Windows 10’s official countdown has turned a long-running conversation into a practical decision many readers face today: do you need a new laptop, or can your existing machine survive the transition with a little effort? The short answer from recent coverage and retail testing is nuanced: Windows 10 will stop receiving regular security and feature updates after October 14, 2025, but that doesn’t mean every affected PC must be tossed. Product reviewers point to a handful of modern, affordable Windows 11–ready laptops as sensible upgrades for most people, while cloud and lightweight operating systems — notably ChromeOS Flex — make it possible to repurpose older machines and avoid unnecessary e‑waste. The Wirecutter pick that’s getting the most attention for everyday buyers is the Asus Vivobook S 14 (Q423SA-U5512): thin, light, OLED display, long battery life, and strong portability — a pragmatic compromise for those who want a fresh machine without paying for a premium, top‑end model.
What “end of support” means practically:
ASUS’s official product page confirms the core specs that make the Vivobook S 14 attractive:
Other options:
Source: The New York Times Windows 10 Is Dead. But You Might Not Need a New Laptop Yet.
Background / Overview
Why the fuss: Windows 10 end of support — the facts
Microsoft has set a clear end‑of‑support date for Windows 10: October 14, 2025. After that date, Microsoft will no longer provide the standard flow of technical assistance, feature updates, or security patches for Windows 10 consumer and Pro editions; the company directs users toward Windows 11 or paid Extended Security Updates (ESU) as a stopgap. This is Microsoft’s official guidance and the anchor that turned a slow migration into a deadline many households and small businesses must plan around. (support.microsoft.com) (learn.microsoft.com)What “end of support” means practically:
- No more security patches for newly discovered vulnerabilities, leaving online machines at greater risk.
- No more official technical support or troubleshooting from Microsoft.
- Some Microsoft services and apps will continue to run for a time, but compatibility and reliability will decline over the years following EOL. (support.microsoft.com)
Windows 11 eligibility: the hardware dividing line
A key complication is that Windows 11 has stricter hardware requirements than Windows 10 did. Trusted Platform Module (TPM) 2.0, Secure Boot, and relatively recent CPU families are central to Microsoft’s security rationale for Windows 11, and many devices manufactured in the mid‑2010s will fail the compatibility checks. For users whose PCs don’t meet the criteria, Microsoft’s official options are limited: buy a new compatible device, run ESU for a short period (if available), or consider a different operating system. This reality makes the upgrade decision more than a software choice — it’s a hardware one. (learn.microsoft.com)What Wirecutter (and shoppers) are saying — the practical angle
Wirecutter’s recent take, which has been widely circulated, boils down to three practical recommendations:- If your Windows 10 laptop is slow, insecure, or incompatible with Windows 11’s minimum requirements, consider buying a new laptop.
- If you do buy a new laptop, prioritize a model that balances portability, battery life, and display quality — Wirecutter’s current Windows pick is the Asus Vivobook S 14 (Q423SA-U5512), praised as the best option for most people because it’s thin, light, and boasts impressive battery life in the ultrabook class.
- If you’re not ready to buy, don’t landfill the old device — options exist to repurpose it (for example, with ChromeOS Flex) or recycle it safely through retail and manufacturer programs. Wirecutter’s coverage emphasizes that there are sensible alternatives between “keep an insecure PC forever” and “buy the most expensive new Copilot+ laptop.”
The Asus Vivobook S 14 — what reviewers highlight (and what the manufacturer says)
Wirecutter’s recommendation centers on a practical balance of features: lightweight at roughly 2.87 pounds, an OLED display, long battery life sufficient for a full day, and a customizable RGB keyboard that stands out in this price/performance space. These are exactly the attributes many buyers value for everyday work, web use, classes, and travel.ASUS’s official product page confirms the core specs that make the Vivobook S 14 attractive:
- 14.0‑inch WUXGA OLED panel with high brightness and a broad color gamut.
- Intel Core Ultra 5 processor family (Series 2) in many configurations with integrated Intel Arc graphics and an on‑device NPU for AI‑assisted tasks.
- 75 Wh battery and marketing claims around extended battery life and mobility.
- Weight: 1.30 kg (≈2.87 lb) and a very thin chassis that emphasize portability. (asus.com)
- The model Wirecutter tested lacks a touchscreen and does not include a fingerprint reader in the base configuration; ASUS uses an IR webcam and facial recognition login instead. If biometric fingerprint login or touch interaction is essential to you, confirm the SKU you buy. ASUS’s spec sheet is the authoritative reference for these features. (asus.com)
- The real-world battery life you’ll see depends heavily on configuration, display brightness, and workload; slight differences between reviewer battery figures (e.g., 16–17 hours in lab tests) are common. Always treat each battery number as an estimate for light‑to‑moderate use.
Alternatives to buying a new Windows 11 laptop
1) Repurpose with ChromeOS Flex (turn your old laptop into a Chromebook)
For many older laptops that are too slow on modern Windows builds or ineligible for Windows 11, ChromeOS Flex is a practical, supported option to extend device life. Google’s ChromeOS Flex is designed to run on many PCs and Macs from the past decade and offers:- Lightweight, browser‑centric workflows with automatic updates.
- Fast boot times, reduced background bloat, and simpler security model.
- Official tooling and a certified device list so you can check compatibility before installing. (chromeos.google, support.google.com)
2) Move to Linux (for power users and privacy‑minded users)
Linux distributions such as Ubuntu, Mint, or Fedora can give older hardware new life, but they require more familiarity and effort to set up. Linux is a strong alternative when you rely primarily on open‑source software or browser‑based tools and are comfortable troubleshooting drivers and hardware quirks.3) Cloud PCs and Windows 365
If your primary applications can be run remotely, a Cloud PC (Windows 365 or similar desktop‑as‑a‑service) allows you to use lightweight endpoints while the heavy compute runs in the cloud. Microsoft explicitly lists cloud options as a migration path for organizations and power users seeking a secure transition without immediate hardware replacements. (microsoft.com)4) Extended Security Updates (ESU) as a bridge
For consumers who absolutely cannot move off an existing Windows 10 machine, Microsoft opened a limited consumer ESU option that extends security updates for a short period for a fee. This is an intentionally temporary, paid route that gives you time to plan, migrate, or repurpose devices. Note that ESU terms and enrollment mechanisms evolve; check Microsoft’s official guidance for the latest eligibility and process. (support.microsoft.com)Responsible disposal: recycling and trade‑in options
If you do replace a machine, it’s critical to avoid throwing old electronics in the trash. Retailers and manufacturers operate trade‑in and recycling programs; Best Buy is one of the largest retail recyclers in the U.S., offering in‑store drop‑off and paid mail‑back boxes, plus trade‑in options that can offset the cost of a new purchase. Best Buy’s recycling page and corporate materials outline accepted items, limitations (household vs. business quantities), and practical steps including wiping data before drop‑off. (bestbuy.com, corporate.bestbuy.com)Other options:
- Sell or trade in through marketplaces and refurbishers (Back Market, Swappa, etc.) to capture value.
- Donate working devices to local schools, charities, or organizations that refurbish and redistribute laptops.
- Use manufacturer take‑back programs (many OEMs offer trade‑in or recycling). Lifewire and other consumer guides offer practical steps for data erasure and donation best practices. (lifewire.com)
How to decide — a practical checklist
This is a short, action‑oriented checklist to take you from “confused” to “decided.”- Confirm your PC’s status:
- Run Microsoft’s PC Health Check to see if your device is eligible for Windows 11.
- Check battery condition and running speed: can simple upgrades (SSD, RAM) fix the sluggishness?
- Evaluate your needs:
- Do you need Windows‑only desktop apps (native Photoshop, engineering tools, specialized software)? If yes, upgrade or buy a Windows 11‑compatible machine.
- Are you primarily a browser/cloud user? Consider ChromeOS Flex or a lightweight Linux distribution.
- If buying, weigh priorities:
- Portability and battery life (light users, commuters): ultrabook picks like the Asus Vivobook S 14 make sense.
- Productivity and futureproofing: look for Intel Core Ultra / Ryzen 7000‑series or better, TPM 2.0/Pluton security, and Thunderbolt/USB‑C.
- If keeping, harden security:
- Consider ESU (if available for you) as a short bridge.
- Run up‑to‑date security tools, minimize online exposure, and keep backups.
- Plan disposal / repurpose:
- Try ChromeOS Flex or donate/refurbish.
- Use a certified recycling option (Best Buy, OEM program) for dead or unsaleable laptops. (learn.microsoft.com, chromeos.google, bestbuy.com)
Critical analysis: strengths and risks of the “don’t rush” approach
Strengths — why Wirecutter’s middle path is practical
- Cost‑effective: Not everyone needs the bleeding edge. A targeted replacement (midrange ultrabook) or a repurpose plan can avoid a large, unnecessary outlay.
- Environmental benefit: Extending the life of hardware or recycling responsibly reduces e‑waste and the carbon footprint associated with manufacturing new devices.
- Real user needs: Many users primarily use browsers and Office suites where the incremental benefits of Windows 11 are small compared with the cost of buying a new machine.
Risks and weaknesses — why caution is warranted
- Security risk: Once Windows 10 stops getting security updates, online devices are more vulnerable to zero‑day and targeted exploits. The ESU program is short and not a long‑term solution for most consumers. Microsoft’s official guidance explicitly makes security the top reason to migrate. (support.microsoft.com)
- Compatibility tangle: Some newer apps and services will be optimized for Windows 11-only features (or hardware acceleration tied to newer NPUs). Over time, software vendors may limit support on older OS versions.
- Hidden costs: Upgrading components (adding an SSD, more RAM) can be cost effective — but those fixes aren’t universally available (many ultrabooks have soldered RAM and non‑user‑serviceable parts).
- Vendor nudges and market dynamics: Microsoft’s Copilot+ messaging and OEM marketing push emphasize newer hardware; whether that’s “necessary” or “opportunistic” depends on how much you value AI integration and the new interface. Critics argue the timing risks generating avoidable e‑waste and imposing costs on consumers. Recent legal action and press coverage highlight these tensions. (windowscentral.com, techradar.com)
Quick technical reality checks and verifiable specifics
- Windows 10 end‑of‑support date: October 14, 2025 (Microsoft official). (support.microsoft.com, learn.microsoft.com)
- ASUS Vivobook S 14 (Q423 series) weight and display: ~1.30 kg (2.87 lb) and OLED display per ASUS product specifications; battery rated at 75 Wh; manufacturer lists long battery life claims (lab conditions will vary). If Wirecutter’s tests reported ~17 hours in a light‑use scenario, that aligns with typical reviewer variability versus ASUS’s marketing statements. Always check the SKU and test methodology. (asus.com)
- ChromeOS Flex is a supported, Google‑provided OS for reviving many older PCs and Macs; it has a certified device list and USB installer workflow. It’s best for users comfortable with browser‑centric workflows. (chromeos.google, support.google.com)
- Best Buy and other retailers run free in‑store recycling and paid mail‑back recycling as well as trade‑in programs. Retailers often offer guidance for data wiping and trade‑in value. (bestbuy.com, corporate.bestbuy.com)
Bottom line — a balanced recommendation
- If your current Windows 10 laptop is performing decently, and your workflow is mostly cloud or browser‑based, you do not necessarily need to rush into a full‑price Windows 11 replacement today. Consider repurposing with ChromeOS Flex, upgrading key components (SSD/RAM) if feasible, or enrolling in ESU only as a short bridge.
- If your machine is slow, has a failing battery, or you rely on software that will benefit from Windows 11 or newer hardware capabilities (AI/NPUs, improved integrated graphics), a modern ultrabook is a sensible buy. The Asus Vivobook S 14 (Q423SA‑U5512) represents a good balance of portability, display quality, and battery life for many buyers. Confirm the exact configuration before purchase and check for touch/fingerprint options if you need them.
- Whatever path you take, commit to responsible end‑of‑life handling: donate, trade in, or recycle through certified programs such as Best Buy’s in‑store drop‑off or mail‑back options to reduce e‑waste. (bestbuy.com)
Quick purchase and migration checklist (final practical steps)
- Run PC Health Check to determine Windows 11 compatibility.
- Back up all data to an external drive or cloud storage.
- If buying new: confirm the SKU, test battery life expectations, and ensure it includes the features you need (touch, fingerprint, ports).
- If keeping the old device: test ChromeOS Flex on USB first, or plan for component upgrades if the hardware is serviceable.
- Before recycling or donating: wipe drives, remove accounts, and follow local laws for data protection.
- Use retailer recycling programs or certified refurbishers to avoid landfill. (learn.microsoft.com, support.google.com, bestbuy.com)
Source: The New York Times Windows 10 Is Dead. But You Might Not Need a New Laptop Yet.
Last edited:
