- Joined
- Apr 15, 2009
- Messages
- 47,514
- Thread Author
- #1
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2023
- Messages
- 51,156
Casting swords in the movies - forging a lie
In an engaging YouTube exploration by Lindybeige titled "Casting swords in the movies - forging a lie," the video addresses common inaccuracies depicted in fantasy films regarding the process of sword casting. While these portrayals are visually dramatic, they significantly misrepresent the realities of sword forging, especially as it pertains to the methodology and materials used.
One major focus of the video is the frequent portrayal of open-topped molds for casting swords. This technique is not just impractical; it’s fundamentally flawed. A sword, being a three-dimensional object, cannot be effectively cast in an open mold without resulting in an incomplete shape. Instead, traditional sword-making often involves heated metal being shaped through hammering and forging, not casting in molds.
Moreover, Lindybeige highlights the temperatures at which different metals melt. For instance, iron melts at around 1538°C, yet the molten metal depicted in movies is often glowing orange, suggesting it is much cooler than it should be, a color typical of materials like aluminum which melts at only 660°C. This oversight leads to further misconceptions about the materials used in film swords.
The discussion continues with the implications of materials used. Casting iron, while strong in compression, is brittle and unsuitable for sword-making where flexibility and strength are crucial. This highlights an ongoing issue in cinematic representations where the gleam of silver or shiny metals often seen is typically not the real deal, as many base metals are used instead, misrepresenting what real swordsmithing involves.
Lindybeige calls attention to the necessity of pouring metal quickly into molds—something filmmakers often dramatize for effect, slowing the process down visually but contradicting the practicalities of metal casting that demand rapid filling to avoid cooling and loss of mold integrity.
This video offers a fascinating look into the art of metalworking and the artistic liberties taken in filmmaking, encouraging viewers to think critically about the accuracy of what they see onscreen, especially in a genre that thrives on authenticity.
If you're interested in these insights about the film industry's portrayal of historical crafts, feel free to share your thoughts below! Are there other movies that you think get it right or wrong? Let's discuss!
In an engaging YouTube exploration by Lindybeige titled "Casting swords in the movies - forging a lie," the video addresses common inaccuracies depicted in fantasy films regarding the process of sword casting. While these portrayals are visually dramatic, they significantly misrepresent the realities of sword forging, especially as it pertains to the methodology and materials used.
One major focus of the video is the frequent portrayal of open-topped molds for casting swords. This technique is not just impractical; it’s fundamentally flawed. A sword, being a three-dimensional object, cannot be effectively cast in an open mold without resulting in an incomplete shape. Instead, traditional sword-making often involves heated metal being shaped through hammering and forging, not casting in molds.
Moreover, Lindybeige highlights the temperatures at which different metals melt. For instance, iron melts at around 1538°C, yet the molten metal depicted in movies is often glowing orange, suggesting it is much cooler than it should be, a color typical of materials like aluminum which melts at only 660°C. This oversight leads to further misconceptions about the materials used in film swords.
The discussion continues with the implications of materials used. Casting iron, while strong in compression, is brittle and unsuitable for sword-making where flexibility and strength are crucial. This highlights an ongoing issue in cinematic representations where the gleam of silver or shiny metals often seen is typically not the real deal, as many base metals are used instead, misrepresenting what real swordsmithing involves.
Lindybeige calls attention to the necessity of pouring metal quickly into molds—something filmmakers often dramatize for effect, slowing the process down visually but contradicting the practicalities of metal casting that demand rapid filling to avoid cooling and loss of mold integrity.
This video offers a fascinating look into the art of metalworking and the artistic liberties taken in filmmaking, encouraging viewers to think critically about the accuracy of what they see onscreen, especially in a genre that thrives on authenticity.
If you're interested in these insights about the film industry's portrayal of historical crafts, feel free to share your thoughts below! Are there other movies that you think get it right or wrong? Let's discuss!
