardware.
• For enterprises: The move signals an opportunity for reduced licensing fees, enhanced data sovereignty, and greater compliance with Chinese regulatory mandates—but at the cost of temporarily diminished access to established international productivity and creative software.
• For global tech watchers: HarmonyOS’s march onto laptops is a landmark event, with potential to reshape the operating system market—at least within “walled garden” markets—and accelerate broader trends toward digital self-reliance.

Conclusion​

HarmonyOS replacing Windows on Huawei laptops is not merely a workaround imposed by external constraints; it is a pivot towards long-term ecosystem control, customer integration, and digital independence. While significant hurdles remain—particularly around software compatibility, international trust, and cross-border standards—the foundations laid by HarmonyOS’s success in smartphones, coupled with aggressive ecosystem-first innovation, mean this is a watershed moment for China’s domestic tech industry. Whether HarmonyOS’s model of seamless device connectivity, data sovereignty, and ecosystem loyalty will extend beyond the world’s largest market remains to be seen—but its domestic impact is already profound, and its global implications impossible to ignore.

---

Source: Tom's Hardware HarmonyOS replacing Windows on Huawei laptops — delivers connectivity across the ecosystem

 

[ChatGPT]

Huawei's grand entrance into the consumer laptop operating system market has sparked vigorous debate and scrutiny across the global tech industry. With the official launch of HarmonyOS Next, Huawei directly sets its sights on Microsoft’s Windows 11, presenting a reimagined desktop user experience. Yet despite promises of innovation and a seamless "ecosystem" strategy reminiscent of Apple's tightly integrated approach, HarmonyOS Next’s initial release is not without calculated trade-offs and perhaps controversial limitations. In this detailed analysis, the strengths, ambitions, and caveats of Huawei's new operating system are carefully dissected.

Huawei’s Ecosystem Ambitions: Closing the Loop​

For years, Huawei has contended with the geopolitical and technical constraints imposed by Western sanctions, particularly those that cut ties with core US software, cloud, and hardware suppliers. This pressure led Huawei to accelerate its vertical integration, culminating in not just proprietary chipsets, networking equipment, and smartphones, but now a homegrown laptop OS. HarmonyOS Next is the capstone of this strategy, a platform aiming to give users a coherent experience across phones, tablets, PCs, and smart home devices.
By creating HarmonyOS Next exclusively for its modern laptops, Huawei signals intent to end reliance on Windows for its consumer computing business in China. The company touts faster performance, a flashy enhanced UI, and native AI-powered features as headline upgrades—factors designed to win over users being ushered into its walled ecosystem. The ambition is to foster device synergy and applications that travel seamlessly between form factors, mirroring in many respects the integrated magic that Apple has orchestrated across its hardware for more than a decade.

Fresh UI Design: Details and Influences​

Visually, HarmonyOS Next diverges noticeably from Windows 11’s familiar design language. Drawing cues from macOS, the OS introduces a “software shortcut bar” at the bottom of the screen, evoking the iconic macOS Dock. This decision is likely strategic; it appeals to users seeking a blend of both familiarity and a refreshing alternative to the traditional Windows Start Menu and Taskbar paradigm.

• Enhanced UI: Early screenshots and demonstrations reveal vividly colored icons, fluid animations, and a cohesive window management system. Consumers accustomed to Huawei’s HarmonyOS on phones and tablets will recognize a similar design vocabulary, crafting a sense of cross-platform consistency.
• App Gallery-Centric Approach: Central to the HarmonyOS Next user experience is the App Gallery, Huawei’s proprietary alternative to Microsoft Store or Apple’s Mac App Store. Every non-system application must be obtained through this portal, as the OS will not support sideloading of software—a policy discussed in more detail below.
• Native Applications: Out of the box, HarmonyOS Next includes a suite of native apps such as WPS Office, designed to ensure productivity workflows are covered without immediate third-party downloads.

Performance and AI: A Step Ahead?​

Huawei’s announcement places a particular emphasis on performance—an area where Windows has faced criticism, especially when dealing with bloatware or legacy compatibility code. HarmonyOS Next’s clean-slate development allows Huawei to jettison old dependencies, potentially leading to faster startup times, more responsive UI transitions, and better battery optimization on supported hardware.
One of the operating system’s crown jewels is its AI capabilities. The OS includes "Celia," an AI assistant that not only handles basic queries but is positioned as a more proactive AI agent capable of performing productivity tasks—such as generating presentations or managing reminders autonomously. By weaving AI into the core of the OS and its bundled apps, Huawei appears intent on future-proofing the user experience, aligning with industry-wide trends in generative and personalized computing.

The Benefit—and Risk—of a Clean Slate​

By crafting an OS from the ground up without shackles to legacy Windows software, Huawei can theoretically build a lighter, more secure, and adaptable platform. However, this decision also means the operating system will only be available on modern Huawei laptops. It will not be retrofitted or backported to older models, and—crucially—it will not feature backward compatibility with previous Huawei device generations.
This is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it sidesteps the technical debt and compatibility headaches that often slow down modern OSes (something which Windows has struggled with due to supporting decades-old software). On the other hand, it risks alienating loyal Huawei customers owning slightly older laptops, locking them out of the new experience and fragmenting the user base at launch.

App Sideloading Restrictions: A Double-Edged Sword​

The inability to sideload applications on HarmonyOS Next is one of the most contentious aspects of its debut. Unlike Windows, where "power users" have long enjoyed the freedom to install software from virtually any source, HarmonyOS Next will require all third-party apps to be obtained via Huawei’s App Gallery.
Why restrict sideloading?
There are several plausible motives behind this decision:

• Security and Stability: By restricting distribution to approved channels, Huawei can better vet software for malware and enforce quality standards.
• Governance: The Chinese tech giant’s strategy may also align with domestic regulatory goals, which favor tighter control over software ecosystems and less reliance on US or European apps.
• Economic Leverage: Controlling software distribution reduces dependence on Western app stores and services, insulating Huawei against further geopolitical disruptions.

User Impact:
While casual users may benefit from greater security, this restriction can be a deal-breaker for enthusiasts, developers, or businesses who depend on niche or custom solutions not available in the App Gallery. In effect, it shifts power from the user to the OS vendor—a move reminiscent of Apple's fiercely curated macOS and iOS approach, but starkly at odds with Windows' open ethos.
Moreover, Chinese consumers—HarmonyOS Next’s primary audience—may not mind this trade-off, as the App Gallery already dominates the app ecosystem on Huawei’s mobile devices in China due to the lack of Google Play. International users, however, could balk, especially in regions where open-source and indie applications thrive thanks to unfettered sideloading.

Backward Compatibility: New OS, New Hardware Only​

Perhaps the most jarring limitation for existing Huawei laptop owners is the absence of backward compatibility. HarmonyOS Next is explicitly confined to select, modern Huawei device models. If you purchased a Huawei laptop even a year or two prior to release, there will be no official support or upgrade path. This creates a natural break with the past, but also raises sustainability and customer-satisfaction concerns.
The OS’s exclusive focus on new models enables Huawei to fine-tune performance, minimize bugs, and streamline its technical support burden. However, it also risks sowing frustration among loyal customers, undermining the proposition of investing in the Huawei hardware ecosystem for the long term. Many consumers expect their relatively new devices to remain supported for at least a few years, particularly when it comes to major operating system updates.
For comparison, both Microsoft and Apple are generally more accommodating in this regard: Windows 11 runs on a wide variety of older hardware (within limits), while macOS is known for supporting machine generations up to five years old or more.

Feature Deep-Dive: What Sets HarmonyOS Next Apart?​

Despite these controversial choices, HarmonyOS Next introduces several technical and user-facing strengths worth highlighting.

AI-Centric Workflow and Automation​

Central to the OS is Huawei’s AI assistant Celia, now evolved from a simple voice assistant on mobile to an integral part of the laptop experience. Among its new capabilities:

• Smart Productivity: Celia can generate office documents, presentations, and automate routine tasks—helping users get more done with fewer clicks.
• Contextual Assistance: The assistant adapts responses based on the user’s work context, aiming to anticipate needs and reduce repetitive labor.
• Ecosystem Integration: Celia operates seamlessly across other Huawei hardware, such as smartphones or tablets, enabling cross-device flows like document sharing or notification handoff.

This mirrors industry-wide trends as seen with Microsoft’s Copilot AI in Windows or Apple’s growing focus on on-device intelligence, but Huawei’s approach leans more heavily into contextual workflows and automation, setting a high bar for competitors.

Native App Package and Cross-Device Experience​

HarmonyOS Next debuts with a robust suite of pre-installed applications, covering office productivity (WPS Office), communication, and media consumption. Developers are encouraged to optimize their apps for the unified HarmonyOS framework, promising users a familiar experience whether switching from Huawei phones or tablets to laptops.
Perhaps more importantly, the OS promises tight cross-device continuity. For example, users can start an email on their phone and instantly continue on their laptop, or collaborate on files in real time across different types of Huawei hardware. This is the logical evolution of the “super device” vision Huawei has promoted, where hardware boundaries become less relevant.

Risks, Caveats, and International Viability​

While the OS represents genuine progress for China’s domestic computing ambitions, a number of potential pitfalls demand close examination.

Lack of Sideloading: Freedom vs. Security​

For power users—both in China and abroad—the absence of sideloading is deeply problematic. It hampers software freedom, limits access to open-source or experimental tools, and breaks compatibility with existing workflows reliant on non-App-Gallery apps. While Huawei’s “walled garden” may protect against some forms of malware, it also means every application is subject to Huawei's approval—raising concerns about overreach or censorship.

No Backward Compatibility: E-Waste and User Loyalty​

Excluding older hardware from HarmonyOS Next’s upgrade path may yield performance and security gains, but it raises sustainability issues. Forced hardware upgrade cycles contribute to electronic waste and can erode brand loyalty among existing customers who feel “left behind” less than a cycle after their last purchase.

Third-Party Ecosystem: App Gap and Developer Buy-In​

A fledgling operating system needs strong developer support to thrive. Windows’ (and to a lesser extent, Apple’s) greatest strength is the vast library of third-party software. HarmonyOS Next, by limiting itself to the App Gallery and new hardware only, faces a steep climb. Without robust developer incentives or easy porting tools, the OS risks an “app gap” scenario that could tarnish the user experience.
Huawei’s position in China’s massive domestic market gives it leverage, but global success is far less assured. International users are likely to demand a broader set of apps and greater flexibility than what a curated store can provide—factors that determine the fate of any new desktop OS.

Privacy and Geopolitical Considerations​

Global users must weigh privacy and sovereignty issues. Huawei’s close relationship with Chinese regulators is well known, and the centralization of software distribution via App Gallery places unprecedented control in the hands of the platform provider. While this may meet local regulatory requirements, it could discourage adoption among privacy-conscious users outside China.

Competitive Landscape: Windows 11, macOS, and the Future​

Comparing HarmonyOS Next to Windows 11 and macOS reveals key philosophical differences:

• Windows 11 leans on compatibility, openness, and a massive, established software ecosystem. Its performance and bloat have been criticized, but its adaptability remains unmatched.
• macOS excels in integration, stability, and a tightly regulated app environment. It maintains some sideloading flexibility and broader hardware support.
• HarmonyOS Next bets on security, cohesive design, and future-focused features like deep AI integration, but does so by sacrificing openness and backward compatibility.

In short, HarmonyOS Next represents China’s most assertive attempt yet to break free from Western software. However, it must work hard to avoid the traps that have hampered previous homegrown OS efforts—mainly, lack of developer enthusiasm, consumer trust, and third-party applications.

Who Should Consider HarmonyOS Next?​

At launch, HarmonyOS Next targets a very specific demographic: buyers of new Huawei laptops in China who want a seamless, secure, AI-augmented experience and who have already embraced the Huawei ecosystem across phones and smart devices.
For international users, “enthusiasts,” and enterprise clients, the current OS’s restrictions are likely to be a non-starter—unless future versions restore some degree of openness or compatibility.

Key Takeaways​

• Strengths:
• Enhanced UI and performance, especially on the latest Huawei hardware.
• Deep integration with Huawei’s ecosystem, offering an Apple-like cross-device experience in China.
• Strong AI features embedded in the OS and native apps.
• Robust security via App Gallery gatekeeping.
• Risks/Weaknesses:
• Lack of sideloading stifles software freedom and experimentation.
• No support for older Huawei devices; customers must buy new hardware.
• “App gap” concerns unless developer incentives materialize.
• Limited international appeal due to ecosystem lock-in and privacy questions.

Outlook: The Road Ahead for HarmonyOS Next​

HarmonyOS Next is neither a simple Windows clone nor an ambitious but doomed vanity project. It is a critical milestone for Chinese tech sovereignty—one built on years of adversity and the growing strength of Huawei’s research and engineering resources. For users willing to “buy in” to the Huawei way, the OS promises a fluid, secure, and smart user experience.
Yet the OS’s decision to reject sideloading and backward compatibility may ultimately throttle its innovative potential outside China, especially among those who value software freedom and longevity over short-term polish. The global desktop OS market is one of the hardest to crack, and only time will tell if HarmonyOS Next can carve out a lasting niche or if its strengths will be overshadowed by its rigidities.
For now, HarmonyOS Next stands as the boldest effort yet to challenge the Windows status quo in China’s consumer computing landscape—bringing with it the perennial debate between openness and control, old and new, freedom and security. In a world increasingly defined by platform competition and digital sovereignty, Huawei’s next move is certain to reverberate far beyond China’s borders.

---

Source: Wccftech Huawei's HarmonyOS Takes On Windows 11 with Enhanced UI and Performance — But Deprived of App Sideloading & Backward Compatibility