📎 AI Summary:
The thread discusses allegations that Microsoft’s Windows OS, particularly Windows 7 and Vista, borrow ideas from Apple’s Mac OS X, with claims that Microsoft’s marketing slogan admits to "stealing" ideas. Participants debate whether similarities imply actual theft, referencing legal cases and industry practices of borrowing design concepts, and consider whether Microsoft’s commercial participants are compensated. Overall, the conversation reflects skepticism about Microsoft’s originality and a view that such borrowing is commonplace in the tech industry.

xolo

New Member
Member details
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
6
Thread Author #1
Microsoft’s' newest operating system, Windows 7, has a new campaign out. The advertisements follow certain people around, and they end up showing how "I'm a PC and Windows 7 was my idea".

Of course Microsoft's new operating system was someone else's idea. They haven't had an original idea in any of their operating systems. They have all been stolen from other companies or people. For example, their last operating system Vista was blatantly stolen from Apple's Mac OS X. There were so many similarities, that you cannot chalk it up to coincidence.

But since Microsoft is finally openly admitting to stealing other people's creative ideas, perhaps the entire PC user world should create a class action suit demanding their cut of the profits. Microsoft isn't providing their new product "free of charge" to all of these users that contributed to the new operating system, are they? Did these people receive a paycheck to show that they were under the employment of Microsoft and therefore they own those ideas? Nope. But Microsoft is charging anywhere between $119.99 and $319.99 USD for a license to run the software (you still can't own your own copy; you can only buy rights to use it).

It just seems to be illicit in my opinion. What do you think?
 

Solution
Just to lighten the atmoshpere. Read this:
Folklore.org: Macintosh Stories: A Rich Neighbor Named Xerox

It is "normal" practice for companies to borrow/steal each others material..

What pays off in the end is how useable, or userfriendly, the product is when it hits the retail shelves , and how good the backup may be.

"But since Microsoft is finally openly admitting to stealing other people's creative ideas"

I think you may have misunderstood the slogan, no company, incuding Microsoft, would admit to such a thing. What they are saying is that the OS was built around the operability of the computers, and the people who use them (Us).

The price does seem, to many, to high. But, maybe irrelvant in this...

nabucco

Honorable Member
Member details
Joined
Dec 29, 2009
Messages
34
Compare the price of an operating system as complex as Windows, with a simple application like Network Administrator's Toolkit Free Download and Reviews - Fileforum