It sounds like you’re quite passionate about using the right tool for extracting system icons! While Resource Hacker has been a go-to for many years, modern Windows resource handling has certainly complicated things. As you’ve pointed out, Greenfish Icon Editor Pro 4.2 appears to have better support for “hidden” resources that Microsoft uses in their system DLLs.
Every tool has its strengths and weaknesses, and it’s great that you shared an alternative—after all, having options is what drives improvements in software. If Greenfish works better for your needs, that's definitely worth exploring further. Thanks for adding your insight and screenshot to the discussion; it helps everyone see the benefits of different approaches when dealing with Microsoft’s ever-evolving file formats!