Is Third-Party Antivirus Still Necessary? Windows 11 Security in 2025

When it comes to securing a modern PC, few subjects trigger as much debate as the real necessity of third-party antivirus on Windows 11. For decades, the adage that “every Windows user needs antivirus” was as universally accepted as locking your front door—but today, things are changing. Microsoft’s rarefied focus on security has led to an operating system where, for the first time, the default suite may offer all the protection that mainstream users need.

The Reinvention of Built-In Security​

Windows Security (formerly known as Windows Defender) has matured from a basic spyware cleaner to an all-in-one security powerhouse, earning perfect, independent test scores for malware protection, low system impact, and usability. As of the most recent AV-TEST evaluations, Microsoft Defender Antivirus scored a flawless 6.0 out of 6.0 in all core categories—protection, performance, and usability—matching or even outperforming leading third-party competitors. These results speak to years of relentless development and millions of dollars invested in threat detection, behavioral analytics, and rapid response frameworks.

What Windows Security Now Offers​

• Virus & threat protection: Real-time scanning with both traditional and behavioral defenses, plus manual and scheduled scan options.
• Firewall & network protection: Advanced management of network traffic and monitoring for unauthorized connections.
• App & browser control: Microsoft’s SmartScreen filter protects not only Edge users against malicious websites and downloads, but also provides a system-wide defense for Chrome, Firefox, and Opera users via network-level alerts.
• Device security: Hardware-based features such as Secure Boot, TPM checks, and Core Isolation defend against bootkits and firmware-level attacks.
• Account protection: Enhanced sign-in options and routine monitoring of account safety measures.
• Device performance & health: A dashboard summarizing critical updates, storage, battery life, and device lifecycle issues, unifying the proactive elements of PC maintenance.

This integration means users receive both scheduled and real-time updates to threat definitions, ensuring the environment remains current against emerging threats without any manual input. In real-world use, Windows Defender demonstrates outstanding efficiency: Even during resource-intensive background scans, CPU usage seldom surges above 14% on typical consumer hardware, with negligible impact on day-to-day performance.

Separation from Microsoft Defender (Suite)​

A crucial distinction is now required: Windows Security (the built-in app) is not synonymous with Microsoft Defender, a paid offering bundled in Microsoft 365 subscriptions. The latter amplifies basic protections with extras like VPN access, dark web monitoring, and a centralized dashboard for multiple device protection—ideal for families or power-users seeking cross-platform safeguards or identity theft insurance.

Assessing the Evidence: Do You Still Need Third-Party Antivirus?​

Independent Lab Results​

Not only has Microsoft Defender nailed perfect AV-TEST scores, but most major free competitors such as Avast and Bitdefender also hover near the top. However, the gap between built-in and third-party solutions continues to shrink. Defender’s overall protection arises from a blend of cloud-based threat intelligence, AI-driven heuristics, and extensive telemetry gathered from across billions of Windows systems worldwide.

• Bitdefender: 100% protection, performance, and usability (AV-TEST, April 2024).
• Avast: 100% across the board, matching Defender, but with additional features and more granular user control.
• AVG, Kaspersky, McAfee: All boast near-perfect records, often with bells and whistles like VPN, password managers, or file shredders—at the cost of upsells, heavier CPU usage, or intrusive notifications.

Despite these achievements, everyday users running relatively standard workloads (web browsing, email, office tasks) are unlikely to experience any tangible increase in security by adding another antivirus package—provided they maintain up-to-date Windows installations and avoid risky online behavior.

The Critical Layer: Security Best Practices​

No antivirus—built-in or otherwise—can compensate for poor user hygiene. Reputable research and countless forum threads consistently highlight that the main vector for malware, ransomware, and phishing attacks isn’t some zero-day exploit, but human error.

Top Recommendations:​

• Keep Windows Updated: The lion’s share of successful attacks leverage known vulnerabilities. Windows Update delivers monthly (and sometimes emergency) security patches, closing these holes.
• Update Browsers and Applications: Exploits target not just the OS, but popular browsers and productivity suites.
• Practice Safe Browsing Habits: Avoid downloading software or attachments from untrusted sources. Refrain from clicking suspicious links, and always verify website authenticity before logging in or submitting sensitive information.
• Use Strong, Unique Passwords: Password reuse remains a catastrophic risk. Employ a modern password manager to generate and store complex credentials.
• Turn on Firewall, BitLocker, and Core Isolation: Layered security is superior. BitLocker, in particular, secures user data in case of device theft or loss.
• Configure User Account Control (UAC): These prompts help prevent malware from making system changes without explicit approval.

These simple, proactive steps form the bedrock of robust digital self-care. In the hands of a diligent user, they can halt even sophisticated attacks at the doorstep.

A Layered Defense Approach: When Does Third-Party Antivirus Make Sense?​

Advanced Features: The Real Draw​

While Defender secures the basics, third-party vendors focus on value-added features that can genuinely appeal to high-risk or specialized users. These may include:

• Dedicated Parental Controls: Robust activity monitoring and filtering for families.
• Comprehensive Device Management Suites: Central dashboards to oversee PCs, Macs, and mobile devices from a single pane.
• Data Leak Monitoring: Active scanning of the dark web for stolen credentials.
• Integrated VPNs: Handy for maintaining privacy on public Wi-Fi.
• Webcam and Microphone Blocking, Encrypted Banking Modes: Exceed Defender’s current feature set.

Premium solutions like Bitdefender Ultimate and McAfee Plus Premium now combine security with bundled privacy and insurance products—a compelling all-in-one suite for digital families that require more than baseline protections, or for small business users with multiple device types to secure.

The Downsides: System Impact and Privacy Concerns​

However, these perks are double-edged. Free offerings seldom arrive without strings attached; users can expect persistent upgrade prompts, telemetry-driven advertising, and, in some notorious cases, the wholesale commercial sale of user data (as witnessed with Avast and other vendors). Furthermore, the more modules a third-party suite introduces—password management, VPN tunneling, parental oversight—the greater the risk of system slowdowns, compatibility glitches, and even vulnerability to software flaws in the security suite itself.
Importantly, when third-party antivirus is installed, Windows disables large portions of its built-in security stack by default, reducing the benefits of its seamless integration. For users concerned with privacy, this trade-off—potentially surrendering data to a for-profit company versus Microsoft—must be carefully considered.

Real-World User Behavior: The Human Element​

It’s not only about the software—security is a continual process. WindowsForum.com users and experts alike agree that most compromised Windows PCs aren’t breached through technical wizardry but via social engineering: phishing emails, malicious scripts masquerading as free downloads, or tricked users disabling critical defenses for “just one” download.

The Most Damaging Security Mistakes​

• Disabling AV or the firewall to run an untrusted app.
• Ignoring update notifications, leaving old vulnerabilites open.
• Using weak or reused passwords.
• Failing to audit and restrict application permissions.

Education and conscious online habits are, without question, the strongest defense. For enterprise or high-value targets—those handling sensitive client information, business data, or finances—a multi-factor, layered setup combining strong authentication, hardware-backed encryption, and occasional security audits is indispensable.

Notable Innovations: Administrator Protection and Least Privilege​

With Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 27774, Microsoft introduced “Administrator Protection”—a just-in-time privilege escalation system that limits admin access to explicit, authenticated tasks. This innovation closes many of the remaining gaps historically exploited via privilege escalation attacks. It allows users to operate as admins while defaulting to standard privileges, and only granting full rights after a secure prompt (often using Windows Hello biometrics), reducing the window for malware to strike.
For the average user, this shakes up long-standing security wisdom: gone is the need to manage separate “admin” and “user” accounts for safety. Now, one can operate efficiently and securely without added hassle or exposure to attack vectors typically associated with elevated privileges.

Caution: No System is Invulnerable​

Despite all these advances, neither Microsoft nor any third-party vendor has solved cybersecurity’s “human problem.” As demonstrated at security contests like Pwn2Own, even up-to-date Windows 11 systems can fall to carefully-crafted, never-before-seen (zero-day) exploit chains. The main lessons for both home and enterprise users:

• Never depend exclusively on patching or a single security layer.
• Deploy a mix of prompt patching, endpoint monitoring, and education on phishing/social engineering.
• Harden user privileges and require multi-factor authentication where feasible.
• Regularly back up critical files, offline if possible, to mitigate ransomware and disaster scenarios.

Weighing the Choice: The Bottom Line​

So, do most Windows 11 users need a third-party antivirus in 2025? For the majority—those who keep their systems updated, use strong passwords, enable built-in protections, and practice solid digital hygiene—the answer is increasingly “no.” Windows Security, as it ships, offers real-time, cloud-driven, behaviorally-aware security that meets the needs of most consumers without fuss or cost.
However, if your threat profile is high—children using shared PCs, employees needing device management at scale, or if you desire niche features like VPN or identity theft insurance—a high-quality third-party suite remains advantageous. Just weigh the performance impact, data privacy implications, and real value of those extra modules before making the leap.
Above all, remember: security is more about sustained personal vigilance than it is about the name on your antivirus. The most insidious malware often comes packaged with a click from your own hand. Let built-in tools handle the technical grunt work, and let education, careful software choices, and prudent habits complete the shield. That’s what genuine peace of mind on Windows 11 ultimately demands—a partnership between user and OS, not just another piece of software.

---

Source: MakeUseOf https://www.makeuseof.com/windows-11-security-no-antivirus/

 

[ChatGPT]

While Windows 11 boasts one of the most robust native security suites to ever ship with a Microsoft operating system, the debate around the necessity of third-party antivirus software remains highly relevant—and surprisingly complex. It’s tempting to take Microsoft at its word: Windows Defender, now officially part of Windows Security, has matured dramatically over the last decade. Independent labs like AV-Test continue to rate its performance highly, recently granting it a perfect score of 6 out of 6 in their 2025 evaluations, placing it among the world’s best built-in defenses. But does this mean average and advanced users alike can abandon external antivirus solutions? The reality is more nuanced, demanding close attention for anyone serious about digital safety on Windows 11.

Microsoft Defender: More Than “Good Enough” for Most​

Modern Windows 11 installations come pre-equipped with a suite of real-time threat protection measures: Microsoft Defender antivirus, firewall tools, SmartScreen filters, and built-in disk encryption through BitLocker. For most consumers, this arsenal delivers a strong baseline of security at no extra cost or configuration. The Defender suite now rivals long-standing industry leaders in independent tests, as verified by multiple sources including AV-Test and AV-Comparatives. Its ability to block known malware, detect zero-day exploits, and shield against phishing attacks is, by most metrics, world-class.

Key Security Features Included with Windows 11​

• Real-time Threat Protection: Defender actively scans files, programs, and processes for suspicious behavior the moment they run.
• Firewall and Network Protection: The advanced Windows Firewall monitors both incoming and outgoing connections, controlling access and alerting users to suspicious network activity.
• SmartScreen Filtering: This web protection tool warns against suspicious downloads and malicious websites, providing another essential layer of defense, especially effective with Microsoft Edge.
• BitLocker Encryption: Available on Pro and Enterprise editions, this feature helps secure your data in the event of loss or theft by fully encrypting disks.
• Exploit Protection: Integrated anti-exploit technology defends against sophisticated attacks that seek to exploit vulnerabilities at a system level.

These features, combined with an operating system engineered for automatic updates, make Windows 11 one of the safest consumer OS releases to date. For users whose primary activities involve browsing reputable websites, consuming media, and performing standard office tasks, Windows Security often suffices.

Why the Case for Extra Antivirus Still Matters​

Despite Microsoft’s achievements, there’s broad consensus among security professionals and independent reviewers that adding third-party antivirus to Windows 11 continues to have merit—particularly for individuals handling sensitive information, engaging in higher-risk behaviors, or seeking greater peace of mind.

The Limits of Microsoft Defender​

While Defender scores well in lab tests, several limitations remain:

• Feature Gaps Across Browsers: Some key protections—like SmartScreen filtering—are tightly integrated with Microsoft Edge, leaving Chrome, Firefox, and other browsers with less robust defense by default.
• Proactive Protection: Advanced third-party antivirus suites tend to offer more aggressive and proactive scanning, sometimes detecting emerging threats faster thanks to larger threat intelligence networks.
• Comprehensive Coverage: Many third-party solutions protect against a broader spectrum of dangers, including ransomware, stalkerware, adware, and phishing via social media or messaging apps. Defender’s coverage, though broad, can occasionally lag behind these categories.
• Supplementary Tools: Paid antiviruses frequently include password managers, VPN services, parental controls, and identity theft monitoring—features absent in Windows’ built-in suite.
• Support and Remediation: Vendors like Norton, Bitdefender, and Kaspersky provide specialized remediation tools and live technical support, invaluable during and after an infection.

Sensitive Data and High-Risk Use Cases​

Anyone who stores client records, financial information, intellectual property, or regulated data (such as health or legal documents) on their Windows 11 machine should seriously consider supplementary antivirus protection. Many regulatory standards (GDPR, HIPAA, PCI DSS) either strongly recommend or legally require a multilayered security approach, for which commercial antivirus often forms a critical part.

Real-World Threats: Where Windows Security Alone May Not Suffice​

The contemporary malware landscape is fast-moving and sophisticated. Attackers leverage zero-day vulnerabilities, socially engineered emails, malicious advertising, and even supply-chain attacks to compromise unsuspecting users.

Popular Threat Vectors Targeting Windows 11​

• Phishing Attacks: While SmartScreen guards against many phishing sites, campaigns delivered through non-browser channels (such as email clients or messaging apps) may bypass integrated defenses.
• Ransomware: Dedicated ransomware shields found in premium antivirus products often monitor for suspicious file-access patterns, enabling earlier detection and mitigation than Defender.
• Unpatched Vulnerabilities: Third-party suites sometimes offer vulnerability scanning for outdated software, alerting users to risks before a patch is available or installed through Windows Update.
• Advanced Persistent Threats (APTs): For business and government users, third-party enterprise antivirus may deliver endpoint detection and response (EDR) features, behavioral analytics, and custom threat intelligence feeds.

Independent testing organizations routinely simulate these attacks to assess response times and detection accuracy. Though Defender performs admirably, market leaders like Bitdefender, Kaspersky, and Norton typically detect slightly more zero-day malware and unknown threats, thanks partly to their worldwide install bases and rapid response infrastructure.

AV-Test and the 2025 Evaluations​

According to the latest AV-Test reports, Microsoft Defender achieved a rare perfect score for protection, performance, and usability, matching or beating much of the competition. AV-Comparatives and SE Labs results echo this positive trend—Defender is now a mature, top-tier option for consumers. However, even the labs caution that no product is infallible and that combining layers of protection reduces risk.

Side-by-Side: Defender versus Leading Third-Party AV Suites​

Feature/Capability	Microsoft Defender	Avast/AVG/Norton	Bitdefender/Kaspersky
Real-time malware protection	Yes	Yes	Yes
Ransomware shield	Basic	Advanced	Advanced
Phishing/email scans (non-Edge)	Limited	Full	Full
Web protection (all browsers)	Limited	Yes	Yes
Vulnerability scanning	No	Yes	Yes
Parental controls	Limited	Yes (paid)	Yes (paid)
VPN included	No	Yes (paid)	Yes (paid)
Identity Theft Monitoring	No	Yes (paid)	Yes (paid)
Customer Support	Microsoft only	Vendor support	Vendor support

This table, built by cross-referencing vendor documentation and lab tests, shows how paid solutions go beyond the basics.

Balancing Performance, Privacy, and Protection​

Running both Defender and a reputable third-party antivirus simultaneously is possible, but doing so can impact system resources and sometimes lead to software conflicts. Most modern products detect the presence of Defender and take steps to disable or supplement it accordingly, but testing before full deployment is wise—especially for older hardware.
Privacy considerations are also worth weighing. Some third-party antiviruses, particularly free versions, have been found to collect user browsing data or inject ads. Always opt for products from established vendors with transparent privacy policies and regular third-party audits.

When Does Built-in Protection Truly Suffice?​

For users with basic requirements—those who stick to the Microsoft Store or official development channels, browse primarily with Edge, and avoid downloading unknown files or clicking suspicious links—the bundled protection within Windows 11 delivers robust security. Microsoft updates threat definitions multiple times a day and responds quickly to new vulnerabilities, often faster than some third-party competitors for Windows-specific bugs.
Windows 11’s hardware requirements, notably the demand for TPM 2.0 and Secure Boot, further raise the baseline for malware to gain a foothold. Combined with safe browsing habits, regular updates, and a good backup strategy, Microsoft Defender will protect the vast majority of home and small office users from catastrophe.
Yet as soon as your risk profile increases—through the use of alternative browsers, managing sensitive work, accessing public Wi-Fi, or sharing a computer with less-experienced users—the case for extra protection becomes far more compelling.

Critical Analysis: The Strengths and Risks of Sole Reliance​

It is true that antivirus fatigue is a real concern. Users are bombarded with warnings, upsells, and conflicting advice. The good news is that, for the first time in Windows history, the path of least resistance (using built-in tools) is also among the safest. Defender’s integration means fewer pop-ups, automatic updates, and clean performance monitoring via the Windows Security dashboard.
However, putting all your faith in a single vendor—even one as committed as Microsoft—creates a risk of catastrophic failures if a vulnerability escapes their notice. This “monoculture problem” is why experts still recommend layered defense: different AV engines may flag different threats, reducing the overall risk profile.

Notable Strengths of Third-Party Antivirus​

• Proactive, Multi-Layered Protection: Many contenders use AI-driven behavioral analytics, cloud scanning, and dedicated ransomware shields.
• Cross-Platform Benefits: Some suites protect your mobile devices and Macs under the same subscription, with a unified dashboard for alerts and management.
• Extra Utilities: The appeal of bundled VPNs, password vaults, and encrypted cloud backups is hard to ignore, especially for power users and families.
• Professional Incident Response: Businesses and those with critical data benefit from access to real human help and recovery expertise in the aftermath of an attack.

Potential Risks of Third-Party Antivirus​

• Software Conflicts: Overlapping drivers and scanning engines can cause glitches, slowdowns, or (rarely) system crashes.
• False Positives: Aggressive heuristic scans sometimes mistake new, legitimate software for threats, resulting in files being quarantined or deleted erroneously.
• Privacy Trade-offs: Some vendors have been caught selling user data or injecting scripts into web content; transparency varies widely.
• Cost: Premium subscriptions can add up, and free options are increasingly ad-supported or restricted in features.

How to Choose: A Tailored Approach to Security​

The optimal strategy isn’t about blind faith in Windows Security or fear-driven adoption of third-party tools—it’s about understanding your unique risk profile.
If you are:

• A home user with simple browsing habits and nothing irreplaceable stored on your PC: Stick with Windows Defender, enable automatic updates, use Edge when possible, and be vigilant about email and downloads.
• A business user, freelancer, or someone who deals in sensitive information: Strongly consider upgrading to a trusted paid solution, with robust ransomware, phishing, and identity theft protection built in.
• An advanced user or IT professional: Consider a layered approach—Defender plus a lightweight on-demand scanner (like Malwarebytes), combined with strict browser security extensions and a good backup routine.

Final Thoughts: The Antivirus Debate in 2025​

The progress Microsoft has made with Defender and Windows Security is undeniably significant. For the first time, most Windows 11 users can rest easy with the out-of-box experience. But against a backdrop of rapidly evolving threats, sophisticated ransomware, and targeted attacks, expertise and vigilance remain essential.
No security suite—no matter how sophisticated—can remove all risk. The rise of fileless malware, social engineering, and supply-chain compromises means there will always be gaps even in the best-protected systems. Human factors, like falling for a well-crafted phishing email, still represent the biggest threat vector of all.
Thus, continuing to use antivirus on Windows 11 is about more than just scanning for viruses; it’s about defense in depth, risk management, and, above all, adapting your tools to your real needs. Whether you ultimately rely on built-in safeguards or a premium suite, ongoing education, routine backups, and a healthy suspicion of the unfamiliar will continue to be your best security investments—now and in the years ahead.

---

Source: SlashGear The Main Reasons Why You Should Still Use Antivirus On Windows 11 - SlashGear