I understand that it is the beta version of what will be the Ultimate version of Windows 7. I do understand that. Now, I've been using computers for a long time. I've put quite a number of them together and installed countless copies of Windows on them. I don't spend hours upon hours every day trying to solve network issues, but I'm reasonably competent and until recently thought that I could get any network going properly. I remember first coming across the way Microsoft was moving when we were all at a pc gaming convention and all of us on desktops had XP Professional, and one friend had a laptop with Vista Home Premium. As the designated "fix-it" guy, they looked to me to get the damn thing talking with the XP machines.
It wasn't the Link Layer Topology issue - we all had updated copies of XP. His laptop could not see any shared folders on our pc's so he couldn't copy any game patches from us (the hotel's 8mb broadband connection quickly degenerated into much worse than dial-up when over two hundred computers were simultaneously trying to go everywhere over the 'net), and worse still, he couldn't see any of the games we were hosting. Vista's network options seemed labyrinthine next to XP's. We spent several hours trying to get Vista talking to the others. At one point, so frustrated with it, I even appealed to the network set-up guys for the 'con - very competent people. They told me they didn't want to go anywhere near it because "Vista's network settings are a balls to get right". In the end we did get it working but it took a fair while after that.
Now, I've had two copies of Vista installed on this media pc of ours. One came with it, because to save time we just bought this cheap little Acer. It had only two sata ports, the hard drive and the dvd drive. We had to swap out the hard drive and put in a pata drive as a replacement, as we'd bought a terabyte drive for media and an LG Blu-Ray/HD-DVD drive - Blu-Ray as it had won at the time and we could rent out films in that format, and HD-DVD as we could get them cheap now that the format was dying out. Anyway, before we swapped it out we had several odd issues with it. The wi-fi card kept picking up the signal as very weak, even though the Wii below the television and behind a glass door picked up a strong signal. The Radeon 3450 we'd bought came with ATi's audio over HDMI, and we'd bought a HDMI cable to take advantage of our 32" Mirai hdtv. Oddly, the HDMI audio device would appear and disappear on the device manager. I got it to work once - only once - and it worked fine. But then I had to reset after a Windows Update and bang! The device was missing, we had no sound, and we had to revert to the vga cable.
Cue the next drive to be put in. The Radeon HDMI device still wouldn't appear, but this installation had other issues. We'd sorted out the wireless card problem by running ethernet cable all over the apartment to the media pc - awkward, but it works. In Media Centre (and it wasn't a codec issue, believe me), videos would jump if we used zoom mode 3 on pan and scan files. Selecting something in the menu with the remote solved the problem for a few seconds, so it wasn't the television. I went all over the Internet to solve that one, even including recording three videos so people could see what I meant. Absolutely nobody had an idea what was going on. The Acer, it seemed, was cursed. While my flat-mate is also competent with computers, this was, as he put it, "your baby". I'd built a media pc out home before we moved out to the apartment and gave it to my younger brother as a birthday present. I promised myself that the one we'd have in the apartment would be better. But this one just seemed cursed. Things would just fail at random. And believe me when I say I've tried everything to solve it. For example, if everything was failing randomly, I thought, it might be a PSU issue. So I bought a good brand 500w PSU. Everything was exactly the same. See what I mean about cursed?
So, I began to resort to somewhat desperate measures. I tried that media-centric version of Kubuntu I mentioned - which was awful. I tried (because I'm impatient and despite having plenty of issues myself with Vista when it first came out, I grew to love it) the 6801 version of Windows 7. We bought a new television, all the jumping went away, we'd bought speakers in the meantime and so went back to the visual only HDMI cable (that audio device still won't appear, yet the 4870 in my desktop brings it up all the time, so I assume the 3450 is faulty... but eh, it does put out a nice image). Everything was hunky dory. Despite all the issues we've had with the pc, though, throughout the various os installations, we were always able to share media across the network. That's right, including the 6801 version of 7, which was also the Ultimate version if I recall correctly. When Microsoft announced that the 7000 beta would be given out free, I signed up to become a tester and decided to put the new copy of 7000 on the media pc in place of 6801. 6801 was working, but it was a fairly barebones copy, and besides, I wanted Windows Update support.
So, fast forward to last week. 7000 is installed. Everything looks beautiful. It's a really nice os. It seemed like all our problems with the pc had come to a close. Except they haven't. I can't share media across the network anymore. Oh, I can copy files across and back again, no problem. I just can't watch videos across the network anymore, neither through my desktop or when in bed, wirelessly using my laptop, like I always was able to. My flat-mate, with his XP-based machines, cannot see the media pc on the network. The media pc cannot see his machines on the network. Despite showing a .jpg of the co-owner privilege in the help files for sharing folders, 7000 does not have this privilege. It has replaced it with read/write. Which works. Except I cannot view videos across the network. The curse was back. So, you can understand my frustration and anger that, after all this time, after all the problems I've had with it that have lead me to tearing my hair out over trying to solve all those weird issues, everything finally worked but for something that was very important with our media pc. So hopefully you can see that, while asking for help, I have to think about the problem and I become so angry that it becomes less a plea for help and more of a rant and rave session at Microsoft.
Our home network is plugged into an ISP. And I do have a fairly good understanding of how network security works, and how important it is. Sharing videos across our private, home network, which believe you me has a well secured adsl connection to the 'net, should not be an issue. That is not the issue here, though I understand why you brought it up. And I did come here (and to two other forums) asking for help, but every time I look at Windows 7's network options, every time I think about the problem, I have to think about all the measures I've gone through to get the damn thing to talk to the other machines in the apartment. It makes my blood boil not just because it isn't working, but because of the way Microsoft is going with networking. With XP, it was so simple. Setup the network wizard, type in the workgroup name, tell Windows you want to share a folder. Badda bing, badda boom. Further security was up to you. I understand Microsoft is trying to make the os secure for everybody (and, of course, being the Ultimate version, it's got to be very secure, I understand this) but if there was a way to turn all of this permission stuff off, I would be so grateful. Not everybody needs it. Not everybody wants it.
Microsoft and Windows 7 should not be concerned about how I share media across my home network. Because I have tried absolutely
everything there is to try and solve this problem, and because Microsoft's new security measures are making it ten times harder, my post here and on the other boards has turned into a simultaneous cry for help, and a bitch session at Microsoft. I can't help it. I get so very angry when I think about the whole issue and how so simple it was in XP... and how though Vista and 6801 share 7's weird network setups, they had no such problems. They had their own problems of course, as evidenced by my long-winded response above (sorry), but they allowed me to share media. When new features come at the cost of such basic functionality, it steams me up even more. iroken22, who has been kind enough to reply to every one of my posts asking for help, has the very same beta copy and has no such problems with seeing XP machines, and media sharing. Maybe now you can understand? Nobody else is having this issue. Just me.
Well, obviously people are having network issues, but I don't see anyone posting about this particular issue. I even posted in Microsoft's own Technet forum and nobody replied. On the Penny Arcade > Games & Technology > Moe's Stupid Technology Tavern > Windows 7 thread, I posted the same rant. Someone said, "Well, let's start at the start. You have shared the folders, yes? What permissions have you given them?" I replied by giving a detailed look at everything I have done, everything I have selected in the network options, and hoped for a reply. I think he is stumped, and everyone along with him, because I have no reply yet and my post is now several pages back.
I withdraw my simultaneous begging for help/rant. Nobody seems able to help me (anywhere over the Internet, which is a first) and this is definitely not a constructive, helpful environment we've got going in this thread here. Sorry people, don't worry your heads about it, let's just pretend I never posted here to begin with.