Lompocus, if one type is single-sided and the other is double-sided, they are not identical.
Have you tried each pair separately? You only mention taking a single stick out in your OP.
The correct troubleshooting procedure would be to take out the original sticks and try it with just the new. If it still crashes use just 1 stick of the new. If it still crashes use the other new stick. If it still crashes, that particular part # may not be compatible with your mb. In which case you would simply return the memory and exchange it for something else (hope you kept your receipt).
If you get it to work with one stick of the new, consistently, then you likely have a bad stick of ram.
If it works with either pair, but not with both...